Verified Document

U.S. Policy Towards The Dominican Term Paper

S. interference in Dominican affairs and quick 'to resent any slight, any tactlessness' on the part of the U.S. representatives." To conclude this portion of the paper, the question is pertinent: why was the U.S. so embarrassingly unprepared for the power grab by Trujillo in February, 1930? Roorda explains that the envoy to the Dominican Republic, John Moors Cabot, only 28 years old, misjudged "the distribution of power between the civilian chief of state and the military commander, a mistake repeatedly frequently" by American diplomats, while a nationalism fueled by militarist dictators "swept across the region" in the early 1930s. Meantime, the U.S. backed Trujillo, and even assisted him. It was all part of the American "Good Neighbor" policy: nonintervention, and support for dictators.

And the additional folly of the American "leadership" in the Dominican had an exclamation point added to it (59-60) when investigative reporter Drew Pearson published a series of articles which detailed the brutal repression administered by Trujillo in the first six months of his dictatorship, the State Department was taken "by surprise." In fact, once the State Department woke up to the reality of the bloody, savage style of power that Trujillo wielded, and investigated, they were "shocked to find that the picture is even more lurid than Mr. Pearson points it." Did the U.S. act within "conformity to ideals of right human conduct" in this matter? The answer has to be "no," America did not behave within the "ideals of right human conduct." They sold out to a dictator.

Under the title, "What did the U.S. try to do well, but wound up doing poorly?" was the Franklin Delano Roosevelt (FDR) strategy to use the Dominican Republic as a safe haven for Jewish refugees fleeing Nazi Germany. On page 144, Roorda explains that in the Spring of 1939, the president of Johns Hopkins University (Isaiah Bowman) was sent on a fact-finding mission to the Dominican Republic by FDR to "study...

Trujillo, who was more interested in getting positive publicity than he was in truly helping Jews flee Hitler's genocidal strategy, albeit he feared "Jews would overrun the country" (145), got a commitment from the U.S. that Roosevelt would deliver a statement "praising Trujillo."
And so, while the initial refugee settlement was a "public relations coup" for Trujillo, a brutal, blood-letting dictator who needed all the positive publicity he could muster, it ended poorly. The news reels about the refugee project (the "amazing human story") "downplayed the Jewish ethnicity of its population," and instead called in a "non-sectarian venture" with people from "Europe's heterogeneous stocks." The fact that the government of FDR would play along with this obvious distortion, speaks volumes about the kind of things the U.S. did not do well.

Worse yet, when Trujillo cut off all visas into his country "except for those [refugees] committed" (145) to the refugee camp area ("Sosua"), FDR's envoy, James Rosenberg, "was instrumental in limiting immigration" to those who were "young" and "strong." The author further explains the utter moral folly of this refugee debacle, by pointing out that "the settlement's rigorous selectivity in some says resembled the discrimination that Jews face in Europe." The bottom line was that the Sosua settlement was, in the author's words, "an anomalous showcase of humanitarianism exhibited to the world against a backdrop of repression." Did the U.S. act within "conformity to ideals of right human conduct" in this matter? The answer has to be "no," the U.S. did not behave in a morally appropriate fashion. And shame on the U.S. For its participation in this sham. Moral Report Card Grade: D+

Reference

Merriam-Webster (2005). "Morality." Accessed on http://www.m-w.com.

Roorda, Eric Paul. (1998). The Dictator Next Door. Durham: Duke University Press.

Sources used in this document:
Reference

Merriam-Webster (2005). "Morality." Accessed on http://www.m-w.com.

Roorda, Eric Paul. (1998). The Dictator Next Door. Durham: Duke University Press.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

U.S. Foreign Affairs Since 1898
Words: 3511 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

S. government chose not only to ignore the great humanitarian tragedy but even refused to condemn the killing. The American inaction on the Rwandan genocide places a big question mark on any subsequent action of its government overseas for humanitarian reasons. Besides being accused of using "humanitarianism" as a smokescreen for pursuing its own narrow national interests, the United States is also accused of undermining the United Nations and International Law

Immigration Policy
Words: 2252 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Wet Foot Dry Foot Policy History of Cuban Immigration Opposition to wet foot dry foot Fidel Castro Haitian American Activist Elian Gonzalez Recent Haitian Immigrants Human Right Advocates immigration policy has long been the center of much debate. In recent months the treatment of Haitian immigrants has come into question. Many in the Haitian American community question why Cuban immigrants are granted asylum while Haitians and other immigrants are deported. The purpose of this discussion is to

Dominican Republic Taino Indians Used
Words: 6941 Length: 18 Document Type: Term Paper

However, following several years of seizing ownership of the bulk of the vital businesses, he started to have stake in the important American-owned industries also, especially, the extremely vital -sugar industry. These takeover ploys connected with Trujillo's interfering in the internal matters of adjacent nations, resulted in more and more U.S. dissatisfaction with the autocrat of the Dominican Republic. (History of the Dominican Republic) The Trujillo administration for more than

Guantanamo Bay
Words: 16801 Length: 61 Document Type: Term Paper

Guantanamo Bay and the United States History of Guantanamo Bay, and the U.S. Involvement with Guantanamo Bay The Legality of the U.S. Occupation of Guantanamo Bay Why Do the U.S. Hold Guantanamo Bay? The Legal Position Regarding the U.S. Being in Guantanamo Bay Recent Events at Guantanamo Bay: Camp X-Ray and Camp Delta The Legal Position Regarding Events at U.S. Camps in Guantanamo Bay The Geneva Convention and Guantanamo Bay In the last two years the U.S. naval

Westward Expansion and Manifest Destiny
Words: 4448 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

" In other words, republicanism in an expanding state would inevitably lead to more despotic, aristocratic, and monarchical regimes. Hence, if the U.S. were to follow a policy of expansion, it would, at least, theoretically conflict with its republican origins. Interestingly, one of the leading proponents of republicanism, Thomas Jefferson had become the third U.S. President after an unexpected electoral crisis in the elections of 1800. He was a great champion

Causes of Different Economic Development Among Different
Words: 1581 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

causes of different economic development among different immigration groups in the United States will be documented on a description of the economic level of each community and some of its characteristics, as well as on the different policies that the U.S. government may have applied in their cases and on the social and human capital they have brought along. The Cubans represent a case apart, mainly due to the legal

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now