Psychology In the year 2005, United States experience one of the biggest, deadliest and costly hurricanes of that period. The hurricane was named Hurricane Katrina; it cost loss of lives, property and flooding across different states. The emergency situation had to be dealt with immediately and strategies to do so had to be all rounded. This is because those affected were either directly involved or witnessed the occurrence. This discussion is aimed and analyzing the victims of the emergency following two approaches that is humanistic and behavioral while comparing and contrasting their effectiveness.

How do therapists using each of these perspectives view the client and client's problem?

Behavioral approach is concerned with theoretical and measurable aspects of human behavior. Human behavior can either be learnt or unlearnt depending on whether they are acceptable on a social and cultural basis. Humanistic approach in the other hand is concerned with individual responses to stimulants provided by therapists that are limited by psychodynamic theories that interfere with results that could provide answers to the real meaning of healthy growth and behavior. Behavioral responses of victims of Hurricane Katrina include antisocial behaviors, reluctance to abandon property, non-communication, withdrawal, erratic movements, and startled responses, changes in speech patterns, impulsivity and pacing. Humanistic responses of the victims include expressed feelings of unreality, denial that the situation has taken place, hopelessness, hostility, anger and feelings of guilt Sue & Sue, 2008.

Using the two approaches as defined above, therapists have different perspectives about the client and the problem they are going through. Hurricane Katrina presented wide problems where victims and witnesses were greatly traumatized and therapists had to find ways to help them deal with their problems. The two approaches are aimed at alleviating psychological suffering depending on the perception of the therapist using developed after symptoms of the patient have been analyzed. This triggers the therapist to decide which approach to focus on amongst the two or even employ both.

It is important to mention the consequences of traumatic stress which include triggering disease, paves way for mental disorders, and destroys relationships between families and friends and results to substance abuse. Using the two approaches to mitigate the psychological stress brought about by the intense hurricane will have a positive effect on the victims, beyond this; media can also be used to offer more timely and practical information to mitigate ongoing emotional suffering. The difference in the two approaches is the manner in which the therapists handle the patients. While using the behavioral approach, techniques employed will focus on behavior change without background information of how the problem came about and any further indulgence trying to find the source of the complexity. In other words, the therapist concentrates on the individual and his current surrounding in order to identify factors responsible for his/her behavior followed by manipulation of the troubling environment to alleviate the difficulty Sue & Sue, 2008.
Therapist attempt to enhance desirable behavior and ensure they are promptly rewarded while the undesirable ones are punished so as to avoid them. Humanistic approach involves the therapist's investigation of individual perception of oneself during the traumatic stress and their willingness to accept and recognize growth, responsibilities and self-direction. The method offers an understanding and non-judgmental experience for the victims to be optimistic, recognize their strengths and strategies to overcome their weaknesses.

How would the process of therapy be different?

What is your overall comment about how these approaches compare in your chosen event?

In the event of the emergency situation that hurricane Katrina presented, humanistic approach was to be intensely employed compared to behavioral approach because of the nature of the victims. This situation…