Verified Document

Vincent Vinikas' Review Of Dominic J. Capeci's Case Study

¶ … Vincent Vinikas' review of Dominic J. Capeci's The Lynching of Cleo Wright takes a critical stance toward Capeci's account of the case of Cleo Wright, a black man who was lynched in Missouri in 1942. Rather than examining the underlying causes concerning why lynching took place (particularly as late as 1942), Vinikas restricts his focus to elucidating logical fallacies that hinder Capeci's article. Vinikas argues that it is lamentable that even in books that purportedly reveal information concerning actual lynching cases, the true facts involved in such cases is never truthfully revealed, such that the public is still not privy to crucial information that colors America's history. In contrast, in her article "An Outrageous Proceeding: A Northern Lynching and the Enforcement of Anti-Lynching Legislation in Illinois, 1905-1910" Stacy Pratt McDermott applies a more comprehensive approach, determining the cultural forces that promoted lynching and made it incredibly difficult to abolish. Consequently, McDermott's article provides a more thorough explication of exactly why lynching took place and the forces that made its popularity difficult to overthrow. Vinikas' article begins with a basic summary of the lynching of Cleo Wright. The author provides particularly graphic details of the incident, including that Wright's leg was attached to the back of an automobile and driven through the streets, as well as the fact that Wright was stripped, covered in gasoline, and subsequently burned. The decision to provide such graphic details is particularly shocking, and to a degree, this validates Vinikas' approach in the article to decry how the specific details concerning who was to blame in the Cleo Wright case have never been fully unearthed. Vinikas criticizes Capeci for claiming to provide authoritative information concerning the case while never revealing the identity of the actual lynchers. However, it is perhaps excessive to liken Capeci to the complacent...

Furthermore, Vinikas' rhetoric is confusing; it is unclear how exactly likening Capeci's rhetorical strategy with the abhorrent conduct of Sheriff Hobbs constitutes a "practical" example.
To his credit, Vinikas provides a brief description (via Capeci) of the cultural effect of the Cleo Wright case. He mentions that the Cleo Wright lynching was particularly notable because it was used as fodder for an anti-America campaign issued by Japan during World War Two. However, Vinikas also argues that the failure to address the historical relevance of the Cleo Wright case is the foremost limitation of Capeci's book. Indeed, he states that "Few of the details that Dominic Capeci relates in The Lynching of Cleo Wright would distinguish this atrocity from thousands that had preceded it over the course of the fifty years" (Vinikas, 1999, 907).

While it is understandable that Vinikas criticizes Capeci for fictionalizing the names of those involved, making it such that it is difficult to discern who exactly committed the crime, this perhaps distracts Vinikas from placing greater emphasis on Capeci's deplorable statement that "Wright beckoned his own destroyers, and they complied" (Vinikas, 1999, 908). This statement suggests that Wright was, in effect, responsible for his own death and implies that Capeci is not even sympathetic to the plight of the African-Americans who were lynched. By emphasizing Capeci's apparent dishonesty and reticence in providing specific details concerning the case, Vinikas distracts himself from addressing the flagrant issue at hand concerning Capeci's lack of sympathy toward a lynching victim.

Unlike Vinikas, Stacy Pratt McDermott takes a far more thorough approach, although this is in…

Sources used in this document:
References

McDermott, S.P. (1999). An outrageous proceeding: A northern lynching and the enforcement of anti-lynching legislation in Illinois, 1905-1910. The Journal of Negro History, 84(1), 61-78.

Vinikas, V. (1999). The lynching of Cleo Wright by Dominic J. Capeci. Review by Vincent Vinikas. The Journal of Southern History, 65(4), 907-908.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Book Review The Civil War As a Theological Crisis by Mark a Noll
Words: 1527 Length: 5 Document Type: Book Review

Civil War as a Theological Crisis' by Mark A. Noll For the Antebellum Americans, trust in divine devotion and destiny to Scripture gave their lives stability and purpose. However, in accordance to Mark Noll's most recent book, The Civil War as a Theological Crisis, religious heads in the years just prior to the civil war were not capable of providing the best solution to the most challenging question of that

Novel Review Character Development
Words: 1357 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Character Development: Novel Review Novel Review: Character Development The novels, The Red Badge of Courage' by Stephen Crane and 'The Things they Carried' by Tim Obrien, are among the best depictions of the role played by introspection in helping individuals better understand themselves. This text depicts the journey to maturity of the protagonists in both novels, and how their development contributed to the full meaning of the work. Character Growth and Maturity during

Organizational Behavior Book Review of
Words: 1815 Length: 6 Document Type: Book Review

This book can really help managers in learning how to build a workplace environment in which better leadership can help employees in overcoming workplaces stresses and how leadership can be a great tool in getting over tougher times by making the best of decisions by making sure that all employees are included. Conclusion The book is a great read for the managers and this book can play great roles in improving

Psychological Book Review: Rebecca Wells Divine Secrets
Words: 990 Length: 3 Document Type: Book Review

Psychological Book Review: Rebecca Wells Divine Secrets of the Ya-Ya Sisterhood Culture and generational attitudes may separate them. Memories of physical abuse may be painful and real. Geography may keep them apart -- to say nothing of nasty quotations out of context by Northern reporters -- but mothers and daughters, particularly Southern mothers and daughters have an indissoluble bond -- as do Southern women friends. Although Southern girls may rebel, they always

Learning Theology Book Review Christopher Hall Is
Words: 714 Length: 2 Document Type: Book Review

Learning Theology Book Review Christopher Hall is Chancellor of Eastern University and Dean of the Templeton Honors College. He has written extensively on scripture, and in the book Learning Theology with the Church Fathers, offers an innovative premise -- instead of listening to modern lectures and interpretations, turn to the source materials to study theology. The early church fathers were prolific writers, seminal thinkers and theologians, and while they did not

Psychological Book Review: Scar Tissue Scar Tissue
Words: 963 Length: 3 Document Type: Book Review

Psychological Book Review: Scar Tissue Scar Tissue is a fictional book about dementia and the effects of aging of an elderly parent can have on an individual's soul, sense of self, and sense of place within a familial context. It tells the story of an artistic woman, married to a scientist, who slips into dementia. At first her husband cares for her, but he dies suddenly, and then she is institutionalized in

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now