This paper presents a book review of Doug Macdougall's Nature's Clocks: How Scientists Measure the Age of Almost Everything (2008). The review examines Macdougall's thesis that modern dating techniques — including radiocarbon dating and related methods — allow scientists to determine the age of objects spanning thousands to billions of years with remarkable accuracy. The paper evaluates the author's use of sources, his narrative style, and his ability to make a technically demanding subject accessible to general readers. Key topics include the history and limitations of radiocarbon dating, its broader impact across scientific disciplines, and Macdougall's use of storytelling devices such as the Alpine Iceman to engage readers before introducing more complex material.
This paper presents a book review of Nature's Clocks: How Scientists Measure the Age of Almost Everything by Doug Macdougall. Macdougall is a former professor and scholar who studies age and time. In the book, he discusses radiocarbon dating and other forms of scientific dating, illustrating how scientists attempt to determine the age of virtually all things in the universe.
Readers often hear about scientists dating items to thousands of years in the past, but few pause to consider how those scientists arrive at their findings. This book clears that up, making the ability to date objects both more amazing and more understandable at the same time. Macdougall writes, "But a plethora of such methods now exists, capable of working out the timing of things that happened thousands or millions or even billions of years ago with a high degree of accuracy" (Macdougall 4). This prompts the reader to wonder how these methods were first discovered and how scientists know they are so accurate. There must be benchmarks against which measurements are verified, and uncovering those benchmarks is at the heart of the book's thesis.
The author offers a concise history of radiocarbon dating — from the circumstances that led to its development to the individuals who discovered and refined it. What could easily become tedious is made engaging because Macdougall presents the inventors as real people driven by remarkable ideas. One particularly illuminating detail is that radiocarbon dating can only be used on material that was once alive; it does not work on inanimate objects such as rocks. This was a surprising and enlightening revelation, as many readers assume the method can be applied to almost anything. Macdougall also demonstrates clearly how the development of radiometric dating techniques transformed science far beyond archaeology and geology, influencing many other disciplines and helping researchers draw conclusions about the Earth, the universe, and their ongoing evolution. It also helped lead to more accurate dating of inanimate objects like rocks, allowing scientists to narrow down the age of the Earth and trace how it has changed through time.
"Macdougall's sourcing, narrative hooks, and readability"
Macdougall, Doug. Nature's Clocks: How Scientists Measure the Age of Almost Everything. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 2008.
You’re 57% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.