This paper examines the evolving landscape of nursing leadership, with a focus on the Clinical Nurse Leader (CNL) — a credentialed role created by the American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN) to address medical errors and rising costs in hospital settings. Drawing on Marie Manthey's foundational framework for nursing care delivery systems, the paper explores the CNL's management responsibilities, fiscal stewardship duties, and microsystem-level practice. It also discusses transformational leadership as an effective style for nursing, communication strategies enabled by emerging technologies, and the ongoing challenges of role definition, overlap with other advanced practice roles, and conflict management facing new CNL graduates.
As nursing has moved toward professionalization, roles for nurses in leadership positions have been created. Historically, the roles of charge nurse, nurse manager, nurse educator, and nurse leader have existed to coordinate and improve care delivery. In recent times, advanced practice nursing education has been introduced to formalize and improve performance of these roles, ensure evidence-based practice, and improve patient care outcomes. While the presence of clinical nurse specialists (CNSs) and other graduate-prepared nurses has been shown to improve patient outcomes, the persistence of medical errors and cost escalation in hospitals has prompted health care leaders to develop a new role addressing these problems. This nascent, credentialed role — created by the American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN) in consultation with nursing faculty, clinical experts, and other stakeholders — is called a Clinical Nurse Leader (CNL).
The outcome variable of nurse job satisfaction measures the degree to which nursing care delivery systems acknowledge, nurture, and protect the practice of the professional nurse. Common indicators of nurse job satisfaction include the degree of job autonomy, the accountability of the professional nurse, and the presence of meaningful work (Aiken, Clarke, Sloane, Sochalski, & Silber, 2002; Deutschendorf, 2003; Kramer & Schmalenberg, 2002).
Nurses work in several different settings and hold many different job titles, responsibilities, and credentials. As new roles for nurses develop in the health care setting, many nursing professionals describe these innovations in care modalities as nursing care delivery systems. This paper discusses some of the innovations and advancements in health care delivery as evolutionary adaptations of the four basic nursing delivery systems, using Marie Manthey's (1990) definition of a nursing care delivery system. Manthey describes nursing care delivery systems as "a set of concepts defining four basic organizational elements. The definitions of these elements are based on principles that are in turn based on fundamental values. These fundamental values will ultimately determine the quality of the product. These four fundamental values or elements are clinical decision making, work allocation, communication, and management" (Manthey, 1990, p. 203). Marie Manthey's definitions of nursing care delivery systems, published in 1990, remain widely accepted today.
The CNL is not a manager, but is expected to lead in the design and implementation of care and outcome objectives while advocating for the best interests of her patients. As such, she collaborates with other health care providers, patients, family and community members, and must be comfortable delegating — and in many cases, teaching — goals and responsibilities to each. The Clinical Nurse Leader should also be vigilant in anticipating risk for illness or injury to her patient or population, and work to mitigate those risks through coordination of health promotion and illness prevention education (American Association of Colleges of Nursing, 2007).
Good fiscal stewardship is a condition of quality care. The CNL, as a patient manager and care coordinator, cannot overlook the cost of care and must maximize resources using evidence-based practice. Just as the owner of a small business monitors possible cost-reduction actions, the CNL must understand economic influences in the clinical world, be able to balance and monitor financial flows, and possess a working knowledge of marketing and business fundamentals.
An effective leadership style for nursing is transformational leadership, because this style adapts well to the demands of the profession. By positioning the nurse as the leader and the followers as anyone in need of the nurse's services — whether a patient, an organization, or other healthcare professionals — a useful philosophy of nursing practice can be established. Transformational leaders possess: (1) charisma, (2) the ability to inspire and motivate, (3) the ability to provide intellectual stimulation, and (4) the propensity to provide individualized consideration to followers. When applied by the transformational leader, these traits can enhance a follower's sense of self-worth and value, which is particularly important in healthcare practice.
"Technology-enabled communication in CNL practice"
"CNL accountability within small patient microsystems"
"Contested terrain and unresolved role boundaries"
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.