Verified Document

Supreme Court And Tenure Term Paper

¶ … Supreme Court Justices as regards their lifetime appointment status. Life tenure by Supreme Court judges has numerous significances as well as drawbacks. However, the advantages outweigh the disadvantages and, as such it should be taken into consideration. Furthermore, the federal judges should receive significant pay as result of the importance of their job.

This article includes the advantages and disadvantages of being a federal judge, as well as their tenure and salaries.

The Pros

Unquestionably, life occupation of office by federal judges has an extremely vital purpose: It protects the judges against the pressure which comes from politics as a result of sporadic accountability to voters. In contrast to numerous state judges, the federal judges do not need to get worried about coming up with funds for vote hunting campaigns or coming up with unpopular rulings that are legally correct but displeasing to the electorates. An important job of the federal juries is to shield from a hyper democratic "tyranny of numbers," whereby, legitimate minority human rights are regularly sabotaged by acceding to the choice of the larger majority (Lazarus). Numerous elements of Rights Bill that the judges are regularly tasked to impose include rights to: Exercise one's religion, free speech, and due course of law among others, were established to shield the rights and freedoms of inward-looking and occasionally ostracized minorities. Executing responsibilities and duties meticulously as a federal judge can be a difficult job even under the...

Judges are not totally insulated from the political pressure even if given life tenure. They stay members of the communities they originate from and consequently, the judges are susceptible to all kinds of associated social burdens. It is not easy being the judge and allowing neo-Nazis walk in the village of Skokie, or the judge who allows the indicted rapist to be free since the police dishonored his legal rights. Visualize how harder the occupation would have been if it had been similar, though regrettably, as is the situation with certain judges of state courts, the professional livelihood of a federal judge hinged on obtaining re-election straight, or hopes of getting reappointment by a designated official. Judges too like occupation security just like any other person.
The Cons

Life occupation of office results in at least the following three drawbacks: Firstly, it results in bad judges remaining in office indefinitely excluding some extraordinarily rare cases where they are impeached. Secondly, it lets all judges, together with several good ones, to stay in office when they are not performing at their best or anywhere near. Lastly, life tenure permits judges to stay in office, even as their level of effectiveness and productivity diminish, as they wait voting in of an ideologically well-suited Commander-in-chief who will appoint an ideologically well-suited successor (Lazarus)., though, is not the best answer to the position. At best, it (Preventing life tenure) would remove a bad judge from office. However, at the same time it would cut short very good judges' time in office. Take, for instance, a rule restraining federal judges to a maximum of twenty years in office. This term permits a federal judge to finish a very considerable amount of judicial task. Thus far, such tenure would have resulted huge majority of the federal judges getting out of office when they are between 60s and 70s. This would make it simple to amass an extensive list of great judges who are…

Sources used in this document:
References

Denniston, L. (2013, September 24). Constitution Daily -- Smart conversation from the National Constitution Center. Constitution Check: Should Supreme Court justices have limits on their time in office? Retrieved September 16, 2016, from http://blog.constitutioncenter.org/2013/09/constitution-check-should-supreme-court-justices-have-limits-on-their-time-in-office/

Joyner. "The Average Salary of Supreme Court Justices - Chron.com." Work - Chron.com. Web. 16 Sep 2016. <http://work.chron.com/average-salary-supreme-court-justices-3039.html>.

Lazarus. (n.d.). CNN - Breaking News, Latest News and Videos. CNN.com - Life tenure for federal judges: Should it be abolished? - Dec 10, 2004. Retrieved September 16, 2016, from http://www.cnn.com/2004/LAW/12/10/lazarus.federal.judges/
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Supreme Court Decisions the Nature
Words: 2427 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

For example, he voted to require that schools utilize resources to support religions activities if they designate resources to non-religious activities (Board of Education. v. Mergens, 1990). Further, Zelman v. Simmons-Harris (2002) called for vouchers to be given to families of low socioeconomic standing for both religious and secular educational institutions. This being said, Rehnquist was not able to completely disrupt the social change that Warren had started in

Establishing the Supreme Court
Words: 715 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

U.S. Constitution Between 1777 and 1786, the Articles of Confederation determined what the federal government could and could not do (School of Law, n.d.). The Articles provided no authority for tax collection or regulation of commerce, a situation that left the states to fend for themselves amidst the often chaotic efforts to compete against one another. Without tax revenues, the federal government had no way to pay soldiers fighting in

Academic Tenure
Words: 1445 Length: 3 Document Type: Literature Review

Tenure -- Literature Review Academic tenure is a system that many universities and colleges use to protect a senior academic's contractual right to a lifetime job unless terminated for just cause. It is typically reserved for academics who have made Assistant or Full Professor, and requires following a strict hierarchical rubric that demonstrates a strong record of published research, teaching, and administrative services. Most institutions allow for a certain period of

Higher Education and Tenure
Words: 1638 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Tenure Process Higher education system in the United States is dominated by tenure process, which has continued to be a source of controversy when examining the American education system. The controversy associated with tenure within higher education is attributable to the belief that the process generates lazy professionals who are interested in attending conferences and creating unreadable research (Mcpherson & Schapiro, n.d.). Such professionals do not focus on teaching and generating

U.S. Courts Until Bob Woodward Wrote His
Words: 1409 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

U.S. Courts Until Bob Woodward wrote his book, The Bretheren: Inside the Supreme Court (Woodward, 1996), the inner workings of the United States Supreme Court were considered off-limits. For nearly two hundred years no one had the courage to investigate how the Supreme Court operates on a day-to-day basis but Bob Woodward, one of the reporters who broke the Watergate scandal to the world, stepped forward and in doing so provided

Faculty Rights What Is Tenure
Words: 947 Length: 3 Document Type: Thesis

The court originally found that Fisher had a comparable worth to her make colleagues. In fact, she actually published more than they did (204-205). 4. Termination of Tenured Faculty For Cause The American Association of University Professors has recommended that universities extend adopt regulations for dismissing tenured faculty for "adequate cause," but leave the specifics up to the university (215). Tenured university professors can be relieved of their duty for cause

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now