Verified Document

Validity The Problem Discussed In The Case Essay

Validity The problem discussed in the case is whether or not the government should manage health care in the United States. The authors identify several problems with the current health care system, including costs that are rising faster than inflation, that health care coverage costs are rising even faster than that, and there are millions of uninsured. The problem can be tackled by using any of a number of logical approaches. Arguably, none of them were used by the articles, whose arguments would not cut muster at a decent high school, let alone in a journal.

Causal thinking seeks to understand the causes of the problem, as a means of identifying the areas where remedy should be applied. There are several causes of the problems. Costs are escalating in part because of innovation, which drives higher quality...

Insurance companies also contribute to the cost, because of profit-taking. All told, health care providers and insurance companies are in a position where they take profits that are very high because buyers and payers do not have adequate knowledge of the cost structure of health care services -- they are price takers.
Had the authors applied causal thinking, they would not say such absurd things like "free health care causes the spread of disease" -- they would have looked for evidence to back up their claim and found none. The causal analysis breaks down again when they claim that people who presently cannot afford health care would see no changes if health care was free -- how does that work? When you lower the price, more people can afford it. Call it cause and effect, or call it supply and demand, but the authors do not seem to understand basic cause-and-effect models here. None of their claims flows from an understanding of the causal links in health care.

Another model of thinking is logical, which can be inductive, deductive or abductive. To understand the underlying reasons behind a problem, abductive reasoning is the most appropriate, because it relies on inference to the best explanation. This method of thinking still relies on understanding the causal pathways. The first thing is that there are many problems in the health care system, and your…

Sources used in this document:
References

Chen, K.. & Chuang, K. (2013). Using systems thinking to analyze health care in the United States: Should we move to a government-sponsored health care system? Academy of Health Care Management Journal. Vol. 9 (2) 3-12.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Validity and Reliability Questions of
Words: 392 Length: 1 Document Type: Thesis

Presumably, the reliability of the responses between a monitored study and an unmonitored study could be validated by consistent reportage from the peer and the incumbent. This method was also used to control for the study's overall validity: the study would be a more valid measure of counterproductive work actions and their relationship to work stressors if an outside source validated the incumbent's responses. The study's authors still acknowledge a

Problem Solving Receiving and Making Important Phone
Words: 698 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Problem Solving Receiving and making important phone calls has been a serious problem in my daily life. This is a problem of time management and a lack of organization. Making and receiving these phone calls is essential because not doing so is affecting daily life. In order to confront this issue and solve this problem some amount of brainstorming must take place. According to Carter et al. (2007) "Brainstorming -- letting your

Validity of Data America Considers
Words: 15529 Length: 56 Document Type: Term Paper

Instead of pretending that racism and its effects no longer exist, we need to strengthen affirmative action and devise a new set of policies that directly tackle the racial gap in wealth." (Derrity, 1). That, in a nutshell, is the position of this paper. America has not given affirmative action enough time to act. Moving forward, we should continue our affirmative action policies, but with an end in mind. Economists

Problem of Evil One of
Words: 2755 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Even before one gets to Rowe's argument, however, one may disregard Hick's argument because it depends on imagining an infinite number of possibilities to explain away evil, rather than accounting for it. Instead of actually explaining how a benevolent and omnipotent god can allow evil to exist, Hick's argument simply states that this evil is not really evil, although with no evidence to back this up other than the convenient

Healing Wounds Case Study
Words: 6082 Length: 22 Document Type: Term Paper

MS Case Study Nurse Practice When patients enter hospitals it is oftentimes they become more ill and sicker due to inappropriate care and professional ignorance. This is due mainly to the amount of hubris involved within the medical profession and a tendency to ignore empirical evidence as practiced to success. This approach underlines the most important aspects of healing and the medical profession itself. The argument for continued improvement in the treatment

Assault Prosecution of Sexual Assault Cases Sexual
Words: 1148 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Assault Prosecution of Sexual Assault Cases Sexual assault remains a charge much embattled in our courts. Approaches to prosecuting in cases of sexual assault have been both inconsistent and generally ineffective as a true deterrent for repeat offenders. The articles evaluated here help to demonstrate that much of this difficulty is due to an inherent victim-blaming orientation within our courts. The article by Frohmann (1991) would be somewhat groundbreaking for the field of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now