Verified Document

Philosophy If Freud, In His Psychoanalysis Theory, Term Paper

Philosophy If Freud, in his Psychoanalysis Theory, believes that each person - from infancy - represses impulses or desires, which its parents reject - and shuts these unwanted impulses out into the unconscious. These are what he calls repressed thoughts. He suggests that, since this process happens throughout life, that infant grows into adulthood, doing things out of the command of those repressed impulses and desires in the unconscious mind. He concludes that the only way a person with overwhelming repressed material can be cured is for an expert therapist to access his unconscious and bring these repressed material to his conscious awareness. And because it is not conscious, and therefore not within the conscious control of the person, he cannot be responsible for what he does from the irresistible command of his unconscious. This makes Freud a determinist in that he believes that human nature, rather than reason, determines a person's culpability in his willful acts.

But Sartre argues that what Freud claims as unconscious repression is only self-deception. He explains this by saying that the patient has the dormant awareness of what ails him. The only trouble is that he is afraid to face or admit that he knows it. Or he rejects such a truth. Sartre illustrates this, using the therapy situation itself: that the patient gets "cured" either by admitting or denying the therapist's analysis of the patient's condition by revealing and interpreting the latter's repressions. If the patient can confirm the therapist's analysis, Freud thinks that it is only because the patient has known the truth itself all along, for he cannot confirm something he has a greater hold of. And if he resists it, it can only be because he is aware of it but does not want to confront it. Either way, the awareness already lies in the patient...

But Sartre says otherwise: a person has always had an awareness of what happens to him and is therefore always responsible - and accountable - for his every deed, because it is conscious and free. As he says, man is condemned to be free. If Freud acquits or shields man from culpability - under the guise of the unconscious --, Sartre accuses man for every act he makes because he is free and responsible, but is merely denying or avoiding facing that freedom and that responsibility.
Sartre emphasizes that man can control what enters his mind rather than pretend to fall victim to outside stimuli, e.g., parental wishes, social conventions, etc. Those so-called "repressions" such as norms, self-image and worldview, are really optional, i.e., he does not have to accept or retain them. He is in full possession of his mind and will. This, he believes, man cando from infancy, and he is not excusing the person at any stage of his development.

Instead, Sartre believes that all that man needs is the courage to face the truth -- each truth in his life and he need not shut anything out of his "conscious" mind into the unconscious counterpart. In this case, he is responsible and accountable for every action he performs.

Freud is a psychic determinist, while Sartre holds that man is utterly and irreversibly free.

In the mind of Freud, man is more a victim than a controller of life. But in Sartre's, man can never be a victim and will always remain answerable even if he refuses to answer for his act.

To recap, Freud maintains that the…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Lavine, Thelma Z. From Socrates to Sartre: the Philosophic Quest. reissue edition.

Bantam Books, 1985

Stevenson, Leslie. SevenTheories of Human Nature. New York: Oxford University Press, second edition, 1987
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Sigmund Freud Psychoanalysis and the Self: Sigmund
Words: 1387 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Sigmund Freud Psychoanalysis and the Self: Sigmund Freud's Influence in 19th Century Philosophy and Science Nineteenth century thinking was characterized by the emergence of two revolutionary ideologies that influenced the course of human history for the succeeding centuries: Karl Marx's conflict theory and Sigmund Freud's method of psychoanalysis in psychology. Marx's analysis of the political economy of the capitalist system led to the development of the Socialist movement. Freud's psychoanalytical theory, meanwhile,

Freud Vs. Rogers the World
Words: 1698 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

This means that other aspects which could be affecting the mood of the individual (such as: a chemical imbalance) are overlooked. This is when the chances rise of some kind of misdiagnosis taking place. As a result, the strengths of this theory will provide everyone with a basic background. However, it cannot be applied to every situation involving patients. Instead, only select elements will offer a better understanding of

Freud Sigmund Freud, Who Is
Words: 1019 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

He focused on the progressive replacement of " erotogenic zones in the body by others. This early biological organism of sexuality first looks for oral gratification by sucking at its mother's breast, which later will be replaced by other objects. At first, the infant is not able to recognize the distinction between itself and the breast, but it soon begins to see its mother as its first external love

Freud and Jung
Words: 383 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

Freud and Jung How did Freud and Jung differ in their approach to personality? Initially, Freud and Jung agreed on their approach to personality, but later, Jung broke with Freud and developed his own independent ideas. Where they differed was in how much of a role sexuality played in analysis, and that is what finally split up the two psychiatrists. Jung went on to form his own brand of analysis -- "rational

Psychoanalysis According to Shultz and
Words: 4994 Length: 13 Document Type: Discussion Chapter

Erikson believed that having faith in others is key at this developmental stage. During this stage, the adolescent and/or young adult continually attempts to make the different aspects of oneself congruent (Friedman & Schustack, 2006). A person who successfully negotiates this stage has a clear understanding of who they are and all of the many facets of their personality. This person will have a clear identity and sense of

Freud: Dreams and the Unconscious
Words: 1353 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Freud believed that dreams had the function of providing latent content that could not be easily discovered by the individual. He believed that the best way for an individual to discover the underlying meaning of dreams was to ignore the natural reaction of censoring thoughts and allow oneself to focus on the associations that can be inferred from the dream. According to Freud, in order to interpret dreams one must

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now