Verified Document

Old Saying, "History Is Written Term Paper

However, though her gender remained constant, Bolton's position changed during her lifetime and she began writing histories of women and openly advocating the role of women in social change (Des Jardins, 17). Therefore, Bolton is an example of how secondary characteristics are more influential on how a historian presents history than gender is. Furthermore, in addition to being secondary to changeable characteristics, gender may also be secondary to other immutable characteristics. Throughout most of American history, race was a more unifying and important characteristic to most African-Americans than sex. After all, while men had de facto superiority over women, African-Americans were considered the legal property of whites for the greater part of American history. Therefore, an African-American man may be better qualified to write a history about the experience of African-American women than a white woman would be. Therefore, the writer's secondary characteristics are more important than gender.

While the first two examples presume an unintentional bias, one also has to understand that historians, just like other people, also exert intentional biases. There are "histories" out there that distort factual realities in order to forward some type of agenda. These histories include books that use selected facts to deny that the Holocaust occurred or use the fact that the first Blacks came to America willingly as indentured servants to support the idea that the institution of slavery was not as horrific as otherwise portrayed. The writers of these histories have agendas, and their writings are used to further those agendas. Women are not immune from this type of behavior. In fact, in the so-called gender wars, women make up a large part of the right, using the word "feminist" as an epitaph, while exercising...

In addition, this biased writing is nothing new. When speaking of the preeminent female historians of the last 1800 and early 1900's, Des Jardins stated that women were gaining prominence by writing collective biographies, which "allowed women to disseminate their prescriptions for national manhood to mass audiences as never before" (15). With this statement, Des Jardins introduces the idea that, by choosing the subjects of their histories, writers introduce personal bias into history.
While it is unimportant if "a" history is written by a man or a woman, it is important if all of history is written by one gender or another. The fact is, while secondary characteristics may be more important than an individual's gender, gender can help determine secondary characteristics. If history is written only by men, it is a logical conclusion that women's contributions are eventually going to be missing from history. From the evidence presented by Des Jardins, this already occurred once in American history (13-15). Likewise, if history is written only by one race, the contributions of other races, and the transgressions against them, are also going to disappear from history. In order to offer a complete vision of history, historians of every race, sex, and background need to contribute to it. In this way, it does matter whether or not men and women write history, not whether men or women write history. Her story, and his, and hers over there are all equally important to offering a complete understanding of American history.

Works Cited

Des Jardins, Julie. Women and the Historical Enterprise in America: Gender Race and the Politics of Memory, 1880-1945. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2003.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Des Jardins, Julie. Women and the Historical Enterprise in America: Gender Race and the Politics of Memory, 1880-1945. Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2003.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

History of Rock Music the
Words: 2074 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

In this aspect, the song is considered to be a masterpiece, because it keeps the listener guessing as to the underlying meaning. Once this takes place, is when you will see a number of interpretations about what the words and events mean. Longview Longview is the struggle of youth, where someone is facing the challenges of life and the common frustrations that many deal with growing up. A good example of

Sallust Is the Saying, "What
Words: 4295 Length: 15 Document Type: Thesis

In Bellum Iugurthinum he claimed that the state will gain more advantage from his otium than from the negotium of contemporary politicians SALLUST'S HISTORICAL WORKS Sallust wrote several historical works, but the two monographs that remain intact are the Bellum Catilinae and the Bellum Jugurthinum. There are also four speeches and two letters as well as approximately 500 parts of his Historiae that was published in five books. It is believed

Christ's Use of the Old Testament
Words: 2945 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Christian religion, the Old and New Testaments form a whole upon which its belief system is based. The transition between the Old and New Testaments resides in the person of Christ, who came to earth as the fulfillment of the Old Testament Messianic prophesy. This transition then occurs not only through the ultimate sacrifice of Christ at his death and resurrection, but also in his ministry during his lifetime. Christ

Creation Narrative Analysis of Genesis Myth or History or Myth and...
Words: 15782 Length: 50 Document Type: Term Paper

Creation Myth Analysis Case Study of the History of Biblical Creation Narratives What Is Myth? What Is History? Manetho Josephus Jeroboam Is Genesis 1:1-2:4 Myth? Is Genesis 1:1-2:4 History? Is Genesis 1:1-2:4 Both Myth and History? An Analysis of the Biblical Creation Narrative of Genesis 1:1-25 and Egypt's Possible Influence on the Historical Record God created the world in just six days, and rested on the seventh, but scholars have not rested at all over the millennia in their investigation of

Nature of Leadership Written and
Words: 1707 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Ethics in public administration is one of the most glaring of needs as without such ethics standards will not be met and many people will be unhappy with the work of the programs and/or administrations that govern and/or organize the resources around them. Though the old saying "you can't please everyone all the time," often comes into play in public administration making a bold effort to do so in

Older Sister "Why Are You
Words: 1294 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

" In this sense, the geisha business has nothing to do with the paid sex business and, as previously stated, may only come as geisha's personal choice. Geisha should be first viewed as an artist and performer, someone who trains the entire life into committing to artistic entertainment, much like kabuki artists, for example. However, given the ambiguous status often related to them, one can often wonder to what degree

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now