Verified Document

Nonprofit And For Profit Healthcare Organizations Non-Profit Essay

Nonprofit and for Profit Healthcare Organizations Non-Profit and for-Profit Healthcare Organizations

healthcare system is in shambles. As a source of intense debate, it is clear that it is failing to provide adequate health care for millions of individuals. Both for-profit and non-profit hospitals have their strengths and weaknesses, yet it is clear that mixing business with health care is a dangerous mix.

First, the locations of the two different types help showcase some of their primary differences. For profit tend to serve a more affluent community that can pay high premiums for the specialty care many offer at high prices. Often, for-profit hospitals run very much like on-profit or government run hospitals, yet it is their location that allows them to focus on a for-profit business strategy. According to the research, "they differentially locate in areas with relatively well-insured patients" (Horwitz, 2005). Meanwhile, nonprofit hospitals are often much more geared towards serving a less affluent population. Thus, these medical facilities are most often found in larger, more urban areas compared to for-profit hospital facilities. In fact, "two-thirds of all U.S. urban hospitals are non-profit, with the remainder split between for-profit and government ownership," (Horwitz, 2005). Urban hospitals are often non-profit, because they aim to try to offer lower costs of non-specialty types of services. From this perspective, "non-profit hospitals are often the intermediate type in terms of balancing profit seeking and serving the poor through service choices" (Horwitz, 2005).

More importantly, however, for-profit hospital facilities operate much a much different set of legal regulations compared to non-profit facilities. For-profit facilities are set up to generate a bottom line for investors and share holders. Thus, as well as paying for physicians and

As such, "for-profits may distribute accounting profits to shareholders, whereas government and nonprofit hospitals enjoy income and property tax exemptions" (Horwitz, 2005). For-profit hospitals take any benefits they may receive from production of care and put it into private hands. Non-profit locations, however, inject any surplus funds back into the operations and infrastructure of the hospital and its care services. Thus, non-profits are constantly reinvesting potential profits into their health services, while for-profit services often have to rely on future investments to reinvest money back into the organization.
Finally, different types of hospitals often specialize in different types of medical care. Here, the research suggests that "medical service offerings vary markedly by ownership, likely because hospital types adopt to prioritize goals differently," and evidence illustrates that "for-profits are more likely to respond to profitability than the other types when making supply" and operating decisions" (Horwitz, 2005). The nature of the profit situation helps direct what types of specialties a hospital will focus on. Often times, non-profit hospitals are geared towards providing cheaper and more generic types of services. On the other hand, for-profit institutions gravitate towards more expensive specialties and procedures. For example, "open heart surgery is relatively profitable," and as such is often a specialty seen within for-profit healthcare facilities (Horwitz, 2005). Non-profits focus on…

Sources used in this document:
References

Andre, Claire & Velasquez, Manuel. (1988). A healthy bottom line: Profits or people? Issues in Ethics, 1(4). Santa Clara University. Web. http://www.scu.edu/ethics/publications/iie/v1n4/healthy.html

Horwitz, Jill R. (2005). Making profits and providing care: Comparing nonprofit, for-profit, and government hospitals. Health Affairs, 24(3), 790-801.

Real Natural. (2012). Hospitals' unnecessary medical treatments exposed. Responsible Health News. Web. http://www.realnatural.org/hospitals-unnecessary-medical-treatments-exposed-are-for-profit-hospital-chains-the-problem/
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Nonprofit Vs. For-Profit Healthcare Organizations Healthcare Organizations,...
Words: 710 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Nonprofit vs. For-Profit Healthcare Organizations Healthcare organizations, both profit and non-profit, are designed to help people in need. However, sometimes that goal fails because of the notions of performance that are used in the private sector (i.e. for-profit). These are not the same as the notions used in the public sector (i.e. nonprofit) (Speckbacher, 2003). Private sector health care is based much more closely on economic theory than public sector health

Healthcare Organizations Hcos Healthcare Organizations -- Whether...
Words: 1908 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Healthcare Organizations (HCOs) Healthcare organizations -- whether they be for-profit or nonprofit -- are a vital component of American society, and as such need to be performing their duties and living up to their missions in order to provide the best healthcare services to the public that is possible. This essay covers many of the issues and points that are important to of any healthcare organization. What are the advantages and disadvantages

Change Management in Healthcare Organizations
Words: 16366 Length: 42 Document Type: Multiple Chapters

1.3. Summary of argument, Hypothesis The role of leadership styles and their applicability to the success or failure of mergers, acquisitions and alliances is the focus of this research. Any leadership study, to be relevant, must also focus on the needs of those served by the organizations studies. That is why in the proposed Change Management Equilibrium Model have customer-driven processes at their center or core. The focus of the research

Health Care Management the Financial Pressure Points
Words: 1629 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Health Care Management The financial pressure points faced by firms in the health care business can be determined by looking at the flow of funds diagram. In this diagram, the health care organization sits in the middle, and as a result acts almost as a conduit or intermediary between different entities. Funds come into the health care organization from third party payers, and go out to suppliers and employees. There are

Health Care Legislative Bill
Words: 1387 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Healthcare Legislative Bill The expanded and improved Medicare for all Acts The Expanded and Improved Medicare for All Act was introduced to the House of Representatives in 2009 and seeks to lobby for the implementation of a common single-payer health care system throughout the United States o0f America. The bill if enacted would require that all medical care costs be paid for automatically by the government instead of private insurances for the

How to Manage a Non Profit Health Care Organization
Words: 1534 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Non-Profit Healthcare Organization-A Comprehensive Study Introduction Catholic Health Initiatives (CHI) is a non-profit organization that consists of four separate national Catholic health systems that were combined under CHI over the past three decades. CHI offers assisted living services, nursing home services, memory care, rehabilitation care, hospital care, adult day care services and many other health care services around the nation. One example is the Madonna Manor in Northern Kentucky, which was founded

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now