Verified Document

Vicarious Liability Case This Present Study Is Essay

Vicarious Liability Case This present study is a vicarious liability case assignment and it is divided into two primary sections. The first section aims at distinguishing between corporate criminal liability and tort law vicarious liability resulting from the negligence of a health care organization's employee. The second section defines and discusses apparent agency and then states the impact status of the agent/employee vs. independent contractor has on analysis of liability.

Corporate criminal liability vs. vicarious liability

Corporate criminal liability falls under criminal law which defines the extent to which a company or a corporate that exists as a legal person can be held liable for the omissions or acts of an employee working for it. Crime punishable by corporate criminal liability can be defined as a breach of public right and duties which affect the whole community. The doctrine of vicarious liability is entrenched in law of torts and it states that an employer who gives consent to a tort will become personally liable for any harm or damage that result from tort of another person who was authorized to do a certain task for the employer. Vicarious liability is imposed on tort which is defined as an infringement of the civil rights belonging to the people. In tort the action is brought in the court by the victim of the tort and the wrong doer has to compensate him while in corporate criminal...

Corporate criminal liability can be presumed to be tool for regulating corporations while vicarious liability can be presumed a tool for making the employer accountable for the actions of his or her employees (Geraghty, 2002, and Laski, 2006).
As compared to vicarious liability, corporate criminal liability is difficult to prove as the law requires that some concrete element of fault, which can be knowledge of the relevant circumstances by the employee, recklessness which could have resulted in an offence or clear intentions to commit an offence. Hence corporations only become liable when the knowledge, omissions and acts of its employees can be attributed to the company itself, this can be ascertained through alter ego test, directing mind and identification tests that can show an employee has sufficient status to be assumed as the company when carrying out his roles and responsibilities. On the other hand vicarious liability doesn't require proof that the accused could have known that the act he/she was committing was wrong and furthermore it doesn't recognize anything like reasonable mistake or any excuse of honest mistake. And hence the reason why most cases which are less serious are imposed vicarious liability charges rather than corporate criminal liability (Geraghty, 2002, and…

Sources used in this document:
References

Geraghty, 2002; Corporate Criminal Liability, American Criminal Law Review,

Gobert, J. 1994; Corporate Criminality: New Crimes for the Times; Criminal Law Review

Laski .H, 2006; 'Basis of Vicarious Liability' Yale Law Journal

Sealy L. S and Hooley R.A., 2009, Commercial Law: Text, Cases and Materials
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Employment Landlord-Tenant Liability and Duties
Words: 1351 Length: 5 Document Type: Thesis

Causation: Irrespective of whether or not ABC Apartments satisfied its duty of reasonable care with respect to the safety of its tenants, the harm for which liability is claimed must relate directly to any failure to satisfy that standard. More particularly, to establish liability, the plaintiff must also establish that any negligence of ABC in failing to exercise reasonable care was the proximate cause of the harm that resulted (Freidman 2005). For

Negligence Law in Present Day
Words: 3040 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

Tort of Negligence with regards to business law. The discussions will particularly focus on areas that affect business decisions and any underlying law principles that have any effect on the same. There is also a section that looks at some of the sources of distrust of law. Negligence primarily means an action that creates an unreasonable risk, or in other words the failure of an individual to act normatively, as

History of Discrimination From Legislation to the
Words: 1826 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

History Of Discrimination From Legislation to the Present Day There are various form of discrimination that have been in existence over the decades, racism is just one of the oldest and most prevailing kind of discrimination. Racism is the belief that a race of people is inferior to another. Various practices in the U.S. are seen to be motivated by racism and these include the slave trade where humans are treated

Nursing Law and Ethics Name
Words: 1913 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

The death of a child is significant and in this case avoidable and a plaintiff has the right to seek compensatory damages as is allowed by law. Case Study 1 Part B At the end of the night shift, Nurse Brown took a verbal handover and then noticed the observation chart had not been filled in. To assist her friend, Nurse Harvey, whom she knew had a busy night, filled in the

Employee Privacy Torts
Words: 7119 Length: 25 Document Type: Research Paper

Employee Privacy Torts Issues relating to employee privacy have been at the forefront of businesses for many years. This has been fuelled by the dynamic workplace which changes constantly and also by employees and employers being more litigation-conscious. Technology has also spurred on employee privacy issues with e-mail and the internet being related to heightened concerns about vulnerability of employers to litigation. Many employers have thus exacerbated their concerns relating to

Keeping Information Technology Safe
Words: 2651 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Installation The author of this report has been presented with a hypothetical situation as ZXY Corporation where a new building has been procured. This building will be the site of the new information technology (IT) and other infrastructures. However, the current setup is very raw and unfinished and this obviously needs to change. The facets of the information technology setup that will be addressed in this report will include a

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now