This essay examines two poems by John Donne—"Song" and "The Indifferent"—to understand how literature reflects the relationship between the individual, faith, and society in the 17th century. While both poems center on the theme of finding love, they present contrasting perspectives: "Song" portrays an optimistic, persistent search for romantic connection, whereas "The Indifferent" depicts a narrator who feigns indifference toward love. Through textual analysis, the paper argues that Donne uses these contrasting personas to express how 17th-century society prioritized marriage and procreation, often at the expense of deeper spiritual concerns. The essay concludes that Donne's work reveals a cultural moment in which romantic partnership was viewed as necessary for social stability, while faith remained secondary.
Every piece of literature throughout the ages relates to the individual, faith, and society at the time. In the 17th century, John Donne was a well-known poet who had significant influence on both his contemporary society and modern readers. His two works "Song" and "The Indifferent" are excellent examples of how deeply these concerns shape the world itself.
The poem "Song" by Donne is unique in both its form and meaning. The nature of the individual is particularly interesting in this poem because the narrator seems lost in imagination, fantasizing about having a wife and bearing children. The narrator appears to be single and searching for someone special, yet he is not optimistic that he will find one. The reader gathers this impression from the final lines of the poem: "Though she were true when you met her, / And last till you write your letter, yet she / will be / False ere I come, to two, or three" (Donne, 1633, p. 605). This closing suggests that the fundamental nature of the individual in this poem is pessimistic—resigned to betrayal even before the search begins.
In the poem "The Indifferent," also by Donne, the narrator adopts what appears to be the conventional poetic form of the time. As the title suggests, throughout the poem the individual maintains an attitude of indifference toward love. Like the narrator in "Song," this persona is also searching for love, but attempts to mask that desire by feigning indifference. Donne establishes this stance at the beginning, presenting a narrator who claims he could love almost anyone. However, because he appears not to care, he invests no genuine effort into romantic pursuit. This attitude is conveyed through the lines: "Poor heretics in love there be, / Which think to 'stablish dangerous constancy" (Donne, 1633, p. 607). This passage suggests that the narrator views those who fall deeply in love with pity, regarding their devotion as foolish given the inherent dangers of romantic commitment.
Both poems share the central theme of finding love, yet they present two distinctly different perspectives on that pursuit. Remarkably, both are authored by Donne, yet they portray contrasting emotional positions. In "Song," Donne's narrator appears determined and persistent in the search for love, though tempered by deep doubt. In "The Indifferent," by contrast, Donne presents a narrator who seems entirely detached from the outcome—someone who claims love is beneath serious consideration. This divergence reflects the complexity of 17th-century attitudes toward marriage and romance. In one mode, finding love is portrayed as vital and consuming; in the other, it is trivialized and dismissed. The poems suggest that 17th-century society held conflicting views: marriage was an imperative, yet genuine emotional investment was regarded with suspicion or irony.
"Love prioritized over spiritual and religious concerns"
Love is the dominant focus in both pieces, and Donne does not appear to integrate faith substantially into either poem. The only passage that hints at faith in relation to the individual and society appears in "Song." Here, Donne incorporates a small amount of folk belief and spiritual reference, writing: "Or who cleft the Devil's foot, / Teach me to hear mermaids singing, / Or to keep off envy's stinging" (Donne, 1633, p. 604). In this passage, the individual's relationship to faith seems rooted primarily in fear—fear of supernatural harm and of judgment after death, rather than in genuine spiritual devotion. The broader pattern across both poems reveals that spiritual concerns take a back seat to the urgent, pragmatic need to marry and reproduce. Faith is acknowledged, but marriage and social obligation take priority in shaping the individual's choices and anxieties.
Both poems "Song" and "The Indifferent" by John Donne reveal how people in the 17th century understood their relationship to society and faith. The poems demonstrate that the social imperative to marry and continue the family line dominated individual desire, often at the expense of deeper spiritual or emotional authenticity. By presenting two contrasting narrators facing the same fundamental situation—the need to find a partner—Donne illustrates the cultural pressures and contradictions of his time. Through his poetry, modern readers can understand the historical significance of marriage as a social institution and the complex emotional landscape of individuals navigating love within rigid social expectations. Donne's work serves as a window into the priorities and anxieties of 17th-century life.
You’re 82% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.