This paper investigates the question of whether computers are capable of genuine thinking. Drawing on definitions of thought, intelligence, and consciousness, the paper argues that computers cannot think independently because they lack emotions, self-awareness, and the capacity to form original ideas. It examines artificial intelligence as a simulation of human behavior rather than true cognition, and explores how the informality of human behavior — shaped by culture, emotion, and experience — cannot be replicated by rule-based programs. The paper concludes that until scientists can develop a system that processes emotions and builds on its own experiences, computers remain powerful tools that assist human thinking rather than perform it.
Thinking is defined as the ability to make sense of, represent, model, or interpret the world a person experiences. Thinking also allows humans to make predictions about their world. For an organism that has needs, desires, and objectives, thinking is helpful because it enables the organism to make plans in order to accomplish those goals. Using this definition, it becomes clear that computers are not organisms and therefore cannot possess the ability to think. Computers have the capability to make predictions, but the predictions made by computers have been programmed by humans. Humans who required tools to assist in analyzing their thoughts and predictions developed the programs used by computers. Without human intervention, computers would not be able to model, represent, or interpret any information.
It is assumed by a majority of people that computers have the capability to think. This is because computers can perform tasks faster than humans and even provide suggestions. The reality, however, is that computers do not have the capability to think. Computers are machines, and like any other machine they rely on software programs developed to perform specific tasks. These programs are developed by engineers, and using the fast processing speed of computers, it can seem as though the computers are thinking on their own.
Making use of the fast processing speed of computers, humans have managed to use them to make predictions about weather changes, stock prices, and other outcomes. Once this information is presented to the world, people assume that the computers arrived at it entirely on their own. Computers do not have needs, desires, or objectives; therefore, computers cannot make plans for themselves in order to accomplish any goals. Human intervention is required to input data into the computer, and only by using the installed program can information be derived. Computers provide assistance to humans — they do not replace human thought.
Thoughts are the result of thinking in the form of ideas or arrangements of ideas. There is no general agreement on how thoughts are formed. If computers could think, they would be formulating ideas on how to improve whatever they are processing. Thinking requires the ability to analyze a situation and make recommendations based on that analysis. While computers do perform a form of analysis, the data required must be provided by humans. The absence of human intervention means the computer cannot perform any analysis at all. This clearly shows that a computer is just a machine, and like any other machine it requires human input in order to perform its activities.
A computer developed to control traffic, for example, cannot be used to perform any other activity without first having its program changed. If this computer had the ability to think, there would be no need to change its program, because it would adapt to the new situation. Thinking would allow the computer to recognize that it is no longer controlling traffic and to analyze its new environment in order to formulate ideas about how to tackle its new task. The programs developed for computers contain a set of rules that the computer must follow in a specified sequence for it to achieve its function. These programs allow computers to perform logic and produce results — but they do not allow computers to think.
Artificial intelligence can be defined in many ways, encompassing abstract thought, self-awareness, logic, understanding, learning, communication, problem solving, planning, retention, and emotional knowledge. Computers have the capacity to communicate, retain information, solve problems, and perform logic. However, they lack the essential capabilities of emotional knowledge, self-awareness, abstract thought, and genuine planning. This indicates that computers can only simulate human thinking; they cannot actually think on their own. Artificial intelligence is based on simulations developed by programmers and engineers, which mostly simulate desired behavior. This desired behavior makes the computer perform activities based on the engineers' perception of human behavior, which has misled many people into believing that computers can actually think.
Computers do not have a mind. Even with artificial intelligence, computers still do not possess the reasoning capability of humans. This limits the range of their reactions to various situations. Intelligence is required for a computer to perform a task while taking into account all relevant circumstances. Scientists have long debated whether it is possible to use artificial intelligence to create a truly human-like computer. This debate is far from over. Some scientists have argued that the programs used by such a computer are all syntax and have no semantics — meaning that a computer is not able to achieve genuine thought, as it merely follows rules telling it how to manipulate symbols without needing to understand their meaning. On the other side, scientists have pointed out that humans must also be taught how to perform various activities, which is why they attend school and college. Using this analogy, some scientists have stated that computers could eventually learn to think. This remains highly theoretical, however, as it has not been proven.
Artificial intelligence gives a computer human-like characteristics, but it does not clone a human being. The characteristics or behaviors a computer will have are determined by its designated tasks. Because a computer can be developed to perform only a specific function, its artificial intelligence will only include characteristics relevant to that function. Adding more functions typically results in errors, as the computer cannot differentiate between the various situations it encounters. This limits the capabilities of artificial intelligence considerably. Even with today's advanced processing capabilities, mimicking human behavior remains difficult primarily because computers do not possess the intelligence and thinking ability of humans. Researchers developing these computers are working to demonstrate that a human-like computer can be built, but they often underestimate how powerful and poorly understood the human mind truly is.
Computers will not have the capacity to think until scientists can successfully develop a system that is able to process different emotions, build on its own experiences, and adapt to challenges. Artificial intelligence also denies computers the ability to build on their own experiences. Instead, computers are given processing power that allows them to handle information at very high speeds. This speedy processing is not based on past experiences but rather on the installed program. Engineers developing computers that can think should focus on how the computer can use information gathered for future use. Even then, this would not mean the computer is truly thinking, but it would be able to mimic thinking behavior more convincingly.
You’re 60% through this paper. Sign up to read the full paper.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.