Verified Document

Seeing Like A State The Book Review

The interests of land owners often clashes with the state in developed nations, where government collusion with large business conglomerates make decisions that are not in the best interests of those who pay property taxes. Those who pay property taxes also hail from too diverse a political landscape to reach any consensus that might benefit the whole community. Scott's argument can also be extended to the realm of genetic engineering of crops and the patenting of seeds. What science has offered is a potential disaster wrapped up as a gift. The state-level planning required to either embrace (as in the case of the United States and some developing nations) or reject (as in the case of most of Europe) genetically modified foods is the problem.

Part of the problem with poor state-level decision making is therefore political. In Chapter 4, Scott touches upon the hubris of urban planners and indeed all public administrators who undertake massive engineering projects. When combined with Scott's analysis of land use, the concept of high modernism and the high modernist city can provide blueprints for more effective urban planning. Likewise, in Chapter 2, "Cities, People, and Language," Scott touches upon the difference between hyper-planned cities and cities that grow organically.

One important question related to land use and the "nature and space" question is revealed in Chapter 8, "Taming Nature." Scott points out the temptation to be stymied by the failure...

Forgetting the importance of understanding radically different climate and soil conditions, the state-level decisions that put into motion a set of regulations and land-use policies are spurious. Such state-level decisions are made without the best interests of the people in mind. Moreover, the people in developing nations, especially those that work on the land, are often politically disenfranchised. The state-level decisions impacting land use in developing nations also carries colonial baggage with it. When a well-meaning NGO presents an economic stimulus package built around projected crop yields and supposed revenues from mono-culture agriculture, the government of a nation is likely to say yes. Even community leaders working closely with the land are unlikely to turn down the proposition of prospering the local economy and eradicating poverty. Theoretically, cash crops may eradicate poverty. In reality, they do not and in many cases have exacerbated the root causes of income disparity. Instead of imposing a worldview that disparages self-subsistence agriculture and the self-sustaining communities that practice it, a new worldview embraces diversity. In many parts of the developed world, such as in Western Europe, community economies are largely self-sustaining. These are the new governance models for the future.
Reference

Scott, J.C. (1998). Seeing Like a State.…

Sources used in this document:
Reference

Scott, J.C. (1998). Seeing Like a State. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Seeing Past Cynicism in Candide
Words: 918 Length: 3 Document Type: Book Review

Even in this moment of supreme individual stupidity and rigidity, which Voltaire plays up with brilliant sarcastic comedy, Pangloss attributes his continued optimism to the intellectual worship of Leibniz. This instance shows that men are generally not stupid individually, in Voltaire's view, but rather that they are dependent on others for this quality. Other examples of stupidity and other negative human qualities being obtained through association abound. In Paraguay, Candide

Seeing the Dome in Milan Was Perhaps
Words: 1001 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Seeing the Dome in Milan was perhaps the first experience that actually knocked me out. This was not a cathedral, at least not like the ones I had seen: it was a myriad of dreams, a swarm of statues, towers and sculptures, a tickle for the soul. I just sat and wondered for a moment and just let the entire imagery gently float over my physical self in an attempt

Seeing World Another Perspective. Half a Day
Words: 571 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Seeing World Another Perspective." "Half a Day" Naguib Mahfouz "Big Black Good Man" Richard Wright "A Very Old Man Enormous Wings" Gabriel Garcia Marquez. Particularities have always served as a tool for discrimination, given that the contemporary society has grown accustomed to treat people on account of their background and depending on the way that they look. Gabriel Garcia Marquez's 1955 short story "A Very Old Man With Enormous Wings"

Seeing Spirituality in Art
Words: 2066 Length: 6 Document Type: Creative Writing

Greek sculptures, 'Veiled and Masked Dancer' and 'Hermes and the Infant Dionysos' dating back to the art periods, and their connection to the realm of spirituality. Is art linked to spirituality in any special way? One might find a number of reasons to answer in the affirmative; there, indeed, appears to be some sort of profuse series of links among the two. Art has always occupied a central position in

State of Human Rights in the Arab World
Words: 3599 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Human Rights in the Arab World As stated by the "Universal Declaration of Human Rights" in the United Nations, Human rights has almost become one of the most important factors that decided the development of a country. To be able to promote economic growth and prosperity it is essential that a country controls its power of creativity and enterprise of its citizens, which would aid it to move into the

What Do State Do
Words: 779 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Max Weber defined state as "a human community that (successfully) claims the monopoly of the legitimate use of physical force within a given territory whether that legitimacy derives from charisma, tradition, or law" (Hokim 2012). Weber held that domination of people being ruled by a ruler is an unavoidable political fact. His vision for democracy in Germany was a political marketplace where charismatic rulers are elected by winning votes

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now