Verified Document

Preservation Of Historic Structures Versus New Development Essay

¶ … preservation of historic properties in urban centers and smaller communities alike has become a political issue. On the one hand, preservation potentially stymies new developments that might be beneficial to the future growth and health of the community. New development can offer greater diversity of housing options and possibly also enable urban growth by replacing older, smaller, and outmoded structures with larger, more efficient, and more flexible live/work spaces. On the other hand, demolishing historic structures frequently results in what Allen (2014) calls "Shanghaization," or the loss of valuable cultural material in favor of quick profit draws. Overly eager development that ignores any appeal to historicity destroys irreplaceable character, aesthetics, and culture. Ideally, cities strike balances between preservation and new development. The most successful cities are those that adapt to change while recognizing the of preservation. Selective preservation can take place when visionary teams replace tendentious bickering with progressive ideals based on what has worked in other cities. Because it is impossible to please all voices, there will be some casualties to new development and also some new development casualties. Using the Miami area as an example, it is obvious that some neighborhoods...

The Miami Beach Historic Preservation Board has for years overseen the development of its city, with a keen eye on the structures that set the community apart from others. By carefully renovating low-rise hotels throughout Miami Beach, while also welcoming new developments throughout the city, Miami Beach has emerged as an exemplar in how to please both preservationists and developers who would have opted to tear down all old structures. Because the Art Deco architecture is one of the primary draws of Miami Beach, preserving historic structures takes on an importance rarely seen in the United States. Tourism money is no small consideration, especially on Miami Beach, which depends almost exclusively on money coming in from short-term and long-term visitors drawn to the unique environment.
Other areas of Miami-Dade County are not faring as well in terms of balancing new development with historic preservation. Heated debates about the Bay Harbor Islands historic structures seem overwrought, with no visionary voices emerging from the fray. Many of the low-rise Miami Modern (MiMo) structures have been slated for demolition to make way for new high-rises, something that many view as inevitable as well as essential. Yet to demolish MiMo…

Sources used in this document:
References

Allen, M.R. (2014). No, historic preservation does not inhibit urban growth. Next City. Retrieved online: https://nextcity.org/daily/entry/the-myth-that-historic-preservation-inhibits-urban-growth
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Egypt Is Going to Take
Words: 9929 Length: 36 Document Type: Dissertation

The source of the current crisis can be traced to 1998 when an initial agreement was reached on a plan of action and policy guidelines to establish the Nile Basin Initiative at the 2nd Nile Technical Advisory Committee meeting held in Arusha. A few months later, the Nile Basin Initiative (NBI) was officially launched at an extraordinary meeting of the Nile Basin Council of Ministers, in Dar es Salaam,

Transformations in Urban Planning
Words: 2350 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

Urban Planning and Historic Preservation of Landmarks In recent years, the preservation of history has continued to develop and some say has matured. Historical preservation now assumes a real part in how property development takes place in communities throughout the country. The National Historic Preservation Act and other preservation statutes have a strong impact not only on how the government deals with its own undertakings, but also on how elected officers

Internationalization of Branding in the Retail Industry
Words: 16085 Length: 60 Document Type: Term Paper

The main focus of the 1980s regarding brands focused on a trend in takeovers, enabling successful brands to become extremely valuable on the open market. Even very early on, a value associated with a brand large was viewed in part as more important than the product itself. Early research indicates that many thought the only way to have a successful brand was to buy one. Many felt that the

U.S. Economic Downturn Has Made Many States
Words: 5798 Length: 15 Document Type: Thesis

U.S. economic downturn has made many states in the United States to implement strategies to boost economic developments of their respective states using different economic incentives to attract investors. Recognizing the needs to be competitive nationally and globally, New Jersey legislative house has sponsored the "New Jersey Economic Opportunity Act II of 2013" with the aim of fostering an economic development in the state. The goal of Economic Opportunity

Trade Between China and the United States
Words: 2499 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Trade Between China and the United States This paper discusses some theories about international trade, and why countries trade with one another. The first trade theory that warrants discussion is specialization, something that Adam Smith touched on. He used the analogy of specific professional to illustrate this theory -- nations do what they are best at. A quick look at the relationship between the U.S. And China illustrates this quite well.

City of Norfolk VA 2008
Words: 4546 Length: 16 Document Type: Research Proposal

1-15). One may note that this amount is offset by a reduction in Federal Aid of $-2,596,200, a 29.4% drop (p. 1-15_. Educational expenses and operating the cities' public schools is by far the costliest budgetary item. This is followed by provision of police and fire services. Costliest Line Item per Department Department Amount Legislative Personnel Services Executive Personnel Services Constitutional Personnel Services Personnel Services Judicial Personnel Services Office of Elections Personnel Services General Management Personnel Services Non-Departmental Appropriations Employee Compensation Increases Community Development Personnel Services Parks, Recreation, and Cultural Personnel

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now