This paper examines how media coverage, particularly Hollywood productions, has negatively influenced public perception of nursing through sensationalized portrayals of professional misconduct and underrepresentation of nurses' actual roles. The author argues that media outlets disproportionately focus on dramatic failures rather than the competent, evidence-based practice of the nursing majority. The paper traces historical depictions from the 1960s through contemporary shows like Nurse Jackie, then proposes solutions including professional educational seminars, literature distribution, and direct patient education by nursing professionals to counter media-driven misconceptions and restore the nursing profession's public image.
It is well documented that the media, particularly Hollywood, is one of the primary avenues through which the general public has become familiar with the role of nurses. This is evident based on numerous healthcare episodes on television, in theatrical productions, and in news coverage. According to Orem, in the early 1960s, nurses were depicted as subordinate to physicians in films and on television. For example, in TV shows such as Dr. Kildare and Ben Casey, nurses were shown delivering messages to doctors, carrying trays, and performing only minimal skill-level tasks. Throughout these shows, doctors were portrayed as condescending toward nurses and constantly depicted as superior.
However, in 1962, a revolutionary TV show emerged that marked a turning point: for the first time, nurses were depicted in a positive and realistic light as objective, articulate, disciplined, and concerned with professional development of themselves and their colleagues. These television programs demonstrated the existence of nursing standards and organization as a respectable profession, offering the public an accurate representation of the field.
Despite this historical progress, the media continues to negatively influence the public image of nursing by repeatedly broadcasting news coverage of nurses who have made mistakes on the job. Unfortunately, these mistakes have sometimes led to detrimental consequences for patients. A prominent example of Hollywood media negatively influencing public perception is the fictional portrayal in the HBO series Nurse Jackie, which depicts a drug-addicted nurse who steals drugs from her facility to support her habit. Such sensationalized representations create lasting negative impressions in the minds of patients and the general public.
It is rare to see news coverage or media representation of hardworking, proficient nurses who effectively perform their jobs while treating patients and assisting physicians. In most healthcare episodes or scenes, nurses are barely featured, while physicians are showcased throughout. The actual scope of nursing practice encompasses critical thinking, decision making, and skillful management of risk, yet the media has focused primarily on the emotional aspects of nursing rather than these essential professional competencies.
If the media were to show coverage of hardworking, capable nurses—which include the vast majority of practicing nurses—it would have a great positive influence on the public's opinion of nurses whose goal is to provide patients with quality care, safety, and healthcare information. The public needs to be educated on the role and scope of nursing and nurses' role in changing the healthcare system. However, there has not been enough done by the media to inform the public on nurses' responsibilities and the scope of their practice, which include critical thinking, decision making, and skillful management of risk; rather, media has focused on the emotional aspect of nursing (Creasia & Friberg, 2011).
Given the media's failure to accurately represent the nursing profession, there are options for nurses to take control of this narrative. One option is for nurses to conduct educational seminars and distribute literature to inform the public about their role and responsibilities. A second and equally crucial option is for nurses to maintain professionalism while caring for their patients. These strategies are important for nursing professionals to pursue independently rather than relying on the media, because some patients have already formed negative impressions based on media portrayals and may initially be skeptical of information provided by nurses themselves.
Personal experience illustrates this challenge. As a nursing professional, I cared for a male patient who was harsh and mean to me, using negative and unprofessional language based on information he had received from the media. However, as a long-time practicing nursing professional committed to patient care, I utilized this opportunity to reeducate the patient on the actual role and perspective of nurses in the healthcare system, countering the misinformation he had received from media sources. This direct interaction allowed me to demonstrate through my professional conduct what the media fails to show: the competence, compassion, and dedication of nursing professionals.
The public needs to be educated on the role and scope of nursing as well as nurses' role in changing the healthcare system. There has not been enough done by the media to inform the public on nurses' roles and their responsibilities, which include critical thinking, decision making, and skillful management of risk. Rather than waiting for the media to reform its portrayal, nursing professionals must take active steps to rebuild public trust through education, professional conduct, and direct engagement with patients and communities. Only through such sustained professional advocacy can the negative stereotypes perpetuated by sensationalized media coverage be overcome, allowing the public to understand and appreciate the true value and expertise of the nursing profession.
You’re 97% through this paper. Sign up to read the full paper.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.