This paper examines a managerial conflict at Hardee Transportation involving truck drivers, customers, and the sales team in the wake of new hours-of-service (HOS) regulations. The new rules reduce actual driving time by including non-driving duties such as pickup and delivery (PUD) within regulated hours, cutting driver earnings and potentially encouraging unsafe driving behavior. At the same time, customers expect full service flexibility, and the sales team warns that imposing restrictions could drive clients to competitors. The paper recommends open communication with all stakeholders and a revised pricing model that compensates drivers for non-driving work without alienating customers.
Hardee Transportation's management faces a fundamental conflict among its customers, driver employees, and sales team. This is a significantly difficult management challenge, because all the parties involved are vital to the company's survival. The solution should therefore be constructed in a way that creates the best possible outcome for everyone involved. The best way to accomplish this is to examine the issues and information at hand, arrive at a suitable compromise, and carefully consider each stakeholder's point of view.
From the truckers' point of view, the new hours-of-service (HOS) regulations reduce actual driving time because they include non-driving duties such as pickup and delivery (PUD) within the regulated hours. For customers with long PUD times, this results in lower wages for truck drivers, who are typically paid only per mile driven. Non-driving work is generally unpaid work. As a result, truck drivers facing long PUD times are likely to increase their driving hours in order to make ends meet. This creates a dangerous situation in which driver fatigue could lead to accidents, ultimately harming the reputation of the company.
This is not a groundless concern. According to Hokey (2009), HOS rule violations are on the rise. Inadequate driver compensation resulting from fewer regulated hours on the road could, paradoxically, create a situation in which drivers are more likely to fall asleep at the wheel. Management's task in this regard is therefore to establish open communication with drivers in order to determine their needs for compensation with respect to non-driving time.
From the customers' point of view, meeting customer demand is generally the best way to build a sound reputation and secure repeat business. The sales team makes a strong point in this regard. If customers were required to reduce their PUD times in order to retain the driving service, they would likely seek another provider willing and able to meet their requirements. In the current economic environment, losing established clients is something no company can afford. The customers and the sales team therefore represent the revenue-generating side of the Hardee business, and their concerns deserve equal weight in any management decision.
"Why satisfying both drivers and customers is essential"
"Communication plan and revised PUD-based pricing model"
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.