Stand Your Ground Law
'Stand your ground' laws
To inform
tand your ground' laws are extremely controversial pieces of legislation.
Attention-getter: 'A man's home is his castle.' How often have we heard this phrase? This concept is at the foundation of the right to defend yourself by using deadly force against an intruder who invades your home. However, recent laws have expanded the 'castle doctrine' and other, existing self-defense laws. Many of these new laws are called 'stand your ground' laws, the most liberal of which exists in Florida.
It is important to gain a historical perspective on 'stand your ground' laws to understand the controversy
tand your ground' laws are extremely polarizing pieces of legislation.
Credibility statement:
My interest in this topic arose during the George Zimmerman murder trial, in which Zimmerman (a member of a neighborhood watch) was accused of killing an unarmed teenager named Trayvon Martin.
Zimmerman used Florida's 'stand your ground' law as his defense.
E. Preview of main points.
1. First, I will discuss the history of 'stand your ground' laws.
2. Second, I will address both sides of the controversy regarding such laws, with specific reference to the Zimmerman case.
3. Finally, I will discuss additional example cases in Florida and the application of 'stand your ground' in other states.
II. Body
A. History of 'stand your ground' laws
1. 'Stand your ground' laws climbed to the forefront of the nation's attention with the George Zimmerman trial.
a. Zimmerman, a neighborhood watch member in Florida, used the state's 'stand your ground' laws as his defense for shooting Trayvon Martin, an unarmed teenager.
b. According to NPR: "prior to the passage of the law, a citizen in Florida had the duty to retreat when confronted with lethal force or with deadly force or the perception of deadly force" (Block 2012).
d. "The common law principle of 'castle doctrine' says that individuals have the right to use reasonable force, including deadly force, to protect themselves against an intruder in their home" which supporters of such laws use to defend the concept of 'stand your ground' elsewhere, outside the home (Self-defense and 'stand your ground,' 2013, NCSL).
2. Today, Florida's state law reads: "a person who is not engaged in an unlawful activity and who is attacked in any other place where he or she has a right to be has no duty to retreat and has the right to stand his or her ground and meet force with force, including deadly force, if he or she reasonably believes it is necessary to do so to prevent death or great bodily harm to himself or herself or another or to prevent the commission of a forcible felony" (Self-defense and 'stand your ground,' 2013, NCSL).
Transition: Now that you know what the specifics of the Florida law states that was used in the Zimmerman defense, let me address the controversy behind the law.
B. The controversy behind the law
1. Even before the Zimmerman trial, the 'stand your ground' doctrine was controversial
a. The Florida law was supported by NRA activists (Block 2012).
b. However, even many police officers as well as civil libertarians were concerned about the 'real world' effects: "the police and prosecutors think that it basically gives carte blanche to shoot first and ask questions later" (Block 2012).
2. The Zimmerman trial further inflamed the controversy.
a. On February 26, 2012, Trayvon Martin was returning from a convenience store, after buying snacks. "Zimmerman, a neighborhood watch volunteer, spotted him and called police" (Botelho & Yan 2013).
a. Even after a 911 dispatcher told…
11. The issued rose in this case is unauthorized use of a company vehicle, which resulted in an accident. Prater was told to bring the truck home over the weekend to work on the body only. His boss never gave him permission to use the truck for any other purpose. Besides, the insurance on the truck would probably only pay for the accident if it occurred on company time. Prater
One of the additional oversights in the Proposed Consent Decree is that it does not address the sensitive matter of cell searches of two-person cells that are focused on one inmate. The cell search conducted by Officer Anderson and Sgt. Belker was conducted in an attempt to locate contraband cigarettes that had been sold by Joe Johnson; however, they were still able to search all of Jack Jones' materials. The
Stand your ground: Constitutionality 'Stand your ground' is not a new doctrine, according to the laws of the land. Its strongest support can be found in the case of Beard v. United States (1895). In the case of Beard, the court found that a "man assailed on his own grounds, without provocation, by a person armed with a deadly weapon and apparently seeking his life is not obliged to retreat,
For the law firms, a multi-point ethical program can address some of the shortcomings of their employees. Fraud is a unique ethical case, since there is no ethical dilemma, only outright criminality. To an extent, fraud is a situation where it is garbage in, garbage out. Thus, hiring becomes the first step in building a strong ethical program. This is especially true in an M&A division, where workers will be
Currently there are no federal laws governing employment contract of law enforcement, and in fact, law enforcement has yet to be professionalized or federalized in any way. This situation may change in the future as the quality of law enforcement in the United States is being increasingly called into question due to incidents like the one described in the sample scenario in which an officer has been repeatedly accused of
Another case illustrates how important proper investigation can be to the outcome of a case. Various authors cite the case of a fire in a home that killed two children. The children's mother had left them in the care of her boyfriend, who left them alone and left the residence. A small fire was seen burning outside the home after he left. The authors note, "The suspect was arrested and
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now