Verified Document

Standards To Resolve Custody Disputes As Society Essay

Standards to Resolve Custody Disputes As society evolves, so do the laws and rules that govern it. Laws and the rules that go along with them are in a constant state of evolution because they may or may not be as pertinent in the present as they were in the past or the views and norms of society may have changed such that they have been made moot. This fact is true for all laws, but takes on a special significance with regard to family law. The modern family is not necessarily a husband, wife, two children, and a dog. It may be comprised of any number of different human components. Unfortunately, it sometimes becomes necessary for families to discontinue their social unit and a divorce becomes necessary. Under these circumstances, it becomes necessary to determine who will care for the children which resided within the family unit after the dissolution of the family unit. Deciding who shall care for the children becomes a matter for the law and as such, the decisions are based on rules. Over time, the rules for determining custody have changed as have families themselves. Different family courts have utilized various standards; however, the three standards of custody addressed here include the primary caretaker presumption, the best interest standard, and the approximation standard.

Many courts have found the primary caretaker standard to be helpful in determining with whom the child or children should reside. Though the term seems self evident, for the purposes here it shall be defined as presuming that, "only one parent -- the nurturing parent-should be given primary custody" (Franklin, 2010). Though the term does not seem to be gender specific, based on familial patterns in the current society, it would seem that the presumed primary caretaker will almost always be considered to be the mother of the child and not the father (Franklin, 2010).

Franklin further asserts that whichever parent was the primary breadwinner during...

In other words, in today's world if either the mother or the father was the designated breadwinner because of their ability to earn more money for the family, he or she would be punished by the primary caretaker rule regardless of their ability care for the child.
Franklin also adds that just because one parent spent more time with a child due to economic reasons, does not ensure that he or she is the best caregiver. On the contrary, the primary breadwinner may indeed be the superior parent (Franklin, 2012). Obviously, more consideration needs to be given to what is truly best for the specific child than simply awarding custody to the parent who spent the most time caring for the child prior to a divorce or breakup.

With the aforementioned in mind, the best interest standard now needs to be addressed. How can one possibly claim to know what is in the best interests of a child one may not have even met (Rohrbaugh, 2007)? Family courts have wrestled with this dilemma for years and many have instituted any number of checks and balances to address the issue. In fact the issue has even been addressed by law.

Though vague, the Uniform Marriage and Divorce Act of 1979 (UMDA) attempts to define the factors that define the best interests standard. Per Rohrbaugh, "Most states have adopted the definition of "Best Interest of the Child" contained in the & #8230;(UMDA), which includes five factors: 1. Parent or guardian's wishes re. custody, 2. Child's wishes re. custody, 3. Child's relationship with his/her parent(s), siblings, and other significant people, 4. Child's adjustment to home, school, and community, 5. Mental and physical health of all family members" ( Rohrbaugh, 2007). Unfortunately, even addressing all these factors will not give a…

Sources used in this document:
References

Franklin, R. (2010, July 8). Is 'Primary Caregiver' Preference in Child's Best Interests?

Retrieved November 28, 2012, from Fathers and Families

website:http://www.fathersandfamilies.org/2010/07/08/is-primary-caregiver-preference-

in-childs-best-interests/
http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/about-fathers/200807/should-child-custody-be-based-pre-divorce-share-caretaking
http://www.rohrbaughassociates.net/pdfs/bestforchild.pdf
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Conflict Resolution History of the
Words: 4166 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

"Divorce mediation confronts one of the most difficult conflicts that exist on earth, the breakdown and ending of the intimate, complex marriage relationship." The desire of individuals to remove divorce from the adversarial legal arena is fundamental to the growth of conflict resolution options for couples leaving a marriage. There is nothing more frightening than change, especially when the emotional stakes of the outcome of such change are so

Domestic Abuse
Words: 4750 Length: 18 Document Type: Essay

Domestic Abuse The human services profession requires its members to be strong-willed, compassionate, energetic and empathetic. These skills are most in need when dealing with one of the most troublesome problems society faces today, domestic abuse. Domestic abuse has wide reaching effects, not only within the family construct, but in the large macrocosmic sense of society as well. Domestic abuse and its often vague and obscure symptoms provide the counselor or

Nike and Child Labor
Words: 5337 Length: 13 Document Type: Thesis

The Secretary of Labor shall provide by regulation or by order that the employment of employees between the ages of fourteen and sixteen years in occupations other than manufacturing and mining shall not be deemed to constitute oppressive child labor if and to the extent that the Secretary of Labor determines that such employment is confined to periods which will not interfere with their schooling and to conditions which

Legal Analysis of Adoption &
Words: 5867 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

Normally, efforts must be reasonable and diligent but not futile. The general grounds for termination of parental rights in all states are as follows. Abandonment is a prime case of abandonment can be established after six months of conscious disregard of any form of parental obligations by a parent, including support, maintenance, love and care. The conduct must be intentional and normally must involve a lack of support plus

Criminal Justice Process Considerable Attention
Words: 5190 Length: 14 Document Type: Essay

Does the criminal justice system discriminate? Provide support your position with reference to the various components of the process, and give an explanation for either why the system discriminates, or why it appears to discriminate. Yes, the criminal justice system discriminates. African-American males are overrepresented in every part of the criminal process, though there has been no good evidence to show that they actually engage in criminal behavior at rates

Appellant Brief - Prisoners' First
Words: 3496 Length: 13 Document Type: Term Paper

M. Lin's release from MCF has had the effect of rendering his lawsuit moot. In this case, M. Lin was incarcerated at the time the lawsuit was filed, but not at the time it is being decided. Thus, M. Lin's cause of action fails on the issue of mootness. Additionally, of the six members whom were denied visitation privileges, five of them have had sons which whom were formerly

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now