Essay Undergraduate 489 words

Comparing Expository Essays: Fish Cleaning vs. Art of Cookery

~3 min read

Abstract

This paper compares two expository essays — Poyssick's guide on cleaning a fish and an excerpt from "The Art of Cookery" on hosting a dinner — by examining their shared rhetorical purpose, organizational strategies, and audience awareness. The analysis finds that both essays aim to inform rather than persuade, and both employ informative process as a development method. However, they differ in primary organization: Poyssick structures his essay by topic, while "The Art of Cookery" follows a time-order sequence of numbered maxims. The paper evaluates the effectiveness of each writer's choices and concludes with a comparative summary of their similarities and differences.

📝 How to Write This Type of Paper Writing guide — click to expand

▼

What makes this paper effective

The paper applies consistent analytical categories — rhetorical purpose, organizational method, and audience awareness — to both texts, giving the comparison a clear evaluative framework.
It avoids mere description by evaluating why each author's organizational choice was appropriate for their subject and audience, adding critical depth.
The conclusion effectively synthesizes both similarities and differences, reinforcing the comparative structure maintained throughout.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper demonstrates the point-by-point comparison technique, analyzing both texts against the same criteria in each section rather than treating each essay in isolation. This method keeps the argument focused and prevents the analysis from becoming a series of disconnected summaries.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens by establishing the shared rhetorical category (expository), then examines each essay's primary and secondary organizational methods, evaluates the effectiveness of those choices, and closes with a comparative summary. This four-part structure moves logically from classification to analysis to evaluation to synthesis, a pattern well suited to comparative literary analysis at the undergraduate level.

Rhetorical Purpose of Both Essays

The art of having a guest over for dinner and the various ways to clean a fish are two topics that both lend themselves to expository writing. Both essays provide step-by-step examples to explain the process of these events. As a result, both are expository in nature. Their rhetorical purpose is not to persuade, but simply to inform — relying on fact rather than opinion.

Organizational Methods and Development

Poyssick's article is organized primarily by topic. At the beginning of his essay, he points out that three main ways exist to clean a fish, and he organizes the entire piece around these topics. Within this structure, Poyssick also uses informative process to explain to the reader how he or she might replicate what is described in each topic.

Unlike Poyssick's essay, The Art of Cookery is developed using primarily time order. This can be observed in the numbered sentences that make up the essay. The author moves from preparations before the meal — such as choosing the tablecloth — to the end of the meal and clearing the dishes. A secondary method of development is informative process, which the author uses to explain to the reader how to achieve a specific outcome.

2 Locked Sections · 225 words remaining

Evaluating Each Author's Structural Choices · 115 words

"Effectiveness of each author's organizational decisions"

Similarities and Differences Between the Essays · 110 words

"Final comparative summary of both essays"

You’re 40% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.

130,000+ paper examples AI writing assistant Citation generator Cancel anytime

Key Concepts in This Paper

Expository Writing Rhetorical Purpose Topic Organization Time Order Informative Process Audience Awareness How-To Essay Essay Comparison Organizational Strategy