This paper presents two discussion responses examining themes of employee motivation and recognition, drawing on insights from The Enthusiastic Employee: How Companies Profit by Giving and The One Minute Manager. The first response explores how workplace environments can inadvertently reward counterproductive behavior, undermining organizational cohesion. The second challenges the notion that personal recognition is unimportant to employees and argues for both intrinsic and extrinsic motivation. The paper also evaluates the One Minute Manager's three-part framework — goal setting, praise, and reprimand — as a comprehensive but interdependent approach to effective management.
The confusion around the terms "motivation" and "recognition" may arise from the very specific way in which they are used in a workplace context. While it is true that children may act out to obtain negative recognition, this is far rarer among employees — or at least less pronounced — because workers face the practical pressure of earning a paycheck. However, workplaces can sometimes unintentionally reward asocial employee behavior, thereby motivating workers to continue undermining overall productivity. A highly competitive workplace, for example, may have a policy of praising extremely cutthroat employees and awarding them bonuses. Ultimately, this approach erodes a cohesive sense of organizational mission and cultivates a workforce that pursues individual interests rather than the interests of the company.
The assertion that employees do not care about being personally recognized by a company deserves challenge. Many people receive adequate salaries yet remain deeply unhappy in their positions because they are poorly treated by supervisors, personally demeaned, and given few responsibilities that make meaningful use of their creative intelligence. Quite simply, good employees will not want to remain in an environment where they are not valued. Recognition does not need to be bestowed in a formal manner through tangible awards. It can come through praise, respectful consideration of employee suggestions, and treating all members of the organizational hierarchy as valued contributors.
"Limits of financial rewards and the role of intrinsic motivation"
"One Minute Manager framework as interdependent management tools"
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.