Verified Document

Sinmed Shoulder Support Cushion For Head And Essay

¶ … Sinmed Shoulder Support Cushion for Head and Neck Immobilisation Brown's (2010) article entitled "Evaluation of a Sinmed Shoulder Support Cushion for Head and Neck Immobilisation," published in The Radiographer, investigates the efficacy in positioning for head and neck patients, with the Sinmed shoulder support cushion, as opposed to standard protocol in place at the Princess Alexandra Hospital Radiation Oncology Department. Understanding that the ability to accurately position a patient is critical to successfully delivering radiation therapy treatment, Brown notes that the hospital has been investigating optimal immobilisation techniques. The author discovered that after trialing the Sinmed shoulder support cushion, manufactured by CIVCO Medical Solutions, no significant differences were found in the positioning accuracy, from the standard protocol.

A small group of patients were trialed for this evaluation of the Sinmed shoulder support. Electronic portal imaging was used to asses the device, as well as a collation of observations that were made from treatment and planning staff at the hospital. As noted, no major differences were found to occur between the use of the Sinmed device and standard departmental protocol, for the accuracy of positioning of the patients. In fact, Brown (2010) notes that trends indicated that the Sinmed device actually decreased the positioning accuracy the staff achieved. Staff reported that the Sinmed device was difficult to use, and when used in daily practice resulted in problematic shell fitting. For these reasons, the hospital has not implemented this device department-wide, instead it has retained it's original protocol except for those patients with anatomical restrictions that could benefit from the device.

Critique of the Article:

The author does an moderately good job discussing Princess Alexandra Hospital's small trial...

Brown's (2010) title allows readers to know what the general topic of the article will be; however, it is a bit misleading in the scope of the evaluation. Reading just the title, the reader may be led to believe this will be a broader evaluation. Instead, the evaluation was conducted on just six patients at the hospital. A more appropriate title would have indicated the small trial size and noted the trial was limited to Princess Alexandra Hospital.
The abstract does a better job detailing the article. Brown (2010) gives the reader a brief explanation as to why accurate and consistent patient placement is important. He then continues to note that Princess Alexandra Hospital investigated the use of the Sinmed device for their radiation department. The method is very briefly described, although Brown notes that it is a small trial size, he could've been more specific with noting that there were only six patients in the trial, so the reader can truly appreciate the small scale of the trial. Results are also briefly described in the abstract, and the conclusion notes that the hospital has not implemented the Sinmed device, due to the results, except in the cases where it may be beneficial due to anatomical restrictions of the patient. In general, Brown's abstract was representative of the article's content; however, it could've provided a few more details regarding the trial scope.

Brown's (2010) introduction provides a clear and concise demonstration of the importance accurate patient positioning in the delivery of radiation therapy, particularly with the advent of Intensity Modulated Radiation Therapy (IMRT). Due to the complexity of the anatomy, as well as the proximity of tumors to critical and radiation sensitive anatomical structures, Brown further notes that accurate and consistent patient placement for patients with head and neck cancer is even more…

Sources used in this document:
References

Brown, E. (2010). Evaluation of a Sinmed shoulder support cushion for head and neck immobilisation. The Radiographer. 57 (3), p12-16.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Radiation Safety in Industrial Hygiene
Words: 3388 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Radiation Safety in Industrial Hygiene Nature has it that all living things depend on a certain type of radiation to survive. This is evident in many ways for instance we can see because our eyes sense and become aware of the radiation in the form of light; then there is infrared radiation that allows is to keep ourselves warm in the cold weather, radiation is used for cooking, whether it is

Radiation Protection Radiation Safety Manual
Words: 2384 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

It is carried out under the auspices of the Ministry of Health, acting through the Russian Federation Department of Sanitary and Epidemiological Surveillance (DSES). DSES is responsible for a wide range of areas of public health, including radiation protection." (Vincent, 1998) Quality Assurance Quality Assurance is statistically determined and tracked within each department when a radiation emitting device is in use. The Performance Improvement Team has overriding authority in this area

Radiation Three Types of Radiation Is the
Words: 567 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

Radiation Three Types of Radiation Radiation is the term given to the emission of various particles, typically from the nuclei of atoms (BCS 2011; Nave 2011). The universe has many different sources of radiation, and there are also different types of radiation depending on the source and, to a much greater degree, the exact particles that are involved in the radiation (Nave 2011). Understanding the different types of radiation is useful for

Radiation Therapy/Medical Dissymmetry My Program
Words: 329 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

My education consists of a Bachelors degree in Radiological Science, I also maintain a high grade point average (gpa), and pride myself on the care given to my study and work history. Although I already have a bachelors degree in the field of radiology, that is not enough. I wish to obtain a higher understanding of the subject matter, addition hands on experience, and the opportunity to use all the

Radiation Control with Types and Effects
Words: 1755 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

Radiation Radiation can be described as energy that is in the form of streams or waves of particles. Numerous types of radiation surround us. When most individuals hear the term radiation, the thing that comes to their mind is nuclear power, radioactivity, and atomic energy. Radiation, however, has several other forms. Visible light and sound are some familiar kinds of radiation. Other kinds of radiation include television and radio signals, infrared

Radiation Oncology the Basics Radiation
Words: 852 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

This technique is not as effective as a primary method of treating cancer Side Effects of Radiotherapy Fatigue, changes to the skin, and loss of appetite are all common side effects of radiation treatments. For treatments in the head and neck region, saliva production is also often inhibited, exacerbating appetite issues Loss of appetite also contributes to fatigue, and doctors recommend eating small meals more frequently as well as taking frequent short

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now