This paper examines the Cardinal Health case study as an example of a successful combined Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) and Business Intelligence (BI) implementation. The analysis explores how Cardinal Health's project teams prioritized tight integration between data structures and information culture, enabling rapid adoption of the SAP R/3 system. Key success factors discussed include consolidation of legacy enterprise systems, use of a common data model, limiting end-user tool variety, investment in a robust support environment, and the role of organizational trust in overcoming change management challenges. The paper demonstrates how aligning technical implementation with social and cultural factors within a company can significantly improve ERP and BI outcomes.
The majority of Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) projects fail despite many of them extending for years without delivering the results they were designed to achieve. Contrary to this pattern of ERP failures, the case study of Cardinal Health illustrates how successful a combined ERP and Business Intelligence (BI) implementation can be when insightful, intelligent planning is completed first. The project teams at Cardinal Health concentrated their efforts on ensuring data structures and information cultures across the company were tightly integrated with each other. Making this a priority and a pervading mindset of the project also solved one of the most challenging aspects of any large-scale IT or ERP project: getting change management to work successfully (Sharratt & McMurdo, 1993).
By ensuring tight integration of data structures with information culture, the SAP R/3 system and BI platforms implemented were immediately responsive to the information needs of the entire company. By unifying these two factors, the system architects were able to infuse the ERP system and BI components into the culture of the company quickly, embedding them into workflows over time by making the system a new, trusted resource for analytics, data, and reporting.
The implementation of any ERP system can take months to years of effort within an enterprise and will often deliver only a portion of the total functionality expected. With millions of dollars spent, many enterprises fail to gain the insights and intelligence they need to make full use of all the features an ERP system offers. Add in the complexity of BI, analytics, and reporting tools, and the potential for confusion — along with the proliferation of reports of marginal business value — can easily arise.
The central paradox for Cardinal Health was the need to rein in the intellectual curiosity that BI and analytics applications naturally generate, while staying focused on the most critical aspects of automating and adding insight into their core businesses. The goals Cardinal Health defined prior to the implementation were to consolidate 20 different enterprise systems, improve the user interfaces of their enterprise systems, and resolve Year 2000 (Y2K) compliance issues.
The three key success factors of the implementation centered on: the use of a common data model, limiting the variety of end-user tools to keep the overall scope of analysis within the boundaries of strategic goals, and — most importantly — the development of and continual investment in a robust support environment. All of these factors combined to drive up the level of adoption and utilization of the BI and analytics systems.
"Trust networks accelerating ERP and BI adoption"
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.