This paper examines conformity and social influence through the case of Sarah, a student new to American high school who adopts the behaviors and values of Lisa, a popular peer. The analysis explores informational and normative social influence, the distinction between public compliance and private internalization, and how authority and social status drive conformity. The paper demonstrates how ambiguous social situations, the need for acceptance, and perceived expertise combine to create lasting behavioral and attitudinal change, illustrating the powerful and often invisible mechanisms through which peer groups shape individual identity.
Sarah has recently moved to Boston after growing up in Africa and being home schooled. She is beginning high school and has no idea how to behave or what the social norms are within the structure of her new high school. She is a pretty girl and is quickly noticed by Lisa, the most popular girl in school, who is two years older than her and controls the school's social scene. Sarah looks to Lisa in order to learn about how she is supposed to act, quickly conforming to Lisa's behaviors due to informational social influence and also due to normative social influence, as Lisa is Sarah's only friend. She wants to be accepted by Lisa, and she also has no idea how to act in high school. Her need for acceptance increases her conformity due to the ambiguous nature of her situation.
Sarah's conformity stems from two distinct sources of social influence. Informational social influence occurs because Sarah genuinely lacks knowledge about high school culture. She grew up in Africa, was home schooled, and has never experienced American high school social structures. When Lisa tells Sarah that taking physics will immediately make her a nerd and ruin her social reputation, Sarah is quick to abandon her lifelong pursuit of science in order to fit in with her new friends. Sarah comes to tease and make fun of those who take physics, despite her previous interest in the subject herself.
Normative social influence also plays a crucial role in Sarah's conformity. She wants to be liked and accepted, and Lisa is her only friend. This need for acceptance drives her to adopt Lisa's behaviors, beliefs, and values. Sarah intentionally changes her behavior due to the explicit social norms dictated by Lisa, but also due to the implicit social norms that she picks up from those around her, such as the implied seating arrangement in the school cafeteria. Both types of influence operate simultaneously, reinforcing each other and strengthening Sarah's conformity to Lisa's expectations.
Within her popular inner circles, Lisa is in charge and is effectively the leader that everyone follows. Sarah interprets Lisa's authority as a form of power, making her even more likely to obey Lisa's rules for behavior. Lisa's power comes from her social status and the fact that people around her view her as an expert on how to behave and what is socially acceptable. Conformity to authority figures is a well-documented phenomenon in social psychology, and in Sarah's case, Lisa functions both as an expert and as an authority figure she is supposed to obey.
Sarah's obedience to Lisa is the result of Lisa's power and Sarah's inexperience with social situations such as high school. Sarah believes that Lisa's behavior is the right way to act and that Lisa knows the unwritten rules of American high school culture. The peer pressure and need for acceptance felt by teenagers drives the conformity to Lisa's behavior and expectations. Sarah does not know any other way of behaving and thinks that this is the accepted and correct way to behave in American high schools.
Sarah's behavioral change began as public compliance. She dressed and acted the way Lisa told her to when she was around Lisa and her friends at school, but remained herself at home. Over time, however, her behavior shifted from superficial compliance to deeper internalization. She came to degrade her parents for their study of physics and internalized the thinking of Lisa that science was not for people like her. This represents a shift from mere public compliance to internalization or conversion, as Sarah began to change her private behavior and her thinking about science, bringing her behavior in line with Lisa's even when not in Lisa's presence.
This progression is significant because it shows how temporary public compliance can become lasting private belief. Sarah no longer simply acts the way Lisa wants her to act; she now believes the way Lisa believes. Her values have shifted. Her sense of self has been reshaped by her social environment. The distinction between public compliance and private acceptance is crucial for understanding how conformity becomes internalized and how it persists beyond the immediate social pressure that created it.
"Synthesis of how conformity persists through internalization and social structures"
You’re 75% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.