This paper presents two nursing case studies addressing the interconnected challenges of nurse fatigue, inadequate staffing, and human resource management. The first case examines a scenario involving a diabetic patient and a fatigued nurse working an extended shift, using it to explore how understaffing and heavy workloads create patient safety risks and what workload redesign strategies can mitigate those risks. The second case addresses a rural nursing facility facing recruitment difficulties, analyzing incentive-based staffing strategies—including compensation, working conditions, and community benefits—as tools for attracting qualified nurses without adversely affecting current staff morale.
This case outlines a scenario in which the effects of nursing fatigue, coupled with inadequate HR procedures, have led to undesirable patient care outcomes. Mr. Patel, a diabetic patient, is in the process of receiving a routine insulin injection administered by his nurse, Ms. Chang, when an interruption from another patient causes her to step away momentarily before completing the task. The case also notes that Ms. Chang is working an extended shift due to human resource issues at the nursing facility.
Ms. Chang does return to Mr. Patel and administer the injection, so it is not entirely clear to what extent fatigue directly influenced this particular incident. However, regardless of the specific details, nursing fatigue and inadequate staffing are two closely related issues with well-documented consequences for patient safety. The required outcome is a redesigned workload that effectively covers all job requirements without placing undue stress on nurses or patients. The patient's family should also be provided with information about the incident and a clear explanation of how it is being addressed.
Cutting staff is a common practice among nursing facilities attempting to control HR costs and reduce overall healthcare expenditures (Eaton-Spiva, Buitrago, & Trotter, 2010). The resulting problems are well documented: ongoing fatigue, heavy workloads, irregular hours, inadequate staffing levels, and a general feeling of being undervalued all contribute to an extremely stressful work environment. Even so, it has long been recognized that organizations can take meaningful steps to support their staff and mitigate potential risks even when operating with reduced staffing levels (Murphy, 1996).
For example, one study estimated that some nurses spend nearly thirty percent of their time on paperwork alone. Creating systems that allow nurses to address routine administrative requirements more efficiently can have a significant impact on both safety and overall efficiency (Eaton-Spiva, Buitrago, & Trotter, 2010). Redesigning the workload — whether by adding additional employees or by implementing time-saving processes — could therefore help ensure that incidents like the one involving Mr. Patel are less likely to occur in the future.
"Location and incentives shape rural nurse recruitment"
"Working conditions and community benefits attract qualified nurses"
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.