Verified Document

Unfavorable Treatment Of Robert E. Lee Among Essay

Related Topics:

¶ … Unfavorable Treatment of Robert E. Lee Among the most important goals of any historian, or history writer, ought to be to present information about events and individuals without any slant or bias. How do historians accomplish this feat? By sticking to their sources, and developing their argument without trying to steer those sources toward their own personal viewpoints. Whether or not authors and historians have done as much for Robert E. Lee, who served as a Confederate General in the United States Civil War is under consideration in this discussion. Two prominent works, Ordeal by Fire by James M. McPherson and Lee Considered by Alan T. Nolan will serve as the basis for determining whether or not Lee was treated fairly in the history books. By the definition of fairness being an unbiased presentation of sources, Nolan did not seem to be as just in his delivery of Lee, painting him as inconsistent with less regard to temporal context than would be expected of a fair portrayal.

Of course, both of these books deal with Lee in a number of circumstances, during the duration of the Civil War and the events leading up to -- and following -- those four years of battle. For purposes of comparison, these texts will be examined herein on the basis of each author's presentation of Lee's stance on slavery and emancipation. Nolan brings up the subject of Lee's views on the Southern institution of slavery...

This is noteworthy because the events he discusses do not actually occur until the war is almost over. While Nolan's book is not organized chronologically, it can easily be surmised that he means his view of Lee's stance to carry through as one of the main points of Lee Considered.
Regarding Lee's view of slavery and emancipation, Nolan writes:

...with the war over and lost, Lee told representatives of the United States

Congress that he had "always been in favor of emancipation -- gradual emancipation" (emphasis added). But […] while still at war, he had described slavery as "the best" relationship between the races and had said that emancipation involved "evil consequences" to both races (Nolan, 1991, 23).

In this quote, he makes no secret of his emphasizing the word "always." What Nolan fails to point out is the difference in context for both of Lee's statements. It may be that, when speaking to the United States Congress, Lee felt comfortable voicing the truth of his convictions, while the letter in which he referred to slavery as "the best" sort of arrangement was written to another member of the confederacy. While Nolan does not hide this information, his combination of these two sources to prove an inconsistency, without at-length discussion of the origin of both sources and their intended audiences, imbeds within…

Sources used in this document:
References

McPherson, J.M. (1982). Ordeal by fire: the Civil War and Reconstruction. New York: Knopf: .

Morton, P. (n.d.). An Interview with James M. McPherson. Bookslut | Issue 107 | April 2011. Retrieved April 4, 2011, from http://www.bookslut.com/features/2007_05_011057.php

Nolan, A.T. (1991). Lee considered: General Robert E. Lee and Civil War history. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Criminological Theories and How They Apply to a Fictional Characters...
Words: 4431 Length: 13 Document Type: Essay

Criminological Theories and Their Application Character History Nikita Voronov was born in Omsk, Russia in 1977 to a 17-year-old mother named Natasha Voronov. She had gotten pregnant with him after dating a man for one month, another Russian male who was working in the mining area at the time. Once Natasha became pregnant she never saw the father of her child again who fled the town. Desiring a better life for her

Obesity in Pregnancy Brief Actionplan
Words: 4542 Length: 15 Document Type: Dissertation

The chapters outlined the significance of the study, the intended objectives, the hypotheses statements, justification of the study, the research design, and the findings and conclusions. The examination carried out within the sections of this paper will be important for bridging the gap of knowledge on the use of UB-PAP in the diagnosis of obesity among obese pregnant mothers. It will be particularly helpful in informing the patients and

Social Sustainability Through Nuclear Energy and Waste Disposal
Words: 38353 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Meta-Analysis Technique for Nuclear Energy and Waste Disposal and Create Social Sustainability A Dissertation Presented using the Meta-Analysis Technique Komi Emmanuel Fiagbe Gbedegan Christina AnastasiaPH-D, Chair [Committee Name], [Degree], Committee Member [Committee Name], [Degree], Committee Member Date Approved Komi Emmanuel Fiagbe Gbedegan, 2016 This research proposal explores the link between public perceptions of nuclear power, how those perceptions are formed, and what influence those opinions have on energy policy. These issues are important in light of two realities.

Social Sustainability Through Nuclear Energy and Waste Disposal
Words: 31658 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Meta-Analysis of Nuclear Energy and Waste Disposal in Social Sustainability A Dissertation Presented using the Meta-Analysis Technique Komi Emmanuel Fiagbe Gbedegan Christina Anastasia PH-D, Chair [Committee Name], [Degree], Committee Member [Committee Name], [Degree], Committee Member Date Approved Komi Emmanuel Fiagbe Gbedegan, 2016 This research proposal explores the link between public perceptions of nuclear power, how those perceptions are formed, and what influence those opinions have on energy policy. These issues are important in light of two realities.

Social Sustainability Through Nuclear Energy and Waste Disposal
Words: 31658 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Meta-Analysis of Nuclear Energy and Waste Disposal in Social Sustainability A Dissertation Presented using the Meta-Analysis Technique Komi Emmanuel Fiagbe Gbedegan Christina Anastasia PH-D, Chair [Committee Name], [Degree], Committee Member [Committee Name], [Degree], Committee Member Date Approved Komi Emmanuel Fiagbe Gbedegan, 2016 This research proposal explores the link between public perceptions of nuclear power, how those perceptions are formed, and what influence those opinions have on energy policy. These issues are important in light of two realities.

Social Sustainability Through Nuclear Energy and Waste Disposal
Words: 31780 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Meta-Analysis of Nuclear Energy and Waste Disposal in Social Sustainability A Dissertation Presented using the Meta-Analysis Technique Komi Emmanuel Fiagbe Gbedegan Christina AnastasiaPH-D, Chair [Committee Name], [Degree], Committee Member [Committee Name], [Degree], Committee Member Date Approved Komi Emmanuel Fiagbe Gbedegan, 2016 This research proposal explores the link between public perceptions of nuclear power, how those perceptions are formed, and what influence those opinions have on energy policy. These issues are important in light of two realities. First,

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now