Rosie the Courtroom Dog
Should therapy dogs be allowed in the courtroom as support for victims?
Rosie the courtroom dog was cute, fuzzy -- and controversial. "Rosie is a golden retriever therapy dog who specializes in comforting people when they are under stress. Both prosecutors and defense lawyers have described her as adorable, though she has been known to slobber" (Glaberson 2011). An example of how Rosie was used can be seen in the trial of a rapist of a fourteen-year-old girl. The girl was able to hold Rosie and pet her while she testified. Advocates of 'Rosies' suggest that dogs can provide helpful emotional sustenance to vulnerable defendants, especially children, when they are struggling with uncomfortable memories. However, opponents of therapy dogs argue that they can unfairly slant the jury against a defendant simply by their presence, regardless of the person's true guilt or innocence. "Defense lawyers argue that the dogs may unfairly sway jurors with their cuteness and the natural empathy they attract, whether a witness is telling the truth or not, and some prosecutors insist that the courtroom dogs can be a crucial comfort to those enduring the ordeal of testifying, especially children" (Glaberson 2011). This essay will present both sides of the story regarding the appropriateness of therapy dogs in the courtroom but will ultimately argue that the pressure to pass a law to permit these animals in the courtroom does not sufficiently protect defendant's rights.
Proponents of the use of therapy dogs point out that service dogs have long been allowed in the courtroom. No one argues that a guide dog for the blind or a service dog for a disabled person is so cute and cuddly they make it impossible to give the person a fair trial. Not all service dogs help people with obvious disabilities. Some assist people with epilepsy or provide emotional comfort to persons with agoraphobia or autism. Allowing a dog to act as an emotional support for a person in the courtroom is just a natural extension of this function. When the judge presiding at the trial of the rapist of the young teenage girl ruled in favor of allowing the therapy dog to be present, his rationale...
" Haddon's novel illustrates this characteristic of autistic families more clearly than any other of his themes and it is this that makes his work significant. Library and Information Resource Net. "Autism and Brain's Immune System Linked." AORN Journal, Feb 2005 v81 i2 p341 (1). Ozonoff, Sally and Geraldine Dawson. A Parent's Guide to Asperger Syndrome and High-Functioning Autism. New York: Guilford Press, 2002. (p27-28). Haddon, Mark. The Curious Incident of the Dog
The dog may lose consciousness and fall to the ground. There may also be teeth gnashing, frantic thrashing of limbs, excessive drooling, vocalizing, paddling of feet, uncontrollable urination and defecation. The Post Ictus is the stage after the seizure when the dog may pace endlessly, appear blind and deaf and eat or drink excessively. When a dog first experiences a seizure, it is essential to rule out causes other than
An average of $11 is the half-day rate. This is the rate for simple services and does not include additional services such as grooming, vet care, or training. The pricing landscape of the competition is largely homogeneous and is relatively price sensitive. Differentiation in the market will not be likely to be achieved through price differentiation. There Product Differentiation Many doggy daycare centers in the area offer grooming and access
Dogs of March by Ernest Hebert Hebert tries hard, I think, to depict the lives of the native rural denizens -- the Elmans and their friends -- as realistically as possible. What are the characteristics of their lives? What are their values, especially their attitude toward their land and nature? How do you think we are supposed to feel about them -- sympathetic? Are they romanticized in any ways? What
Dogs Verses Cats Dogs and cats are the two most common animals among pet owners. Each provides unconditional love as well as health and emotional benefits for the owners and each are fairly equal regarding responsibility and care, however, dogs and cats each have unique qualities. There are numerous benefits to pet ownership, whether one owns a dog or a cat. It is reported that pet owners live longer and healthier lives
Dog Training Training a dog requires proper planning and execution of the training methods so as to reinforce and encourage repetition. Proper training calls for the creation of a desire by the dog to please and seek positive attention and feedback from its handler. For a well behaved and trained dog, proper behavior adjustment and obedient command training are needful. This training starts with the sit command and training. The sit
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now