Verified Document

Watson And Pauley Term Paper

Nursing and Care Theories Two of the major theories of nursing have been published by Jean Watson and by John Paley, who each have taken markedly distinct approaches to conceptualizing nursing care in a theoretical construct. Paley looks at some of the darker elements of nursing, using frames of "slave morality" and applying Nietzschean ideologies to the manifestation of contemporary nursing theory. Jean Watson has approached the theoretical foundation of nursing from a very different perspective over a long career focusing on the compassionate element of nursing care as it applies to human and humane experiences in care and loss.

Jean Watson, who hails from West Virginia, was educated at the University of Colorado and was appointed Distinguished Professor of Nursing and endowed Chair in Caring Science at the same university. Dr. Watson's degrees are in nursing and psychiatric-mental health nursing and PhD in educational psychology and counseling. Dr. Watson has received the prestigious Kellogg Fellowship in Australia as well as a Fulbright Award and half a dozen honorary degrees. The fundamental paper for Dr. Watson's nursing theory was published in 1979 in Nursing and is titled "The Philosophy and Science of Caring." This publication was followed up with 1988's "Nursing: Human Science and Human Care."

Watson divides her view on nursing into seven assumptions and ten primary carative factors pertaining to the role of nursing. The seven assumptions focus upon the key elements manifest in the role of care in nursing. They include acknowledgements such as that caring can only happen in an interpersonal, physical environment and that caring is central to nursing. She stresses the importance of patient agency while in the caring environment and projects that adequate caring contributes to the ability for health promotion and family and individual health (Meleis 1997).

The ten primary...

Faith, hope, and sensitivity are also crucial elements to the development of a self oriented toward the ability for adequate nursing care. In what might seem like a departure from the more esoteric elements of Watson's philosophy of care, the factors Watson crafts include an explicit reliance upon scientific methodology in decision making. The environment of care is defined by Watson across several variables, including the domain of mental, spiritual, physical, sociocultural, and emotional. The importance of attending to human physical needs is also underscored, highlighting the pragmatic elements of nursing care. Trust and a safely didactic environment are also cited as elements of Watson's philosophy of care (Taylor and Lillis 2001).
John Paley is a Senior Lecturer, Department of Nursing and Midwifery, University of Stirling in the United Kingdom. He takes what could be described as a skeptical perspective on the theories of care that Watson and similar theorists have put forth over the last several decades. Paley's areas of research interest include "Nursing's appropriation of phenomenology, the philosophy of qualitative research, professional ethics, nursing applications of the philosophy of mind, clinical cognition, and dynamic systems in health care. (University of Stirling 2011).

Paley suggests that there is no moral imperative, as Watson states, that privileges the benefit of altruism over any other moral or value system of belief. Even more controversially, Paley looks at the problematic elements of human and human care and suggests that caring is not necessarily and unquestioningly a virtue as Watson suggests and could be reframed as a vice as it "promotes favoritism, injustice, and self-deception. (Paley 2002)." Paley also suggests in his paper…

Sources used in this document:
References

Paley, J. (2002), Caring as a slave morality: Nietzschean themes in nursing ethics. Journal of Advanced Nursing, 40: 25 -- 35.

Meleis, Ibrahim Afaf (1997). "Theoretical Nursing: Development & Progress" 3rd ed. Philadelphia, Lippincott.

Taylor Carol, Lillis Carol (2001) The Art & Science Of Nursing Care. 4th ed. Philadelphia, Lippincott.

Potter A Patricia, Perry G. Anne (1992) Fundamentals Of Nursing -- Concepts Process & Practice. 3rd ed. London: Mosby Year Book.
University of Stirling. (2011). "John Paley." Retrieved from: http://www.nm.stir.ac.uk/people/john-paley.php
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Jean Watson Nursing Theory
Words: 1424 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Jean Watson Analysis of Nursing Theory Jean Watson is one of the reputable contributors in the contemporary nursing field. She is rather well-known for her work namely, Theory of Human Caring. Other than this eminent theory, she has presented various research papers which have made visible addition to theoretical work in the field of nursing. Her work on caring has also been included in the standard education related to patient care and

Jean Watson's Theory of Caring a Total
Words: 2415 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Jean Watson's Theory Of Caring A TOTAL HEALING EXPERIENCE Jean Watson's Theory of Caring Every person or patient has needs, which must be uniquely recognized, respected, and filled in the quest for healing and wholeness. Caring for the patient not only enhances recovery in any mysterious way. It can also be demonstrated and practiced by those who care for patients, especially nurses. Caring occurs in an environment, which accepts the patient as a

Jean Watson's Theory of Caring
Words: 2048 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Jean Watson's Theory Of Caring Iconic nursing leader and theorist Jean Watson established an innovative and much-needed component to the field of nursing which she refers to as a caring theory. This paper uses Watson's theories and examples of what she called "a caring moment" in the context of fully discussing nursing from Watson's point-of-view. Major components and background of Watson's theory "Watson (1988) defines caring as the moral ideal of nursing whereby

Watson Discuss Major Advantages Disadvantages Jean Watson's
Words: 684 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Watson discuss major advantages disadvantages Jean Watson's Theory clinical practice . How nurses explain Watson's theory Human Caring nurse coworker? . Peer-reviewed references Major advantages and disadvantages of Jean Watson's Theory in clinical practice One of the major advantages of Jean Watson's Theory of Human Caring is that it is a holistic system of care. Watson's Theory of Caring stresses the need to treat the whole person through caring and openness. It embraces

Jean Watson's Theory of Human Caring or
Words: 2193 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Jean Watson's Theory of Human Caring or Caring Science involves exercising core practices/principles. "Watson's theory of human caring focuses on holistic care and the authentic relationship between caregivers and patients" (Lukose, 2011, p. 27). The evolution from Carative to Caritas involves five principles. These are practice of equanimity and loving-kindness, enabling deep faith of other like colleague, family, or patient (otherwise known as authentic presence). The other is cultivation of

Jean Watson: Theory of Human
Words: 832 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

"Transpersonal Caring acknowledges unity of life and connections that move in concentric circles of caring-from individual, to other/s, to community, to world, to Planet Earth, to the universe." (3, Watson). This theory serves as a comprehensive guide to nurses in patient care. Caring is institutionalized in the sense that it is seen as a whole separate science that nurses need to excel in. Watson maintains that the core of nursing

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now