This narrative essay examines a pivotal moment in a friendship when one character discovers that her online romantic partner has concealed a fundamental aspect of their identity. Through dialogue and introspection, the paper explores themes of digital deception, emotional vulnerability, and the challenges of forming authentic connections through internet platforms. The story illustrates how anonymity and distance enable dishonesty, and how the revelation of hidden identity creates tension between romantic attachment and logical skepticism about trust in online relationships.
Holly pulled up to the car door, emerging from the blackness of the night. "I'm so sorry I'm late; I had to finish putting my clothes in the dryer. Merry Christmas!" she called out.
"Merry Christmas," Jen retorted back, a little annoyed at her tardiness.
It was really two days after Christmas, but they were on city time—which always runs a little late. Jen had insisted on picking her up; she always wanted to drive. They were off to Pepo's, a great little Italian restaurant where their other friends were already no doubt waiting, annoyed with their tardiness once again. Holly was struck by the confused look on Jen's face. Something was wrong.
"Is everything alright?" Heather asked her quietly.
"Yeah, why do I look like something is wrong?" Jen asked, trying to pretend like nothing was really bothering her. It was obvious, though—Holly knew she wanted her to ask. Jen was a little dramatic about everything; she had wanted to be an actress somewhere in a younger, former life. She smiled and quickly turned her head back to the road. "It's just Braiden again," she whispered.
Braiden and Jen had met somewhere around two years ago. He had found her and added her as a friend on MySpace, the latest trend in social networking sites. She was never one to really talk to strangers, but this one was different. He lived somewhere in Oklahoma, or so he said. He said he found her on another of her friend's profiles and started chatting her up. It eventually led to a twisted internet romance—the kind you see on crazy MSNBC predator shows. The whole affair had really turned ugly. The poor girl was in love with a man she had never even set eyes on before.
Normal couples who meet online will eventually meet in person, but these two had a suspicious streak of bad luck. He had contacted Holly in one of his crazy fits to start drama in Jen's life, saying he had come to Los Angeles many times. However, Jen was "negligent" and tardy, as usual, to pick him up. A whole half hour late, and this MySpace Casanova seemed to pull off an impossible feat: the boy had gotten off a plane, waited, gotten his luggage, and bought a plane ticket back to Oklahoma—all in half an hour at LAX. If it was really true, he had either been a time traveler or had supernatural abilities. It can be assured that this implausible story signaled something fundamentally dishonest about Braiden.
This is a testament to the boy's insane persona, which Holly and most of Jen's friends knew was a complete sham. It was so weird to watch it all go down. Such a promising young woman lured into such a strange situation, leaving her to acquire a love for solitude rivaling the most elusive of hermits.
"What happened now?" Holly asked in disdain. She was sick of hearing the craziness and thought it couldn't get any worse. She, like everyone else, had assumed this so-called "Braiden" was either married or ancient, one of the two. He would either die of old age, thus stopping all contact, or Holly knew she would be hearing about some scandal involving an angry marital partner sooner or later. "Don't let him stop you from having a good time tonight. It's the holidays, and we never see each other anymore. Just let him cool down so he stops with the dramatics," she said, feigning sympathy. Holly never really understood how you could let a man you have never seen, with no existence perfectly confirmed, rule your life. And that's exactly what Jen did.
"I found out who he really is," Jen whispered again, bashfully.
"Who? Is he—?"
"He's a she," Jen fell silent, waiting for some sort of response. She had just dropped a bombshell. Holly sat in disbelief; she couldn't even imagine the concept. Not only had this fictitious Braiden character lied about an entire identity, he didn't even have a penis—that is a pretty big lie. Holly looked at her, still in utter disbelief.
"But I still love her... or him, whatever, that person, the one I knew," Jen said, her voice shaking. "I don't care who they are on the outside. I care about the person I've gotten to know."
Holly, with her mouth agape, could not even hide her disbelief. There was nothing she could say. The thoughts raced through her mind: How do you know who that person is? Who is really there through all those eyes? Finally, she uttered, "You must be just as crazy as she is."
"Stunned silence follows the disclosure of deception and conflicted emotion"
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.