Verified Document

Violation Of First Amendment Rights, Term Paper

On the other hand, a motive of debate was whether or not the Court should be intervening on issues that, ultimately, belong to daily operations in schools. The Court judged, however, that this was a breech to "basic constitutional values" (as in Epperson vs. Arkansas) and, in this sense, the judicial system's intervention becomes a necessity.

Additionally, the Court decided that the school board's decision could not be justified by the sole means of "educational suitability," which would have made it permissible, but that it was based on a purely partisan, political approach (some of the 9 titles clearly suggest this).

Petitioners rightly possess significant discretion to determine the content of...

But that discretion may not be exercised in a narrowly partisan or political manner."
ANALYSIS

In Board of Education vs. Pico, the Supreme Court affirmed, with a 5-4 vote an order from the Second Circuit Court of Appeals of a trial to determine whether the school board was acting from unconstitutional motives in removing nine books from the school library. Although their constitutional basis was undecided, their argumentation tended to show that the removal of certain books, when done in a partisan manner, was a breech of the First Amendment corollary of access to information.

The school board's action was narrowly judged to be unconstitutional, following this argumentation.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

First Amendment Vs. National Security
Words: 1074 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Paper

DRNC Scenario The author of this report is to answer to three major questions as it relates to the DRNC scenario advanced by the story that preceded it. The first question is the legal claims relating to the use of the LRAD. The second question is the basis that should be used to deny Amnesty International from getting their permit and the implications that this could cause. The final question requires

First Amendment Case Study Jonathan Zaun the
Words: 860 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

First Amendment Case Study Jonathan Zaun The disputed legality of government sponsored religious displays is a matter which must be examined through the unclouded lens provided by the Establishment Clause of the Constitution's 1st amendment. This prohibition of state sanctioned or sponsored religious activity states expressly that governing bodies shall not support or endorse any religious viewpoint through either establishment or preferential treatment. In many instances, however, public displays have been erected

First Amendment Including Kind Cases the First
Words: 1603 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

First Amendment including kind cases The First Amendment is imbued with a degree of preeminence that supersedes virtually all other amendments of the United States Constitution, largely because it was the first of many. As such, its importance to the country and to protecting the rights of its citizens is largely self evident. Perhaps one of the most cogent testimonies to this fact is the numerous times this amendment has

Right to Vote, Elections, and
Words: 8240 Length: 25 Document Type: Term Paper

One hypothesis is that many African-Americans yielded to the intimidation of the time and simply did not want to risk their safety and the safety of their families. 6. Poll Taxes A poll tax is a tax of a fixed amount charged each person to register to vote. (Webster's New World Law Dictionary.) as discussed previously, poll taxes were outlawed by the Twenty First Amendment. The practical effect of poll taxes

2nd Amendments First Amendment &
Words: 952 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

" Still, a judge has ordered the State Board of Education "not to enforce the new law while a suit filed by the father of a public school student proceeds" (Keen, 2007). Barry Lynn of the group Americans United for Separation of Church and State said the judge realizes "...that there is no motive for a moment of silence except a religious one." The First Amendment comes into play here

Second Amendment Rights: A Discussion
Words: 2590 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

The decision went further to suggest that, "even if possession were to be allowed for other reasons, any law regulating the use of firearms would have to be "unreasonable or inappropriate" to violate the Second Amendment." (Oyez Project, 2008). Had the decision gone the other way, gun rights activists and gun owners would have likely felt as though their constitutional rights were under attack. The District of Columbia v. Heller

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now