Verified Document

Soldiers Rhetorical Analysis: Chapter 5 Essay

When describing the incompetence of the Iraqis, Finkel chooses to cite the barrage of questions that occur in the mind of a typical soldier. For example, when the Iraqi security forces allow an EFP to explode that was clearly within their range of vision, Finkel rhetorically lists the queries likely to pop into a troop's mind: "Did they know the EFP [explosive formed penetrator] was there but not say anything because they were in partnership [with the insurgent]? Were they merely incompetent? Did they ever come running to help? No. Not ever. Not even once" (Finkel 85). Finkel's use of military terms like EFP (rather than simply say 'explosive' like a civilian might) shows his attempt to enter into the bitter, sarcastic mentality of a soldier. Instead of merely reporting that the Iraqis did nothing meaningful to protect their country, even though they were ostensibly being taught to do so by the American military, he enters into the mind, sentence by sentence, of a troop on the ground, and shows the thinking process of an American soldier. After the list of questions that imply that there is no way that the Iraqis could not have known about the EFP -- and if they did know, they were so incompetent as not to be worth saving -- they are also shown to be without pity and consideration for the dying American troops who are supposedly helping them. In the eyes of the American soldiers, the Iraqis are unsympathetic, even though the U.S. is supposedly on an officially humanitarian mission, now that is clear that there were no weapons of mass destruction in Iraq.

'Making the world safe for democracy'...

However, Americans are clearly embroiled in a country with ancient, tribal rivalries that even American leaders do not fully understand. The Iraqis and the Americans may have the tools of modern warfare, but so do their enemies. Of one Iraqi National Police battalion leader under American control: "He was a Sunni and most of his soldiers were Shiite, and for all he knew they were the ones sending him the text messages," prophesying his immanent demise (Finkel 85). The fact that death threats between ancient religious factions are now sent via text message is bitter testimony to the fact that while some things in the Middle East may change, other things stay the same.
Finkel's use of irony occasionally provokes mirthless chuckles in the reader, as he demonstrates the incompetence of both the Iraqi military and American intelligence. But ultimately, the author's use of irony conjures up a sense of sadness and pity in the heart of the reader for the good soldiers of the title who must risk their lives. The soldiers see the irony of their mission and its contradictions. Finkel takes the reader into the combatant's eyes and minds and forces him or her to see the world as a soldier. The troops are dedicated to their mission, but they also feel that it is doomed in many ways. "I like this president" says Kauzlarich, watching George Bush, as he eats dinner -- as ordinary soldiers bitterly mourn the loss of the lives of their friends (Finkel 105).

Works Cited

Finkel, David. The Good Soldiers. New York:…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Finkel, David. The Good Soldiers. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2009.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Burkian Analysis Brief Analysis of
Words: 2998 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Stephen Colbert's Speech at the White House Correspondents Dinner, 2006 In this speech comedian Stephen Colbert gives a hysterically funny account of the Bush administration and the White House Press Corps. President Bush and the member of the press are co-agents. Often he takes an idea of Bush's and carries it to its ridiculous conclusion and "gives people the truth, unfiltered by rational argument." The message seems to be that together

Creation Narrative Analysis of Genesis Myth or History or Myth and...
Words: 15782 Length: 50 Document Type: Term Paper

Creation Myth Analysis Case Study of the History of Biblical Creation Narratives What Is Myth? What Is History? Manetho Josephus Jeroboam Is Genesis 1:1-2:4 Myth? Is Genesis 1:1-2:4 History? Is Genesis 1:1-2:4 Both Myth and History? An Analysis of the Biblical Creation Narrative of Genesis 1:1-25 and Egypt's Possible Influence on the Historical Record God created the world in just six days, and rested on the seventh, but scholars have not rested at all over the millennia in their investigation of

Delimitations Today, Modern Business Systems
Words: 20751 Length: 75 Document Type: Research Proposal

A favorite target for conspiracists today as well as in the past, a group of European intellectuals created the Order of the Illuminati in May 1776, in Bavaria, Germany, under the leadership of Adam Weishaupt (Atkins, 2002). In this regard, Stewart (2002) reports that, "The 'great' conspiracy organized in the last half of the eighteenth century through the efforts of a number of secret societies that were striving for

Clinical Psychology
Words: 60005 Length: 200 Document Type: Dissertation

Clinical Psychology Dissertation - Dream Content as a Therapeutic Approach: Ego Gratification vs. Repressed Feelings An Abstract of a Dissertation Dream Content as a Therapeutic Approach: Ego Gratification vs. Repressed Feelings This study sets out to determine how dreams can be used in a therapeutic environment to discuss feelings from a dream, and how the therapist should engage the patient to discuss them to reveal the relevance of those feelings, in their present,

Comparison of Poetry
Words: 2363 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

life William Blake's poem the Lamb, defining it as the divinity of creation. Furthermore looking at Wildred Owen's poem In Dulce et Decorum Est, with an argument that its' message is one that contradicts the generally held beliefs that it is noble and heroic to die for one's country. The paper illustrates this further using quotes form the poem. All is fair in love and War: the lamb and the

Media Bias Knowledge Is Rarely
Words: 7231 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

The spin that often surrounds war, is fundamentally damaging even if it is intended as damage control for the nation as a whole, or at the very least the leaders of the nation. Public Belief It has been hinted at within this work that the old adage, the public does not necessarily believe what it hears, but it hears what it believes is at play when it comes to media. As

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now