Scott, Joan W. "Gender: A Useful Category of Historical Analysis."
The American Historical Review, Vol. 91, No. 5. Dec., 1986. pp. 1053-1075.
The word 'gender' is often used by feminist scholars to dissociate the physical characteristics of the female sexualized body from the social constructions attached to such female bodies. However, gender is still often used as a synonym for women, even by historians who attempt to debunk sexual stereotypes. Also, within the academy gender has been used as a less critically threatening term to describe the analysis of female history, because the term implies the study of men as well as women, unlike the more polarizing and radical term "women's history" (Scott 1056). Conversely, but perhaps just as damagingly, the term gender has been used to describe matters that only pertain to the female sexual experience, such as childbirth, which can compartmentalize experiences like war that might not be constructed as female. Joan W. Scott believes that the term of gender must find a way to encompass race and class without stressing the sexual and material aspects of gender, as psychoanalytic and politically oriented theorists of patriarchy and Marxists have tended to do. Theories based in patriarchy (and also psychoanalysis) tend to reinforce the male/female separate spheres divide even while they seek to undo it, and women's oppression predates industrialism and class.
Scott's analysis is especially useful at the end of her essay, when she calls for understanding power not as a male vs. female war, but what she calls a diffuse and Foucault-like manner that sees gender as woven to a fabric of social relationships (1067). Scott clarifies how gender is culturally symbolic as well as involves normative symbols for the individual, as well highlights gender's function in social institutions and organizations and in specific historical contexts.
On one hand, Scott seems to ask a great deal of the word gender, but by doing so her essay performs a useful function, not simply for scholars, but for everyone who is a participant in our own society's web of meanings, for she highlights the pervasiveness of gender assumptions in daily life, their mutability, and quite often their invisibility.
It makes sense that the advanced and more inclusive study of a history of a group of disenfranchised individuals, such as women and/or men and women of color, would occur simultaneously with the rise in providing them a voice within their modern place in society. The fact that these individuals have not been traditionally explored within the realm of class, society, and politics does not mean that they are not
discloses to the reader something of what happened during the era under discussion. But it also reveals at least as much about the era in which the history was written. What is considered significant enough to mention, what events are seen as causative rather than incidental, who are the true villains - all of these things may change from one generation's historical account to that of the next, and
Women and Islam Do Muslim women really need saving? Strengths and weaknesses Between here and there: feminist solidarity and Afghan women. Strengths and weaknesses Do Muslim women really need saving? Anthropological reflections on cultural relativism and its others. Topic overview and framework The article deals with the topic of 'War on Terrorism', the war claimed to have been launched for liberating the Afghan women from Taliban and an argument with anthropological perspective to deconstruct the essentially flawed
Employee Satisfaction And Productivity employee satisfaction and productivity ASTRACT Employee satisfaction directly links to organizational excellence and/or productivity. Maybe… Maybe not… Researchers regularly debate exactly what components contributing to employee satisfaction and the company's and/or organization's productivity. Similarly, employers and employees do not typically agree on the reason/s an employee stays committed to a company or what factors contribute to an employee's satisfaction with the company. During the mixed-method case study, the researcher focuses
In album after album, women are referred to as *****es, hoes, gold diggers, and chickenheads, and this representation of women as sexual objects for men's use is a common trope within this genre (Crossley 2005). The sex act is openly portrayed as being about the body and the availability of the body, and the use of neuter pronouns heightens its alleged objectivity and divorces it from personal significance (Crossley
In addition, repeating ACSI can provide trend data (Hall, 2002, p. 23+), important to government agencies, but also to new industries. Hall notes that, "Besides the ability of the ACSI to maintain a pulse on customer satisfaction, the ACSI is an index, not just a survey. This means it groups all participants and provides an integrated score, or index" (2002, p. 23+). Schay et al. reported that the United States
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now