Verified Document

Plato The Failure Of Rationalism: Term Paper

and, through the scientific study of modern, cognitive science, the idea that 'I' am doing the thinking in a way that is separate from my body and that this can be rationally deducted, simply by thinking and without scientific experimentation would be confounded. However, those using empiricism as their main philosophical view of the world have also been able to twist the empiricism to use science's supposed rationalism and objectivity to justify tyranny of 'the best,' as in the case of eugenics, and the notion of 'survival of the fittest,' which suggests that the 'best' (morally, racially, and ethically) thrive and should be allowed to triumph over the 'weak.' In reality, Darwin's actual theory merely supports the idea that those best suited to an environment survive, not that survivors are innately better or superior creatures (a mutated moth that can blend in with a coal-blackened environment is not 'better' than the white moths who are now more apt to die than before, because they are more obvious to predators when before they could be camouflaged by foliage in a pre-industrial society). Both deductive and empirical rationalism are problematic when filtered through emotional and subjective human biases. Humans are invariably influenced by emotions, and often use rationalism or scientific empiricism to justify absolute rule, or prejudices of various kinds. In fact, in a kind of mirror-image of Platonic deductive rationalism, this zealous Social Darwinism suggested that 'the best' would naturally rule, according to the laws of science, not philosophy or religion.

In a climate that celebrated first religious rationalism, then scientific, empiricist rationalism, the philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche in "The Antichrist" celebrated what he called the death of God. He celebrated the inability to know anything 'certainly.' Now that science had shown that, rather than a moral intelligence, there was...

Without the moral glue of Christianity (which Nietzsche characterizes more in terms of myth, rather than Platonic rationalism like Descartes) or Aristotelian rationality, society would begin to devolve into a series of multiple, personal perspectives -- a kind of prediction of the current era of postmodernism, where a singular, uniting cultural ideal seems forever elusive and indeterminate. However, even Nietzsche forecast the development of an eventual 'superman' in a harsh, irrational world, while today it seems that multiplicity, rather than a singular, dominant philosophy or leader is the reality of the postmodern era.
Of course, it is easy to respond to Nietzsche that God is not dead -- look at the enthusiasm, if nothing else for the current Republican vice presidential candidate's evangelical beliefs in many pockets of America! But the divisions that characterize America -- of red and blue states and values, and the divides that characterize the globe in terms of East vs. West, developed vs. developing nations do reveal the fundamental weakness of Platonic rationalism and also extreme, scientific empiricism. These rational systems are constantly confronted with the messy irrationality of human beliefs and desires. The triumph of irrationality (or multiplicity rather than Nietzsche's prophesy of a superman) has not always lead to 'the best' succeeding, and seems to yield the triumph of many pockets of different clashing world views, some democratic, some autocratic, some biological and scientific, others hostile to science. But it is a better, more representative solution than the tyranny of rationalism and Social Darwinism, which are, in reality, the most irrational systems of governance of all.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Dialectic Method Plato's Dialectic Method
Words: 4256 Length: 15 Document Type: Essay

Plato conceived that there were two great causes of human corruption, viz., bad or ill-directed education, and the corrupt influence of the body on the soul. His ethical discussions, therefore, have for their object, the limiting of the desires, and the cure of the diseases produced by them in the soul; while his political discussions have for their immediate object, the laying down of right principles of education, and enforcing

Does the Fisher, Ury Model Work
Words: 29882 Length: 120 Document Type: Dissertation

Negotiation Skills A High Impact Negotiations Model: An Answer to the Limitations of the Fisher, Ury Model of Principled Negotiations This study aims to discover the ways in which blocked negotiations can be overcome by testing the Fisher, Ury model of principled negotiation against one of the researcher's own devising, crafted after studying thousands of negotiation trainees from over 100 multinational corporations on 5 continents. It attempts to discern universal applications of

Philosophy While There Is Plenty to Criticize
Words: 3858 Length: 12 Document Type: Essay

Philosophy While there is plenty to criticize in the work of Descartes, Locke, and Hume, one cannot justifiably claim that Jose Vasconcelos criticisms of traditional Western views on the nature of knowledge apply to these theorists if only because Vasconcelos' criticisms do not really apply to anything, as his criticisms are largely based on straw men. This is not to say that traditional Western views on the nature of knowledge should

Odyssey Homer's Odyssey and the
Words: 1437 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

For Aristotle, true freedom and liberty consists in ruling and being ruled in turn and not always insisting on fulfilling one's own personal desires at the cost of others. Thus, for Odysseus, true freedom can only come about when one is allowed to contribute to society for the betterment of everyone involved, a sure sign of moral correctness and rational thinking. In addition, Aristotle stressed the importance of justice and goodness,

Emmanuel Levinas Phenomenology Ethical Constructivism
Words: 5109 Length: 15 Document Type: Thesis

The metaphysical constructivists who are successful hardly take the truth of a substantive normative claim for granted. Transcendence In his phenomenological descriptions, Levinas used various accounts of transcendence to refer to the tradition and divergence of phenomenology in relation to Heidegger. His transcendences enacted the irreducible urge by oneself to get past the limitations of their social and physical states or conditions. Transcendence of the Other as described by Levinas is

Ancient Greek Beliefs of Afterlife
Words: 6046 Length: 22 Document Type: Research Paper

Life After Death: Afterlife Within the Realm of Ancient Greek Beliefs The question as to what happens after death is not fathomable within human reason. As such, it remains one of the biggest mysteries of life. The belief in life after death is what keeps the hopes of the human race intact even in the face of the tragedy of death. The concept 'afterlife' appears absurd in light of rational thought

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now