Trial Brief: NLV v. Eco
NLV Laboratories, Inc. v. Eco Compliance Corporation
Whether an existing dispute over an agreement should have precluded summary judgment.
SUBSTANTIVE FACTS:
NLV appealed the summary judgment, claiming that no accord and satisfaction could have existed unless full payment was received.
NLV argued that the mere existence of a dispute should have precluded a summary judgment.
PROCEDURAL FACTS:
NLV Laboratories billed Eco Compliance $42,754.50 for services rendered
Eco Compliance sent a check for $13,531.19, stating in writing that this amount represented full and final payment and difference from the bill was deducted for overcharges and negligence on a different project.
NLV responded by depositing the check sent by Eco and then demanding the balance owed in writing.
Eco refused to pay any more and NLV sued.
Eco presented an accord and satisfaction defense and a request for summary judgment based on this defense was granted.
NLV appealed the summary judgment.
HOLDING: The Washington Court of Appeals concluded that an accord and satisfaction (fulfillment of the contract) did exist because NLV deposited a check for an unliquidated claim.
REASONING: The Court of Appeals relied on the same legal precedence the lower court used to draw a distinction between liquidated and unliquidated debt. A liquidated debt is defined in the accord (contract) and if the contract between NLV and Eco had defined the amount owed once services were rendered, then depositing the check would not have satisfied the agreement and summary judgment would have been reversed. Since Eco alleged in their letter that NLV overcharged for some services and was negligent on another job, these disputes rendered the debt unliquidated. If the creditor deposits a check for an unliquidated debt that the debtor claims satisfies the dept in full, then this implies the accord is satisfied regardless of the existence of a dispute. An accord can be satisfied either by an express agreement or implied from the circumstances (Evens v. Columbia International Corp.).
JUDGEMENT: Affirmed
Trial" by Franz Kafka The human sense of justice in "The Trial" by Franz Kafka The field of literature is filled with stories depicting human suffering in both explicit and implicit forms, which made the readers empathize or react to the horrors depicted in these illustrations of suffering. However, there is a far more horrific portrayal of human suffering, and this is the experience of injustice in one's life. In the
He is taken outside, where the fresh air revives him. In this Chapter, K. suffers two types of defeat; first the defeat of his aborted sexual conquest that would ultimately be a victory over the Magistrate, and secondly the defeat of the air making him unable to go the Court offices. He is physically unable to be in the vicinity of the Court, and therefore unable to attempt to
Appellate Brief Question Presented / Issue Statement Appellant Mary Smith seeks review of the decision of the United States District Court for the District of Anytown, which granted judgment in favor of appellees, the United States Postal Service (U.S.P.S.) and Jim Bonilla, Regional Supervisor of the U.S.P.S., on their motion to dismiss appellant's complaint for failure to exhaust administrative remedies in appellant's lawsuit for gender discrimination, hostile work environment, and constructive discharge
Miranda v. Arizona. 384 U.S. 436 (1966) This case was first brought in district court against Ernest Miranda after a rape investigation led authorities to question him. Under questioning, Miranda admitted to raping a young girl and signed a written confession. The case was heard in Phoenix district court and Miranda was adjudicated as guilty. The Arizona Supreme Court rejected Miranda's appeal, finding him guilty once again. The U.S. Supreme Court
Civil Disobedience The Trial of Socrates The Athenians suffered a crushing defeat in 404 B.C.E. with the end of the Peloponnesian War. A Spartan occupation force controlled the city, and instituted the rule of the Thirty Tyrants to replace Athenian democracy. While a form of democracy was reinstated it lacked the acceptance of ideas and freedom of speech that had been such an integral part of Athenian society (Rogers). In Athens at this
3 16 JTF JFACC JFLCC JFSOCC JFMCC Yellow MOD Coordination TACON OPCON COCOM XX ESG CSG SAG MPS PATRON SAG Amphib X SF NSWTG PSYOPS JSOAC AETF AEF ASOG Yellow Patrol Boats COA 1 Task Force Command Level Major Subordinate Element (MSE) Level MSE Subordinate Units Level Depict Command Relationships X XX Yellow JTF-50 COA Presentation Format DJMO C340 EXERCISE MATERIAL Reading C340.3 17 Phase I-Deter Air and naval strikes, in coordination with Sof and Marine for Operation theater entry. Additional forces are brought to the shore whenever it is necessary. With control area being denied to enemy forces That could be of a big threat to mine clearing operations. With central areas denied to enemy forces that could threaten other
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now