Verified Document

Political Status Of PR

Puerto Rico became a possession of the United States after the Spanish-American War in 1898, but has never been fully incorporated into the Union (Pantojas-Garcia, 2013). It later became a Commonwealth in 1952, a status it maintains to this day. The subject of the status of Puerto Rico has, since that time, been controversial. There have been multiple referendums on the subject, the latest in 2012, but as yet there has not been a change in the status of Puerto Rico. The 2012 referendum indicated a majority of Puerto Ricans want the status of their territory changed, with most preferring full statehood. Yet this number is not sufficient to break what is essentially a stalemate, and there are other options as yet on the table. This paper will look at the issue of the stalemate, its causes, and will explore the ideas of solutions. Analysis of History

Puerto Ricans are essentially faced with several options with respect to their future political status, ranging from the status quo to statehood to full-fledged independence. The four that have appeared on the official plebiscites (not all on the same one) are commonwealth, statehood, independence and a concept known as free association. Commonwealth is essentially the status quo vote, meaning that any change in the way that Puerto Rico is governed will have to come within this structure. The Commonwealth option was popular in 1967, when it garnered 60.1% of the vote, but in 1998 this option gained less than 1000 votes total, or 0.1% share, and it was removed entirely from the 2012 plebiscite (Pantojas-Garcia, 2013). On the last two ballots the question was split -- the first part asking if a change was desired, which is essentially creating a separate question for the Commonwealth option. Thus, blank ballots for the second question on the type preferred reflect a Commonwealth vote. In 1998, this was 50.3% of the vote, and in 2012 it was 26.5%. In 2012, this option more or less split the pro-Commonwealth vote between the status quo and the adapted idea of free association (Pantojas-Garcia, 2013).

Statehood as an option gained in popularity, and has been the option that has received the most votes in the last three plebiscites. The state option would provide a pathway for Puerto Rico to become the 51st state in the Union, with all of the rights and privileges therein. Full statehood would entail several changes over the existing structure, including greater tax obligations for Puerto Rican people, but greater...

Its peak vote was 4.4% in 1993 and full independence has never received even close to 100,000 votes. A plebiscite vote for full independence would not necessarily create a pathway for full independence and the issue has never been serious enough for the U.S. government to give the implementation of this much consideration. There is little to talk about with respect to the independence option.
The free association concept was only viable in the 2012 plebiscite. A sovereign free associated state is akin to a more autonomous commonwealth (Pantojas-Garcia, 2013). The idea received little support in 1998, but basically split the commonwealth or blank vote in 2012. Thus, half of the supporters of the status quo would prefer to have greater autonomy, but without full independence. On a practical level, this means keeping their U.S. passports, while still minimizing tax obligations, and having a stronger local government to run the island.

The Stalemate

Puerto Ricans are not interested in independence, but the split between the current status and statehood seems to have intensified recently. A change to statehood would represent a tradeoff between lower taxes under the current structure and greater political representation. There is an element of feeling that statehood would also represent a step backwards in distinctiveness, as currently Puerto Rico's status makes it unique. As a state, it would be one of 51 states, and therefore would lose some of its distinctiveness. In essence, Puerto Rico would be American first, Puerto Rican second, in contrast to the way it is viewed today. The public representation of Puerto Rican culture would change, along with identity for the island's people (Davilla, 1997). Cultural identity is one of the underlying currents of the stalemate.

That the stalemate is about cultural identity makes sense. The stalemate would be much easier to resolve…

Sources used in this document:
References

Davilla, A. (1997). Sponsored Identities: Cultural Politics in Puerto Rico. Temple University Press: Philadelphia.

Garrett, R. (2011). Political status of Puerto Rico: Options for Congress. Congressional Research Service. Retrieved November 18, 2014 from http://fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RL32933.pdf

Pantojas-Garcia, E. (2013). The Puerto Rico status question: Can the stalemate be broken? Caribbean Journal of International Relations & Diplomacy. Vol. 1 (2) 41-52.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

PR Econ Lopez, Aide and Thomlinson 2001
Words: 685 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

PR Econ Lopez, Aide and Thomlinson (2001) discuss how the shift towards urbanization and away from an agriculture-driven economy has affected Puerto Rico. The authors note that in the 1930s, 43% of the island's gross national product came from agricultural products. This has shifted such that by 1996 that figure was 1.2%. This is in line with most urban, developed economies, but to an extent there was no major industrialization of

Political Persona: Joseph Stalin Political
Words: 3921 Length: 12 Document Type: Research Paper

Domestically, Novosti disseminated information on life in other countries and on life in the Soviet Union. All of these institutional structures fell under the authority of the Party. The television system in the Soviet Union was centrally controlled through the State Committee for Tele- vision and Radio (Gostelradio), which coordinated the communication of the ideological message sent down from above. The reorganization and elevation of this committee to the all-union

Political Economy of Television It
Words: 2975 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

Among the various prime-time offerings there is a hospital drama, ER, which happens to be one of that network's longest-running dramas and focuses on an emergency room in an urban area. Furthermore, not only does ER feature many non-white cast members, but it portrays minorities in positions of power. It features African-American, Indian, Croatian, and lesbian doctors. In fact, one of the more recent storylines centered on an interracial

Status, and Power Mass Media
Words: 2561 Length: 8 Document Type: Thesis

Also, gay characters have slowly become more prominent both on TV and in the movies. In the 1990s, producers gave up on feeling that they had to challenge gender representations as models of masculinity and femininity had become less offensive and clearly defined. We can, for instance, refer to the hit sit-com Friends which presented three male characters, Ross, Chandler and Joey whose masculinity was placed within conventional models of

Political Philosophy
Words: 2784 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

inegalitarian systems in society. The writer explores how they operate and argues that they damage not only the ruled but the ruler. The writer uses several angles to argue this point and illustrate the ways the ruler is negatively impacted by having such a society under him or her. There were eight sources used to complete this paper. Throughout history societies have struggled to discover the most palatable way to

American Political Parties
Words: 2877 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

American Political Parties The Political Impact of Media Bias From 1962 to his retirement in 1981, Walter Cronkite led America through such pivotal events as the Kennedy assassination, the moon landing, the Vietnam War, and the Watergate scandal as the anchor on the CBS Evening News. Each night he would sign off his newscast with his signature sign line "And that's the way it is." As a result, he was identified by

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now