Verified Document

Systematic Research Review Critique Of Systemic Research Research Paper

Systematic Research Review Critique of Systemic Research (SRR) RELATED TO NURSING

Critique of a Systematic Research Review (SRR):

Breast self-examination, breast awareness, and practices of systemic review

Breast cancer is one of the most deadly and fastest-spreading cancers in the world today. To mitigate the tide of this epidemic should ideally include preventative measures as well as proactive treatments. The purpose of the literature review "Breast self-examination, breast awareness, and practices of systemic review" by Parvani (2011) was to assess the current research findings on the degree to which breast self-examination and more general breast self-awareness campaigns were useful in increasing the rates of early detection of breast cancer.

Research rigor of selected studies

Studies were not screened for specific levels of research rigor. General medical databases were searched for relevant studies using Medline, CINAHL, PubMed, Science Direct, and Cochrane using words such as "breast awareness," difference," "breast self-examination," breast cancer screening" and "breast screening" (Parvani 2011: 336). Only articles from the past five years of the authorship of the article (2005-2010) were selected. Date of publication vs. standards of rigor were the determining factors.

Clarity of study presentation and critique

One drawback...

There is no table outlining the differences between the studies. The emphasis on study selection was clearly more upon quantity rather than individualistic research analysis. The results of the studies are presented in a more general format in terms of their results without extensive pagination being devoted to breaking down their methodology. The upside to this, however, is that the results of all the studies are presented fairly clearly, along with their implications for practice.
Overall finding of the selected studies

The overall finding of the selected studies stressed the relative inadequacy of current screening methods, including mammography and breast self-examination. Of a particular feature of interest was the overall lack of efficacy of breast cancer self-screening. Randomized control trials (RCTs are considered the 'gold standard' of rigor in terms of research analysis) in Russia and Shanghai yielded no apparent medical benefit to breast cancer self-examination. Research indicates that breast self-examination could only detect about 60% of breast cancers detected by mammography as well as some breast cancers not detected by mammography but there is no clinical significance in the size of the tumor and lymph nodes between those who engage in self-examination and those who do not…

Sources used in this document:
Reference

Parvani, Z. (2011). Breast self-examination, breast awareness, and practices of systemic review.

Professional Medical Journal, 18(2), 336-339.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Analysing and Assessing Translational Research
Words: 6128 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Evidence-Based Practice Translation of Research in Evidence-Based Practice Nursing involves men and women who are willing to help the patients with their skills like health maintenance, recovery of ill or injured people and the treatment. They develop a care plan for the patient sometimes in collaboration with the physicists or therapists. This paper discusses the current nursing practice in which I am involved and needs to be changed. Identification of a Current Nursing

Organizational Behavior Systematic Study of
Words: 1484 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Moreover, Bartlett (cited in Churchwell, 2003) underlined that, in the past, managing diversity was rather synonymous with giving equal opportunities to people of different gender or race. Nowadays, he emphasized that diversity meant "legitimizing diverse views in an organization, including those based in cultural differences." In addition to his remark, one could say that managing diversity under contemporary circumstances doesn't exclusively consist of providing equal treatment to different people. It also

Developing a Research Hypothesis
Words: 2368 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Abstract Developing a researchable question is one of the challenging tasks a researcher encounters when initiating a project. In current clinical practice, both unanswered issues or when experiences dictate alternative therapies may provoke an investigator to formulate a clinical research question. This paper describes PICO (population, intervention, control, and outcomes) criteria in framing a research question. Finally, it assesses the characteristics of a peer-reviewed article on urinary tract infections. Part 1 EBM, shorthand

Criminal Justice Systemic Malignity Racial
Words: 2221 Length: 7 Document Type: Journal

Baker reviewed three landmark Supreme Court decisions on capital punishment and concluded that the death penalty is capriciously imposed on Black defendants and thus serves the extra-legal function of preserving majority group interests. He viewed discrimination in capital sentencing as deliberate and identified the primary reasons why Black defendants with white victims have been denied fairness in capital sentencing. These are prosecutorial discretion in the selective prosecution of capital

Family and Systemic Therapies Shift From First-Order to Second Order...
Words: 2684 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Shift From First-order to Second-Order Cybernetics in the Family and Systemic Therapies The strategic family therapy model came up in the 1950s and was inspired by two primary works: the works of Milton Erickson who came up with revolutionary paradoxical interventions which took advantage of people's resistance to change to help alter psychiatric symptoms first; and the works of Gregory Bateson and the Palo Alto Group that made use of

Health Management Information Systems
Words: 3256 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

A. Identify a current nursing practice within your healthcare setting that requires change.HIS in Nursing practice1. Describe the current nursing practice.HMISs (Health Management Information Systems) are included among the building blocks vital to strengthening the nation’s health and healthcare system. They may be defined as data collection systems targeted specially at supporting planning, decision-making and management within hospitals smaller healthcare centers and health and healthcare related agencies.Health information constitutes a

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now