This paper explores the nature of New Zealand's unwritten, flexible constitution, tracing its development from the Constitution Act of 1852 through to the Constitution Act 1986 and the Statute of Westminster. Central to the discussion is the Treaty of Waitangi — the 1840 agreement between Māori chiefs and the British Crown — and its contested status as a founding constitutional document. The paper examines the treaty's historical significance, the discrepancies between its English and Māori versions, the role of the Waitangi Tribunal, and the ongoing debate about formally incorporating the treaty into New Zealand's constitution. It concludes by reflecting on the treaty's conditional relevance in contemporary New Zealand governance.
New Zealand, much like its counterpart the United Kingdom, is constitutionally flexible. Neither Britain nor New Zealand is regarded as having a constitution in the form of a single document. New Zealand's "unwritten" constitution consists of a set of fundamental laws adopted since the second half of the nineteenth century. However, one particular document is nowadays regarded as formally representative of New Zealand: the Constitution Act, passed by the UK Parliament in 1852. It was succeeded decades later by the Constitution Act 1986, which was passed by the New Zealand Parliament. The Treaty of Waitangi is also considered a principal source of the New Zealand constitution.
This paper addresses the major written documents regarded as part of the country's constitution, as well as some unwritten conventions. It also specifically examines the Treaty of Waitangi in connection with New Zealand's constitution, with an emphasis on its role and its relevance — or lack thereof — in the present day.
Māori people arrived in New Zealand in approximately 800 AD. By the late 1830s, there were approximately 125,000 of them in the region alongside some 2,000 settlers, with more arriving constantly. In 1840, an agreement was established between the Māori chiefs and the United Kingdom. The Treaty of Waitangi ceded sovereignty to the Queen of the United Kingdom while preserving territorial rights for the indigenous Polynesian people of New Zealand. More specifically, the agreement granted the British complete governance by the Crown and the right to develop colonial settlements. In return, the Māori were promised protection of their interests and rights, as well as full citizenship rights.
It is important to note that significant discrepancies exist between the English and Māori versions of the treaty. Various studies have indicated that the indigenous chiefs had a different understanding of what the agreement implied compared to what the British claimed. For example, whereas the English translation implies that full sovereignty was ceded to Queen Victoria, the Māori version of the text is understood to mean that the chiefs granted the British a right of governance while retaining their own previous authority. The treaty later formed the basis for indigenous people to request and claim rights in relation to the loss of land and unequal treatment.
Nevertheless, while it served its purpose in 1840, and some Māori were indeed successful in invoking the treaty for justice, the signed agreement was largely set aside by the state in the following decades. By the 1970s, a number of complaints had been acknowledged and pressure regarding breaches of the treaty had increased substantially, making a new approach necessary. In 1975, the Waitangi Tribunal, established under the Treaty of Waitangi Act, was given the authority to address Māori claims concerning the Crown's violations of the treaty.
"Treaty's modern status and Waitangi Tribunal claims"
"Legislative milestones toward full New Zealand independence"
"Democratic evolution and accessible governance since 1980s"
Kumarasingham, H. (2010). Onward with executive power: Lessons from New Zealand, 1947–57. Wellington: Milne Print.
New Zealand History Online. (n.d.). Treaty FAQs [Data file]. Retrieved from http://www.nzhistory.net.nz/politics/treaty/treaty-faqs
Orange, C. (2004). An illustrated history of the Treaty of Waitangi. Wellington, New Zealand: Bridget Williams Books Ltd.
You’re 33% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.