Verified Document

Roanoke The Fact That Author Book Review

In fact most of the Preface consists of questions that are editorially legitimate ("Why did John White take his colonists to Roanoke, and not to Chesapeake Bay as planned?" And "…If the Powhatan didn't kill them, then where were the Lost Colonists?"), and they cry out for answers, which the author attempts to provide throughout the book. What can be said about the substance -- if not the style -- of Miller's narrative is that she is certainly thorough. Her training as an anthropologist comes through very plainly when she takes several pages to show she has done the research on all the characters in this book. As to John White, and why his name isn't mentioned other than in an "…anonymous 1585 ship's log," Miller takes great pains to explain why there would be no record of him even being on board. When she builds a case against a character, for example Fernandez, the pilot of the ship that brought the settlers to Roanoke, she spares not the tiniest tidbit of knowledge in attempting to fully present his purposes, his attitudes, his actions and the possible ramifications of all he does in the context of this voyage. Why did Fernandez not tell the colonists about the poison fruit, since he knew full well it was harmful? Did he tell them it was okay, and that explains why they didn't just take a tiny sample of one piece of fruit, but in fact they all munched down and got sick?

It's Miller's detailed accounts of what certain characters did or did not do that leads the reader to the potential answer for the myriad riddles in the complicated plot lines.

My Reaction to the Book

I have always enjoyed reading the history of the discovery, the settlement, the challenges of the early settlers of North America -- and how as the country grew and became independent, the people carved out a culture for themselves. And so this book is interesting and even fascinating from the point-of-view of an author / anthropologist who is attempting to find truth among the rubble of old historical documents,...

Already I have mentioned that the narrative isn't always smooth, but in the context of a professional anthropologist digging through history to find the truth, this book is very interesting and valuable.
Her case against Walsingham is brilliant. The documented history of this man's skullduggery is so competently expressed by Miller that an alert reader cannot help but link him to the demise of those 116 men, women and children. Clearly there is far more available documented evidence in British history books and letters than there is vis-a-vis the actual Roanoke episode, hence Miller's ability to track down Walsingham's likely involvement in this nefarious matter. I was struck with the dreadful and depressing vision of starving people on an island, where they had been left, apparently deliberately, to die -- and with obscure power struggles in distant England that could be linked to the pathos experienced on Roanoke Island.

In conclusion, this paper has criticized the technical flaws in Miller's book, but there is much to praise as well. The details that help explain why characters like Fernandez and Walsingham behaved as they did, the power struggle in England and Walsingham's cutthroat behaviors within that milieu, are very well presented. Even the fictional recreations of how the settlers probably responded and behaved when White's boat sailed away ("Birds pass quietly overhead, adrift on the breeze, as a cold horror descends on those who wait…" [261]) work well for Miller. Her thoroughness alone deserves great credit, but she has gone well beyond just being thorough. When she challenges the theories of other authors that have gone before her (but didn't have anthological background she had) she is not vicious, just editorially crisp. One can tell she put her heart and soul into this research, and the pride she feels as a result shows through.

Works Cited

Miller, Lee. Roanoke: Solving the Mystery of the Lost Colony. New York: Arcade Publishing,

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Miller, Lee. Roanoke: Solving the Mystery of the Lost Colony. New York: Arcade Publishing,
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Colonial America -- Issues and
Words: 1949 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Because under the first Navigation Act" all American exports had to pass through British ports, and other foreign traders were not allowed to come into American ports, the higher price of imports hurt most American consumers and American businesses. On page 16 Newton quotes from a book by Jeremy Atack and Peter Passell: "Americans paid higher prices and earned smaller incomes than would have been the case if they had

Illegal Immigrants in the U.S.
Words: 2196 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

So who is an American and what an America can or cannot do are questions which are critical to the issue of legalizing immigrants. Does being an American mean you cannot show allegiance to any other country? The images of people raising and waving Mexican flag had enraged many but it need not have. It should be accepted that people who come from different countries would forever hold in their

Fiction "The Fall of the House of
Words: 2721 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Fiction "The Fall of The House of Usher" is a very interesting story. It talks of a man who received a letter from his friend Roderick Usher asking him to visit. The letter talks of the torture and torment Roderick was going through and is a plea for help. In the letter, Roderick explains his distress over his mental illness and the state that he is suffering from. The man was

Domestic Terrorism Within the Armed Forces
Words: 2887 Length: 9 Document Type: Dissertation or Thesis complete

Terrorism and the Military (APA). Domestic Terrorism and the Military On Friday June 17th a member of the United States Marine Corps Reserve was arrested for trespassing on the grounds of Arlington National Cemetery. In the man's car, police found Al Qaeda literature. What this Ethiopian-born American citizen was doing, and why he had Al Qaeda literature in his car has yet to be determined, but with the recent wave of attacks

Current Event Analysis -- Apple's
Words: 556 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

The fact that iTunes is compatible across the entire spectrum of iPod/iTouch, and iPhone models has transformed Apple's business model by creating significant switching costs, further ensuring their market leadership. This has also created a defensible market position with suppliers and partners of all forms of digital content, from music and movies. Third, Apple's unique design strategies in smart phones have also been an effective deterrent against competitive entry into

China -- Not Necessarily a
Words: 4943 Length: 14 Document Type: Methodology Chapter

12). Six weeks after that public relations disaster for RC2 Toys, other toy company, Fisher-Price, was obliged to recall "nearly 1 million of its most popular character toys, also because of lead paint," Field continues. Not long after those embarrassing recalls, Mattel and Fisher-Price announced "three more recalls from China" (Field, 12). When an adult item is recalled, it doesn't make as big a negative splash as when items for

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now