Verified Document

Vitamin D In Controlling Urtis In Recent Article Critique

¶ … Vitamin D in Controlling URTIs In recent times, several experimental studies have been conducted in order to understand the impact of vitamin D on controlling Upper Respiratory Tract Infections. This paper has selected by article "Effect of vitamin D3 supplementation on upper respiratory tract infections in healthy adults: the VIDARIS randomized controlled trial," a research study conducted by Murdoch et.al (2012). The goal of the article critique is to thoroughly analyze the article and to determine its validity and reliability. Furthermore, the critique would help in understanding the impact of Vitamin D on URTIs in healthy adults.

Experimental studies have reported that the relationship between serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D (25-OHD) and upper respiratory infections is inversely proportional. Murdoch et.al (2012) has reported that results of these experimental studies have been found to be inconclusive. The goal of Murdoch et.al (2012) was to study the impact of vitamin D on Upper respiratory infections (URTIs). The experiment lasted for a period of ten months and was conducted in Christchurch in New Zealand. A sample of 322 healthy adults was collected through random sampling. Dosage quantity had been divided in the following manner; 200000 IU oral vitamin D3 at the initial stage, 200,000 IU for a period of one month the following month and lastly, 100,000 IU later onwards. From the results, it was revealed that the dosage of 100, 000 IU of vitamin D did not have the ability to reduce the severity of URTIs in adults, who were healthy.

Critique

Participants were selected in accordance to criteria of enrollment as the advertisement campaign had been used to screen the individuals, the researchers were looking for. Exclusion criteria had been established in order to ensure that the trial's outcome is not influenced in any way and since the participants were screened thoroughly, therefore, it is safe to conclude that it did not influence the conclusion of the experiment.
After establishing the eligibility condition, computer generated randomization had been conducted to give participants vitamin D or placebo randomly. Both tablets appeared to be identical. Table 1of the research, demonstrated that the baseline characteristics of all the groups were balanced evenly on basis of the characteristics established. Both groups contained equal number of participants and therefore, did not influence the results and outcomes of the study.

The authors stated that the 91% of the participants took complete part in the treatment as well as in the follow up study. However, the measures for determining this result had not been stated by the authors and in this type of research, participants were not allowed to take any type of medications that would influence their results. About 6% of the participants completely withdrew from the research and the 3% did not take part in the treatment but were active in 18 months follow up program.

The findings of the research conducted by Murdoch et.al (2012) also gave the same…

Sources used in this document:
References

Murdoch et.al (2012). Effect of vitamin D3 supplementation on upper respiratory tract infections in healthy adults: the VIDARIS randomized controlled trial.JAMA. 2012 Oct 3; 308(13):1333-9. doi: 10.1001/jama.2012.12505.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Infection Control Surgical Site Infections Are a
Words: 1204 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Infection Control Surgical site infections are a major issue for any hospital and the eradication of these events is the goal of hospitals and regulatory agencies. The Joint Commission completed a surveillance of the hospital and they gave specific advice regarding surgical site infection control and the results that they had gathered. This particular plan focuses on infection control because it a very critical area that can cause dire issues with

Infection Control and Therapies for
Words: 698 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

The central theme that is discussed is the importance of matching the patient and therapy correctly in order to facilitate the best possibility of positive treatment and healing. The article also provides an overview of mind - body therapy and the way that it relates to the mind's ability to aid the bodily functions in fighting diseases like cancer. There are various modes of this therapy, which can include methods

Infection Control - Surgical Infection
Words: 3848 Length: 14 Document Type: Term Paper

70% 36-38 0-0-5 Overall Rate SIP 2a Subtotal Measure Title Data Period Rate/Value Numerator Denominator Missing Excluded Cat-E) Invalid Cases Population Numerator SIP 2b Data Prophylactic Jul-04 Antibiotic selection for Aug-04 surgical patients CABG Sep-04-100% 10-10 0-0-33 SIP 2b Subtotal SIP 2c Prophylactic Jul-04 Antibiotic selection for Aug-04 Cardiac Surgery Sep-04 0-1 0-0-42 SIP 2c Subtotal SIP 2d Prophylactic Jul-04 Antibiotic selection for Aug-04 hip arthroplasty Sep-04-100% 8-8 0-0-35 SIP 2d Subtotal Measure Title Data Period Rate/Value Numerator Denominator Missing Excluded Cat-E) Invalid Cases SIP 2e Population Numerator Data Data Prophylactic Jul-04 Antibiotic selection for Aug-04 surgical patients Knee arthroplasty SIP 2e Subtotals SIP 2f Prophylactic Jul-04 Antibiotic selection for Aug-04 surgical

Infection Control
Words: 343 Length: 1 Document Type: Research Paper

Failure to implement infection control precautions can lead to potential complications that include the spread of infection to otherwise healthy individuals within the ward or facility where the infection occurs and even out into the community through visitors who become infected (Banach, Bearman, Morgan & Munoz-Price, 2015). Thus, complications that arise from infection spreading may not be confined to the hospital or facility where they occur but can easily become

Infection Control and Prevention
Words: 2573 Length: 9 Document Type: Essay

Infection Prevention and Control Proposal for Clinical Experience and Project For this project, I elected to experience the leadership role in a clinical practice with a family nurse practitioner (FNP). Towards this end, my area of specialty will be infection prevention and control in a short-term and long-term rehabilitation facility. The relevance of this clinical experience cannot be overstated when it comes to the further enhancement of my professional capabilities. As a matter

Readmission Rates and Infection Control
Words: 1140 Length: 3 Document Type: Peer Reviewed Journal

HCAHPS (Hospital Consumer Assessment of Healthcare Providers and Systems) survey offers hospitals and other healthcare centered organizations and facilities the ability to assess how patients perceive the quality of care. While hospitals have implemented this kind of survey in the past, HCAHPS allows the data to be displayed publically and provides national data to allow for valid comparisons across hospitals nationally, regionally, and locally. This data display adds pressure

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now