This paper offers a comparative literary analysis of two short stories by Shirley Jackson: "The Lottery" and "The Villager." The essay examines how the two works share key literary elements, including setting, plot structure, character parallels, thematic concerns, and the use of metaphor and symbolism. By tracing similarities between characters such as Mr. Summers and Hilda Clarence, and comparing the mysterious, ritual-laden plots of both stories, the paper argues that these works collectively demonstrate Jackson's mastery of the uncanny and her ability to expose the darkness lurking within ordinary social conventions.
In the short stories The Lottery and The Villager by American author Shirley Jackson — best known for her novel The Haunting of Hill House — the reader can easily see that these two stories have much in common, especially regarding their settings, plots, characters, themes, metaphor, and use of symbolism. Thus, The Lottery and The Villager demonstrate Jackson's ability to tell a story steeped in the weird and the unknown, two traits that make her one of the best short story writers of the twentieth century.
In The Lottery, the setting is a village located somewhere in New England — a prime location for the strange events of the story. The main character, Mr. Summers, known by the villagers as the "conductor" of the lottery, is described as a "round-faced, jovial man" in the coal business who accepts the sympathies of the villagers due to being childless and having a wife who constantly scolds him (292). Mr. Summers is also the main practitioner of the mysterious lottery and is obviously very knowledgeable about this odd practice, as evidenced by his insistence that every year a new box must be constructed to hold the slips of paper bearing the names of all the villagers.
This serves as the main plotline of the story and symbolizes the strange traditions carried on within this unnamed village — a place filled with old superstitions and myth.
Thematically, Jackson attempts to convey the idea that Mr. Summers and the villagers are still living in the "Dark Ages" as practitioners of some ancient ritual far beyond the bounds of "normal" society. After reading The Lottery, one might ask why Mr. Summers and his fellow villagers continue to practice such a strange ritual. The lottery may stand as a cultural metaphor, one that expresses the dominance of evil over good for the perceived benefit of the community.
In The Villager, literary devices similar to those in The Lottery are easily recognized and serve essentially the same purposes. There are also clear similarities in character, setting, plot, theme, and the use of metaphor and symbolism. For example, the setting of the story is another village — namely, Greenwich Village in New York City — where the main character, Hilda Clarence, works "as a stenographer in a coal and coke concern" (49), an occupation strikingly similar to Mr. Summers's coal business in The Lottery. Ms. Clarence also refers to herself as a "Village die-hard" (49–50), a description close to what the villagers in The Lottery represent.
"Mr. Harris, moral ambiguity, and character comparisons"
Overall, these stories contain powerful ritual images — Mr. Summers directing the lottery, and Ms. Clarence conducting her ritualistic survey of everything in the apartment, much like someone presiding over a mysterious rite of passage. Together, the two works confirm Jackson's mastery of the uncanny and her ability to embed deeply unsettling social commentary within the fabric of everyday life.
Jackson, Shirley. The Lottery and Other Stories. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 1982.
You’re 71% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.