This annotated bibliography surveys fourteen scholarly works addressing two interrelated themes in higher education: academic tenure and organizational effectiveness. Sources examine the historical rationale for tenure, faculty satisfaction, nursing tenure debates, and survey findings on professor attitudes toward tenure policies. Alongside these, a substantial body of sources investigates organizational effectiveness in colleges and universities, exploring Cameron's nine-dimension framework, the role of leadership (including transformational leadership), mission orientation in two-year colleges, cultural complexity, and managerial strategies. Together, the sources offer a comprehensive overview of how institutional leadership, faculty motivation, mission alignment, and governance structures shape the effectiveness and credibility of academic institutions.
Tierney (1996). Tenure and Community in Academe. Educational Researcher, Vol. 26, No. 8.
This article addresses the importance of academic tenure within the academic community. According to the article, tenure carries two specific meanings: it provides liberty in teaching, research, and educational activities, and it creates opportunities for both male and female faculty to utilize their abilities while offering a degree of economic security that increases the credibility of the profession.
The article notes that during the 1960s, students received professional education without significant disruption from radical cultural transformation. They established their educational plans and implemented them within a smooth, well-functioning system. There was also an obligation for institutions to demonstrate good citizenship—achievable through cultural taxation and by fulfilling the basic representational needs of ethnic communities.
Brock & Butts (1998). Tenure: Viable or a Dinosaur. School of Nursing.
This article briefly describes the academic history of tenure and examines the current pros and cons of the tenure system, drawing on both nursing and non-nursing literature. The most significant contemporary challenge is encouraging the nation's colleges and universities to explore more creative ways to analyze intellectual academic work and understand its relationship to promotion and tenure guidelines. The paper presents criticisms and arguments about tenure, highlights the specific impact of nursing tenure, and offers future recommendations, implications, and solutions for the nursing tenure dilemma.
Cameron (1978). Measuring Organizational Effectiveness in Institutions of Higher Education. Administrative Science Quarterly, Vol. 23, No. 4.
This article examines organizational effectiveness in higher education institutions and highlights the barriers and obstacles that impede it. The obstacles are identified with proper criteria descriptions, and the article briefly describes the distinctive qualities of colleges and universities. Criteria for selecting effective organizational practices are addressed and analyzed. A benchmark was created from leading coalition members across six institutions, and nine dimensions of organizational effectiveness were derived. The reliability and validity of these dimensions were rigorously examined, and evidence for effective dimension configurations was established across all nine dimensions.
Cameron (1986). A Study of Organizational Effectiveness and Its Predictors. Management Science, Vol. 32, No. 1.
This article addresses organizational effectiveness and its predictors. While some authors argue that research on organizational effectiveness should be abandoned, others disagree, and the article explains why organizational effectiveness remains essential in certain types of organizations. The study highlights weaknesses and criticisms of previous research and how those findings were reported. Results show that managerial strategies are directly proportional to strong performance outcomes and improving effectiveness over time across 29 organizations. The study concludes that managerial strategies are more effective determinants than structural, financial, demographic, or other organizational factors.
Walton & Dawson (2001). Managers' Perceptions of Criteria of Organizational Effectiveness. Journal of Management Studies, Vol. 38, Issue 2, pp. 173–200.
This article examines the managerial approach to organizational effectiveness, focusing on how individual and collective knowledge and expertise—overlapping across time and professional contexts—constitute the competencies that drive effectiveness. Competencies are understood as composed of knowledge capital, skills, and behavior. The approach assumes that competencies must be developed before any high-level exploitation of potential can occur, making them sophisticated and inherent tools that professional workers draw upon during the performance of their duties. The article further argues that effectiveness, as an integrated system, is ultimately the responsibility of human resources—individuals and groups—supported by an administrative environment that provides appropriate regulatory structures and incentive systems.
Cameron & Whetten (1996). Organizational Effectiveness and Quality: The Second Generation. Higher Education Handbook of Theory and Research, 11: 265–306.
This article addresses organizational effectiveness and quality measures. It is concerned with the standard of maturity in the use of material, financial, human, and informational resources. Organizations aiming for growth and development must believe in the possibility of a continuing flow of resources in order to function effectively and continuously—particularly given today's environment of resource scarcity. The article argues that organizations must not rely solely on directive approaches to optimization; they must also seek to reconcile their objectives with available human, financial, physical, and informational resources. Setting unrealistic goals relative to available resources leads to severe failures across institutional activities.
Smart (2003). Organizational Effectiveness of 2-Year Colleges. Research in Higher Education, Vol. 44, No. 6.
The main purpose of this article is to analyze whether the perceptions of community college faculty and administrators regarding organizational effectiveness are related to one another. The paper studies the relationships among perceptions, cognitive behavior, organizational culture complexity, and the leadership roles performed by senior managers. Results indicate a strong relationship between perceptions of organizational effectiveness and the level of cultural complexity present on campus. The paper also identifies a strong relationship between organizational effectiveness and the leadership behavior of senior officials, and discusses future implications for educational institutions.
Smart & Hamm (1993). Organizational Effectiveness and Mission Orientations of Two-Year Colleges. Research in Higher Education, Vol. 34, No. 4.
This article analyzes organizational effectiveness in a national sample of two-year colleges by applying Cameron's (1978, 1983) nine dimensions. It also highlights differences across Cameron's nine dimensions for differently mission-oriented colleges. The findings indicate a strong and positive association supporting the nine dimensions of organizational effectiveness and their applicability to two-year colleges. The study strongly recommends that such institutions maintain a firm interdependency with their mission orientation. Mission-oriented two-year colleges were found to have effective management systems and senior institutional officials who successfully implement organizational effectiveness strategies—making such effectiveness a reliable indicator of management practices and institutional performance.
"Academic leadership and faculty motivation links"
"Survey data and arguments for and against tenure"
Taken together, these fourteen sources map the scholarly conversation on tenure and organizational effectiveness in higher education. They reveal that strong leadership, clear mission orientation, and well-structured tenure policies are mutually reinforcing pillars of institutional performance. Cameron's nine-dimension framework, transformational leadership models, and empirical surveys of faculty attitudes collectively offer researchers and policymakers a robust foundation for understanding and improving the effectiveness of academic institutions.
You’re 52% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.