Gender Norms and Women's Roles in East Asian History

Introduction

Gender norms are socially constructed and thus change over time. This paper examines East Asian women from ancient times to the contemporary era, tracing the social and ideological construction of womanhood and femininity in pre-19th century East Asian contexts and critically examining the shifts and transformations of women's gender roles. The social and ideological construction of womanhood has varied considerably over the past century.

Filial Piety and Patriarchal Ideology in Pre-19th Century East Asia

In pre-19th century East Asia, women were often considered to occupy a low social status. The most deep-rooted ideologies were primarily sexist in nature and originated from the Confucian era. The concept of "filial piety" was the most dominant form of ideology as it related to women before the 19th century. According to research conducted by Bauer and Wang, filial piety as practiced before the 19th century was based on three core tenets (Bauer, 1992). The first tenet held that women must obey men at all times, irrespective of whether this behavior could adversely impact a woman or her standing in society. The second required that citizens obey their ruler, and the third that the young obey the elderly.

For thousands of years prior to the 19th century, these three tenets helped maintain a patriarchal structure in which women were primarily subordinated to men. This arrangement led to widespread abuses on the part of men, including the buying and selling of women as property, the beating of women, and even the practice of female infanticide.

Foot-Binding and the Physical Control of Women

The most brutal of customary practices was foot-binding. In East Asia, women with small feet were often considered beautiful. As a result, many Asian communities engaged in the practice of foot-binding, in which the toes of young girls were forcibly bent under the bottom of the foot. The feet remained bound for the rest of a woman's life, eventually resulting in permanent deformity. Unable to walk properly, most women were confined to the home environment, creating still further dependence on men.

The Reformist Movement and Western Influence

Gender norms in East Asia gradually improved over time. These shifts and transformations were, ironically, often initiated by men seeking to improve the standing of women in society. For example, the practice of foot-binding discussed above was eventually outlawed during the Qing Dynasty in China. Other East Asian countries soon followed, marking the first step toward gender equality in the region.

The reformist movement of the 19th century allowed women's initiatives to enter the forefront of male-dominated leadership for the first time. Western ideals began to permeate throughout East Asia during this period, and many of these ideals created a movement toward more equitable gender norms. Elements such as democratic social systems, family dynamics, and marriage customs began to influence East Asian culture. The most notable changes for women included the idea of equality between men and women, the freedom to choose one's own spouse, heightened educational opportunities for women, and the ability to participate in the labor market. All of these rights, prior to the reformist movement, had been heavily discouraged and often resulted in severe punishment for those who advocated them.

Conclusion

The law established in 1949 would essentially abolish many elements of the feudal system and allow women to enjoy rights and privileges equal to those of men. This brought about a fundamental transformation of gender roles, enabling women to enter the workforce, obtain higher levels of education, and ultimately compete with their male counterparts within society.

The trajectory of gender norms in East Asia illustrates how deeply entrenched ideological systems can be challenged and reformed over time. From the Confucian doctrine of filial piety and the physical subjugation enforced by foot-binding, to the legal equality enshrined in 1949, women in East Asia experienced a profound reordering of their social, familial, and civic roles. These changes were not inevitable but were the product of sustained intellectual, political, and feminist activism across multiple generations.

Bauer, John, Wang Feng, Nancy E. Riley, and Zhao Xiaohua. 1992. "Gender Inequality in Urban China, Education and Employment." Modern China, Vol. 18, No. 3 (July 1992): 333–370.

Hooper, Beverley. 1991. "Gender and Education." Pp. 352–74 in Chinese Education: Problems, Policies, and Prospects, edited by Irving Epstein. New York: Garland Publishing, Inc.

Wang, Zheng. 1997. "Maoism, Feminism, and the UN Conference on Women: Women's Studies Research in Contemporary China." Journal of Women's History, v8, n4, pp. 126–53.