This paper examines the role of Advanced Life Support (ALS) within Emergency Medical Services (EMS) through a review of multiple research studies. It covers the definition and scope of ALS, its application in trauma care in rural West Virginia, pediatric pre-hospital care in South Africa, and a comparative analysis of the Franco-German and Anglo-American EMS models. The paper also addresses the cost-effectiveness of ALS in cardiac arrest treatment and the broader question of whether ALS consistently produces better patient outcomes than Basic Life Support. Collectively, the studies highlight the complexity of deploying ALS across diverse geographic, economic, and political contexts worldwide.
Advanced Life Support (ALS) represents a complex collection of rules and procedures extending beyond elementary life support, further aiding ailing or injured individuals in clearing their airway, supporting breathing, and ensuring air circulates throughout the body, thereby supporting blood circulation under emergency circumstances (Advanced Life Support [Definition and Explanation], 2016). The following individuals commonly require ALS transport (Lifeline: Basic and Advanced Life Support, 2016):
Surgical or medical patients receiving ongoing intravenous medication but not requiring a Registered Nurse, in keeping with state regulations. Individuals with a cardiac monitor attached. Urgent care center patients. Patients suffering from a possible airway compromise. Obstetrical patients. Patients considered to have a possible complication in the course of transport, as indicated by a report forwarded by the sending healthcare facility.
Whiteman, C., Shaver, E., Doerr, R., Davis, S., Blum, F., Davidov, D., & Lander, O. (2014). Trauma patient access: the role of the emergency medical services system in North-Central West Virginia. The West Virginia Medical Journal.
Individuals suffering from trauma encounter a number of impediments when attempting to access North-Central West Virginia's healthcare system. The authors of this paper identify and discuss key hurdles, as well as legislative and administrative programs that could help mitigate the inequalities encountered by rural trauma patients.
The research adopted an observational, reflective design and employed data drawn from a university Medcom Database. EMS calls linked to trauma between 2002 and 2011 were analyzed to determine several EMS care parameters within the Medcom catchment area. A total of 54,952 trauma-linked EMS patients were studied to establish estimated arrival time (ETA) at the destination healthcare facility, trauma activation conditions, EMS response level, and transport time and date, among other variables.
Observations and Conclusion: The average emergency transport ETA overall was 11.7 minutes; the average for Pendleton County — the most remote county — was 28.4 minutes. Basic life support providers handled approximately 23% of calls, while advanced life support personnel handled the remaining 76%. Thirty percent of emergency transports met West Virginia's trauma activation criteria. Advanced life support personnel and basic life support personnel transported 78% and 19% of traumatic patients, respectively.
The state's north-central region presents numerous barriers to trauma patient care, including lengthy transport durations, roughly half of the counties lacking a hospital altogether or having one with limited capacity to care for trauma-related EMS patients, and limited capabilities among responding EMS teams (Whiteman et al., 2014).
Anest, T., Ramirez, S., Balhara, K., Hodkinson, P., Wallis, L., & Hansoti, B. (2016). Defining and improving the role of emergency medical services in Cape Town, South Africa. Emergency Medical Journal.
Underdeveloped and developing nations bear a disproportionately heavy burden of child mortality and morbidity (under 18 years of age). South Africa, as a developing nation, suffers an excessively high mortality rate among children under five years old. Several factors contributing to child mortality are time-sensitive and require access to competent emergency care. Obstacles and delays in EMS delivery cause increases in pediatric mortality and morbidity from time-sensitive conditions.
This research took the form of a qualitative assessment of pre-hospital care for patients under 18 years of age in Cape Town, a major South African city. A purposive sample of healthcare workers who participated in or interacted with Cape Town's EMS system was interviewed using a structured interview method. Every interview was both audio-recorded and transcribed, and two separate reviewers conducted a blinded content analysis of the transcripts. The journal has been cited in Grant's 2015 work.
Results and Conclusion: Study authors performed thirty-three structured coding sessions over approximately one month. The coding process produced eight general themes: communication, access, infrastructure, equipment, community education, triage, staffing, and training. Researchers used subcategories to identify areas for targeted intervention. An overall agreement rate of 93.36% was found between the two coders (κ-coefficient = 0.69).
Pre-hospital systems are crucial to timely care delivery for pediatric patients with time-sensitive conditions. In this middle-income, single-facility area, obstacles to communication between dispatch workers and EMS providers or healthcare facilities were identified as a priority area for intervention to improve care delivery. Other targeted intervention areas should include training dispatch workers in basic medical terminology and expanding the ALS provider base (Anest et al., 2016).
Page, C., Sbat, M., Vazquez, K., & Yalcin, Z. (2013). Analysis of Emergency Medical Systems Across the World. Worcester: Worcester Polytechnic Institute.
This Interactive Qualifying Project (IQP), centered on the MIRAD Lab, offers a foundational overview of EMS's role in select nations worldwide. The paper summarizes the Franco-German and Anglo-American EMS systems, covering their functions, structure, and regulatory standards of operation. Many nations around the globe have adopted these systems to deliver high-quality care within emergency and pre-hospital settings.
The physician-centered Franco-German model allows EMS personnel and a physician to assess and treat patients experiencing medical emergencies; patients may be transported to a healthcare facility for additional examination if needed. The Anglo-American EMS model, by contrast, relies on ambulances staffed by paramedics and Emergency Medical Technicians (EMTs) trained in basic, intermediate, and advanced life support. These personnel provide pre-hospital patient stabilization, transport to a healthcare facility for further evaluation, and clinical intervention.
The IQP analyzes both models and studies select nations — including the United States, Germany, China, South Africa, Oman, and Portugal — representing diverse geographic, economic, and political backgrounds. The findings give IQP members an opportunity to recognize and understand the social impact of pre-hospital services and the ethical challenges associated with maintaining consistent quality in patient care delivery (Page, Sbat, Vazquez, & Yalcin, 2013).
"Comparison of two dominant international EMS frameworks"
"How nations tailor EMS models to local conditions"
"Cost-effectiveness and survival data for ALS cardiac care"
Ryyanen, O.-P., Iirola, T., Reitala, J., Palve, H., & Malmivarra, A. (2010). Is advanced life support better than basic life support in prehospital care? A systematic review. Scandinavian Journal of Trauma, Resuscitation and Emergency Medicine.
Whiteman, C., Shaver, E., Doerr, R., Davis, S., Blum, F., Davidov, D., & Lander, O. (2014). Trauma patient access: the role of the emergency medical services system in North-Central West Virginia. The West Virginia Medical Journal.
You’re 48% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.