This paper reviews Kevin McCarthy's book on business strategy, which uses stories and anecdotes to illustrate how companies can balance product quality with customer satisfaction. The review traces the book's central argument through its opening story of Fred Taylor, a CEO whose product-focused company declines because it fails to adapt to changing consumer expectations. The paper then examines McCarthy's broader thesis about the evolution of business organizations — from product-based, to customer-based, to a modern fusion of both — and how this shift defines successful 21st-century management.
Kevin McCarthy's book on business discusses how people can effectively run their organizations and generate substantial profits and sales without sacrificing customer satisfaction. Rather than a conventional business manual, the book is structured as a collection of stories and anecdotes that illustrate the various problems and strategies business people commonly encounter. Most of these stories offer readers a view of what it is like to face organizational dilemmas — situations in which managers and owners grow confused about the direction and focus of their companies. McCarthy provides suggested explanations to these problems, embedding his guidance implicitly within the narratives themselves.
The book opens with a chapter entitled "The Interview," in which the author quotes Bill O'Brien, former CEO of the Hanover Insurance Company, at the outset: "There are two fundamentally differing views of human nature and work. The 'objective view' sees work as a source of economic means. The 'subjective view' is concerned with the effects of work on the person. By the end of the 21st century, quality will become commodity, and companies will be distinguished by the wholeness of their people" (McCarthy 21). This quote captures the essence of the entire book, and the story that follows closely mirrors the situation O'Brien describes.
The narrator introduces Fred Taylor, a man who worked his way up in the business world from errand boy to chief executive officer of a successful organization. However, as time passed, the business world changed around him. Where product quality had once been the primary concern of consumers, 21st-century customers began demanding quality service in addition to quality goods. The story even uses a watch as a symbol of these changing times. Rather than adapting, Taylor stubbornly resisted the new trends in business management. Under his leadership, the company "has fallen into a comfort zone" — a consequence of the success achieved in earlier years.
As Taylor continued to fight the changes taking place in business management and organization, his company fell behind. Small, agile business owners — the frontrunners of the new era — outpaced him, while his company's profits, sales, and leadership reputation all declined together. The narrator describes the product-oriented business model that once defined success as "a time when one's character and reputation clearly stood above quarterly earnings and personal fortune, a time when one's life was more than a job and collective status symbols" (McCarthy 24). The customers of today wanted low-priced, high-quality products, and Taylor's company could not deliver on that promise.
"From product-based to customer-based to hybrid models"
"Taylor's repackaging raises prices, exposing the tension"
The evolution and fusion of today's business organization — from a dichotomized model of product and service into a unified approach — is now the universally accepted standard. McCarthy argues throughout his book that focusing on both product quality and consumer satisfaction is what enables businesses to become more profitable and to increase sales. The 21st-century business model is, in this sense, more ideal than its predecessors: product-and-service-based organizations can achieve high profits and increased sales without sacrificing either the quality of their products or the quality of the service they provide to consumers.
You’re 63% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.