Verified Document

War And Peace Essay

Sociologists do not see war as something humanity is genetically programmed to do, but the result of social forces. Why do they believe this? What is the evidence? If war is not caused by biology, what are some of the social forces that sociologists argue have contributed to it? Illustrate your points with concrete examples from the readings. According to Howard Zinn, there is no evidence that human beings are innately predisposed to war, biologically or sociologically. War is generated by the actions of governments, not individuals. Zinn justifies his contention by the fact that citizens must be urged through propaganda and monetary rewards to die for the state. This shows that all wars are innately unnatural and totalitarian, given that the state demands that citizens act against their personal interests, such as living to see their children grow up, to die for an abstract concept such as 'national security.' If all human beings stopped fighting, then wars would cease (Zinn 2007: 190).

However, Zinn's idealistic analysis is belied by the fact that quite often people do seem to eager to engage in warfare. The resources of the world are scarce, and out of a desire, however foolish, to improve their nation's standing...

Rationally, if every soldier refused to fight for his or her government, war would cease, but fear that the enemy will not do so, combined with the desire for what might be gained if the enemy could be defeated, warfare continues. Even for citizens who are profoundly resistant to engaging in warfare, when faced with an aggressor, they may feel justified supporting war when their government resolves to arm itself.
There is an aspect of the infamous 'Prisoner's Dilemma' scenario in this: while it might be in two nations' mutual interest not to engage in war against one another, the fear that the other country will 'turn traitor' and betray the other by going to war causes one of the affected parties to engage in a first strike, in what it perceives as self-defense. The concept of self-defense is upheld even in the moral philosophy of the West. For example, according to Catholic doctrine, while Christianity is ostensibly a religion of peace, even an offensive war can be justified in defense of a moral objective, if the state has been injured. This is deemed analogous to the government punishing domestic…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

War Society Modern World War Has Been
Words: 1559 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

War Society Modern World War has been an integral part of the development of our civilization from the earliest times. It is estimated that there are more than 14,000 wars that have occurred since events began to be recorded and this has resulted in the death of billions of people. It was an essential part of the survival and behavior of human beings and the society at large. This attitude continued

War and Death When Considering
Words: 3476 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

This is not to suggest that either the United States or the Soviet Union were necessarily desiring this conflict, because "based on the scattered evidence now available from Soviet archives," Stalin was "wary and reluctant" in his support of the North, and only finally agreed to offer military equipment and advice when it became clear that China would intervene should the Soviet Union fail to offer support (Cumings 144).

War the Experience of War Has Changed
Words: 1228 Length: 4 Document Type: Thesis

War The Experience of War War has changed greatly in character from the days of knights in shining armor. The concept of a "state" rather than just a regional ruler has changed the dynamic of war. Rather than meeting on a battlefield and duking it out, two armies now willfully attack civilian targets to demoralize a population, cut off trade routes to starve a population, and, if it comes to it, invade

War Why a Military Presence
Words: 870 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

However, little concern is given to the Afghan people when their innocent is killed due to military action of developed nations. This too will only exacerbate the turmoil within the country. Revenge is a powerful emotion, especially when an individual has nothing a stake to achieve it. As such, due in parts to foreign operations in Afghanistan, many individuals have extreme animosity towards the developed world. It is therefore much

Peace or War in Homer
Words: 2107 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Is it a sign of inconsistency in Athena that at the end of the Odyssey she echoes the sentiment of Zeus and sues for peace whereas in Book 4 of the Iliad she is all too eager to ignore the sentiment of her father and manipulate the warriors into shedding more blood? Again -- not necessarily. While, were it up to Zeus he would gladly see men work out their

Peace Like a River: Chapter
Words: 1277 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Proposal

Davy, notably more active in his pursuit of that which he believes is right, is instead driven by the desire not to be abused by the world. As Mr. Land characterizes it though when he remarks upon 'plunging' his hands, it is to be understood that he is willing to accept the worst of what God has to offer with the faith that all will be resolved in the hereafter. Another emergent conflict in the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now