This case study examines the employee turnover crisis at Domino's Pizza, which reached a 158% turnover rate in 1999. The paper identifies defective human resources management and poor store manager selection as root causes, then evaluates retention strategies including improved supervision quality, management training, financial incentives, and workplace culture development. A comparison with Starbucks' wage-focused approach highlights Domino's longer-term, culture-centered strategy. Drawing on Ajzen's theory of planned behavior and HR alignment principles, the paper concludes with a recommended implementation plan centered on store manager selection, training, and systematic performance evaluation.
This case study focuses on one of the most challenging human resources issues in the food service industry: employee turnover and the way it manifested at Domino's Pizza. The company's turnover rate reached 158% in 1999. In the food industry, this rate is not unusual — other companies in the field have registered turnover rates as high as 200%. Nevertheless, a complex set of corrective measures was required.
In response, Domino's CEO began focusing on the company's human resources by implementing several strategies: improving store managers' workplace quality, improving personnel selection, recruitment, and retention methods, and introducing financial incentives. These strategies resulted in a decreased turnover rate of 107%.
A SWOT analysis of Domino's situation revealed the following. Strengths: good market position and strong geographical coverage. Weaknesses: elevated employee turnover, lack of coherent human resources strategies, and an incorrect division of tasks among employees. Threats: strong competition and a low employee retention rate. Opportunities: competitors facing the same personnel problems but handling them less effectively, and the potential to implement new strategies regarding personnel management and company culture.
The main problem identified in this case study is a defective organizational culture and inadequate human resources management. These conditions led to increased employee turnover, which in turn caused numerous additional negative consequences.
The most significant contributing factor was that store managers were not selected and evaluated properly. Moreover, store managers were not receiving assistance in tracking their best and worst performers, their work was not supported by computerized systems, and they did not benefit from training programs that would have helped them improve their performance and contribute to the company's success.
Another factor responsible for elevated employee turnover was the absence of adequate personnel strategies. Human resources management at Domino's appeared to be defective: the importance of personnel had not been given sufficient consideration, and the human resources strategy had not been aligned with the company's general strategy. As the U.S. Office of Personnel Management (1999) notes, HR alignment means integrating decisions about people with decisions about the results an organization is trying to obtain.
Several strategies can lead to an increased employee retention rate. For example, Starbucks addresses employee turnover by increasing wages, improving managers' work conditions, and enhancing the work environment. Domino's, by contrast, focuses less on wage increases and more on improving store managers' quality of work, developing human resources practices overall, raising the quality of its franchise operations, and implementing financial incentives such as stock investment programs.
Some specialists in the human resources field argue that the most important factor in increasing and maintaining employee retention is the quality of supervision employees receive (Heathfield, 2007). This retention strategy centers on establishing clarity between employees and their supervisors regarding performance expectations and the company's general direction. An important component of this strategy is encouraging regular feedback from employees.
Employees must also be aligned with the company's general direction by integrating personnel values with the company's mission and vision. This alignment will bring about positive changes in company culture that will have a significantly beneficial impact on the company's future success.
Another strategy already underway at Domino's is providing management skills training for every store manager. This approach will have positive impacts on all parties involved: the company as a whole, the store managers who benefit directly from the training programs, and the employees those managers supervise, who benefit indirectly.
Additional strategies for increasing employee retention include organizing company events, providing financial compensation and benefits packages, offering career development plans, and delivering other forms of employee support (Heathfield, 2007).
"Short-term wages vs. long-term culture building"
"Manager selection, training, and rollout steps"
"One-year review plan and fallback strategy"
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.