Verified Document

Philosophy - Utilitarianism & Abortion Term Paper

Therefore, the utilitarian would likely object on moral grounds to any late-term abortive procedure that would cause the fetus pain, even if the balance of objective moral good suggests that aborting a seriously defective fetus. Other than the issue of causing pain to the fetus, the utilitarian position would also consider the long-term subjective experience of living with a severe defect, which might also be quite painful on more than one level. With respect to concern for the defective fetus, the utilitarian would likely object to any procedure that caused pain to the fetus during the process; otherwise, the utilitarian would consider late-term abortion in this case, in relation to the harm-benefit analysis to others, provided that the procedure chosen would incorporate the moral need to anesthetize the fetus. Beyond the issue of the fetus' pain, the utilitarian would consider the emotional difficulty and economic harm to the mother and to her family associated with coping with severely handicapped child who required extensive medical care and lifelong care.

Since the implications of taking on this responsibility would severely impact the lives of everyone in the family indefinitely, the utilitarian analysis would likely justify a painless) abortion for the benefit of the family. Furthermore, the utilitarian would also consider the cost (and therefore, the harm) to society as a whole of sharing the responsibility for accommodating severely handicapped...

If the social cost of providing medical care and other necessary accommodations included significant expenditures of funds diverted from other socially beneficial uses for the benefit of many individuals, the utilitarian position would favor abortion, for this reason as well. The case involving rape is different in principle, primarily because it is harder but not impossible) to conceive of any benefit to the fetus. Whereas the defective fetus could be said to have been spared a difficult life, that is not necessarily the case in the rape situation, assuming the fetus is healthy. The utilitarian could imagine that being raised by a mother emotionally traumatized by the memory of rape might be something from which to spare the fetus, this requires a speculative stretch of the imagination. Assuming only that the issue of causing the fetus pain is either inapplicable (by virtue of the early stage of development at the time of consideration), or that the procedure could be accomplished in a humane (i.e. painless) manner, the utilitarian would likely support the woman's choice to abort the fetus. This is because the beneficial interest (or corresponding harm) associated with the dilemma include those experienced by the woman and her family, which outweighs the same interests of any single individual, including those of the unborn fetus. In a utilitarian analysis, there is no corresponding social cost as in the case of the handicapped child. However, the utilitarian might stretch the imagination again to consider the possibility that a child who is the product of rape might be more likely to follow a deviant or violent lifestyle to whatever extent his father's conduct was a reflection of genetic predisposition. In this regard, both Wertheimer and Sumner would likely support virtually any choice to abort (painlessly) on the basis of utilitarian concern for the mother's interests, those of her family, and those of society. Callahan would likely support any choice to abort based on fetal defect or peril to the well-being of the mother, but would likely oppose the callous use of abortion as retroactive birth control once a fetus has acquired sentience and/or viability.

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Philosophy
Words: 989 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Segment In Physics II Chapter Three, Aristotle outlines the term nature as a source or cause of being moved and of being at rest in which it belongs primarily. He contrasts two kinds of nature, and these are nature as matter and nature as a form or definition. Aristotle outlines four causes, including material, efficient, formal, and final. Material cause is delineated as that out of which a thing becomes and

Philosophy Analyzing Rembrandt the Following Paper Is
Words: 1152 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Philosophy Analyzing Rembrandt The following paper is a response to questions regarding the painting, "Aristotle with a Bust of Homer." The painting was painted by Rembrandt van Rijn in 1653. It is oil on canvas and access to the painting is gained by the website of the Metropolitan Museum of Art, physically located in New York City. The paper will first contextualize the painting, trying to situated in history and establish a historical

Utilitarianism and Categorical Imperatives a Comparison of
Words: 1076 Length: 4 Document Type: Thesis

Utilitarianism and Categorical Imperatives A Comparison of the Theories of Utilitarianism and Categorical Imperatives The principles of Utilitarianism and Categorical Imperatives contradict each other on many fronts. Both provide a rational for making moral decisions, both have benefits and flaws. A compelling argument can be made for each. From my perspective the principal's of Kant exemplify a more ethical way to conduct life. Utilitarianism Utilitarianism as a specific school of thought is generally credited

Utilitarianism Utilitarian Ethics Was First
Words: 1748 Length: 5 Document Type: Book Report

Today's laws consider human life the highest of all rights. Hence also the ethical difficulty relating to abortion. Although abortion might be the utilitarian course of action; the mother does not have the finances to support a baby: there is no husband; the baby will not have access to his or her basic rights as a person, the ethical viewpoint of many fundamentalists is that it simply cannot be

Lesson Plan Amp; Reflection I Didn't Know
Words: 857 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Lesson Plan Amp; Reflection I didn't know what state you are in so was unable to do state/district standards! Lesson Plan Age/Grade Range; Developmental Level(s): 7-8/2nd Grade; Below grade level Anticipated Lesson Duration: 45 Minutes Lesson Foundations Pre-assessment (including cognitive and noncognitive measures): All students are reading below grade level (5-7 months) as measured by standardized assessments and teacher observation Curricular Focus, Theme, or Subject Area: Reading: Fluency, word recognition, and comprehension State/District Standards: Learning Objectives: Students will develop

Branding New Service Dominant Logic
Words: 12522 Length: 50 Document Type: Dissertation

Branding in Service Markets Amp Aim And Objectives Themes for AMP Characteristics Composing Branding Concept Branding Evolution S-D Logic and Service Markets Branding Challenges in Service Markets Considerations for Effective Service Branding Categories and Themes Branding Theory Evolution S-D Logic and Service Markets Branding Challenges in Service Markets Considerations for Effective Service Branding Branding Concept Characteristics Characteristics Composing Branding Concept Sampling of Studies Reviewed Evolution of Branding Theory Evolution of Marketing Service-Brand-Relationship-Value Triangle Brand Identity, Position & Image Just as marketing increasingly influences most aspects of the consumer's lives, brands

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now