Verified Document

Twelve Angry Men: Persuading The Essay

According to the boy himself he had motivation as well as the means to kill his father. Perhaps most damning of all, the young man has no alibi. He says he was 'at the movies.' Saying he was at the movies seems like a convenient excuse, given that it is a dark place where no one is likely to have seen him. Furthermore, the defendant claims he cannot remember the films he saw. I ask you, gentlemen of the jury, if your life hung in the balance, could you not remember the names, or at least a few images and actors, of the movies you saw while your father was murdered? The young man's refusal to provide any evidence underlines his guilt. If he named a film, there would be no eyewitnesses at the cinema, and he knows he might give a wrong name and time for the film. Any inaccuracy would automatically catch him in a lie.

Further straining credibility is the statement by the young man that the knife he purchased fell through a hole in his pocket. How likely is it that the boy's knife fell through a hole in his pocket and then was discovered by the murderer in the same neighborhood -- and then the murderer carefully wiped the handle of the blade clean?

There has been a great deal of debate about the credibility of the witnesses. Some say that an old man could not have gotten to the door...

But given the extremity of the circumstances, would we not all move more quickly? The man had just heard someone being murdered in his presence! And I ask again: what reason does he have to lie? Simply because an individual is old and infirm does not mean that he should be mistrusted: to ignore him would be another injustice, against the wisdom and the opinion of someone who has lived a long life.
Once again I state the defendant is poor and non-white has no bearing on this case: other than the fact that it is essential that justice is done for the sake of the victim. Merely because the victim lives in a poor neighborhood, and is neither white nor educated does not mean that we can take our responsibilities lightly.

We must also consider the defendant's character. He has been to reform school; he stole a car when he was fifteen. His willingness to defy the law is established. This seems to be a sad life pattern, cumulating in the death of the boy's father. The young man, when tried as a juvenile, was given a second chance. That second chance, given to him by the judicial system of our land, has resulted in the death of his father. It is up to all of us to make sure that the young man does not have a third chance to harm another individual.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Angry Men Twelve Angry Men:
Words: 767 Length: 2 Document Type: Reaction Paper

Juror 7 can be classified as a salesman who simply cannot wait to be elsewhere. The eighth juror is an insightful individual, who is also patient and who constantly strives to attain the truth. Juror 9 is the eldest and is a fair individual as well. Juror 10 is much like Juror 3, in that he is opinionated, intolerant and a racist. Juror 11 is an immigrant who expresses respect for the American system

Angry Men the Jury in Twelve Angry
Words: 801 Length: 3 Document Type: Movie Review

Angry Men The jury in Twelve Angry Men is not diverse in terms of ethnicity and gender, because it consists of twelve white males. The only diversity evident is with Juror 5, who has a social class-consciousness that is different from the other men due to his having grown up poor. This little "in" to the theme of prejudice is what helps Juror 8 eventually persuade the others that their

Deconstruction of Leadership in Film:
Words: 1525 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

This exact statement no doubt describes the premise and situation in 12 Angry Men. Fonda's character works to secure justice for the accused man, regardless of whether the ultimate verdict will be guilty or not guilty. Fonda appears to be less concerned with the verdict than with whether or not the trial and jury deliberation is conducted fairly and thoroughly. Accordingly, Fonda exhibits the forensic rhetoric precisely in his

Flannery O'Connor Born in Savannah, Georgia, in
Words: 1150 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Flannery O'Connor Born in Savannah, Georgia, in 1925, Flannery O'Conner was the only child of a Catholic family. The region was part of the 'Christ-haunted' Bible belt of the Southern States. The spiritual traditions of the area greatly influenced O'Connor's writing. O'Connor's father, Edward F. O'Connor, was a realtor who worked later for a construction company and died in 1941. Her mother, Regina, came from a prominent family in the

Homeland Security
Words: 2038 Length: 6 Document Type: Article Review

Pat Proctor of Kansas State University was published in the peer-Reviewed Journal of Strategic Security in 2012. The point of this article is not so much posing a question but presenting a proposal. The proposal is directed at the United States, suggesting in strong terms how the United States (and presumably its allies) could and should engage in "…mass politics" which Proctor calls "war without violence" (Proctor, 2012, 47). The

Hockey I Am I Canadian
Words: 1230 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Of course, Fuller is not the only one to draw connections among hockey, the media, and differences between Canadian and American national identities. In fact, Gruneau and Whitson get the name of their book from Canada's most famous television program -- Hockey Night in Canada. Like learning to skate before learning to walk, the pair suggest that the Saturday night "TV program made us feel like part of a

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now