Verified Document

Nation Building As Such Refers Term Paper

S. effort must follow certain guidelines in any such efforts, like for example, it must perforce be for the innate purpose of changing, or propping up the regime. It must also deploy large numbers of U.S. ground troops, and it must also involve these troops, as well as large numbers of civilians in the basic political administration of the country. (U.S. Involvement in Nation Building before Iraq) If all three of these criterions are met, then it can be termed as a nation building effort, as it happened in Germany after the World War II was concluded in May 1945, after which the victorious French and British and American and Soviet forces set about occupying particular zones in Germany, and in setting up military governments. (U.S. Involvement in Nation Building before Iraq) It was in 1947 that the multi-billion dollar 'Marshall Plan' was created, with the purpose of rebuilding and also strengthening the various democracies of Western Europe, and America took up the lead in transforming Germany from the dictatorship that it was, into a democracy. Therefore, the U.S.A., at the outset, outlawed the Nazi Party, and then disbanded the military and fired all the existing government officials. After this, a new German Police force was trained by America, to take over most law enforcement functions. (U.S. Involvement in Nation Building before Iraq) The very first National Elections in Germany took place in the year 1949, in the combined English, British and American occupied zones. This election in fact formed the 'Federal Republic of Germany', and since then, Germany has remained a strongly democratic nation. As far as Japan is concerned, after its surrender following the devastating atomic bombing of Hiroshima and Nagasaki in 1945, America was alone in occupying the nation and building it up into a democracy, and General Douglas MacArthur was the Supreme Commander of the reconstruction efforts being undertaken. (U.S. Involvement in Nation Building before Iraq) He wrote a new democratic Constitution, which the Japanese adopted in the year 1946, and one specific condition was that Japan must forfeit war forever. Democracy is now firmly rooted in Japan. (U.S. Involvement in Nation Building before Iraq)

In Afghanistan, following the Al Quaeda Terrorist attacks in September 11, 2001, on the World Trade Center in the United States of America, the United Nations gave a firm approval of the subsequent U.S. attacks on the Taliban Regime in Afghanistan. The reason may be that it was in fact the Taliban that had provided a refuge for the terrorists of the Osama bin Laden's Al Quaeda terrorist outfit that had launched the attacks. (U.S. Involvement in Nation Building before Iraq) Today, peacekeepers from the United Nations and from the NATO maintain peace and order in Kabul, the Capital city of Afghanistan, while at the same time, more than 10,000 numbers of U.S. troops are engaged in ferreting out members of the terrorist Al Quaeda outfit. It must be mentioned that even today, on account of the widespread and widely prevalent unrest and disorder and also violence in several parts of Afghanistan, the peace keeping and the nation building efforts have not taken off to a satisfying start as yet, and all efforts are being concentrated on maintaining law and order within the country. (U.S. Involvement in Nation Building before Iraq)

Both the Rand Report, as well as the Carnegie Report offers a similar opinion, that it is much too early to judge the effectiveness of the nation building efforts being undertaken by the United States of America, in Afghanistan. Both the Reports also state that in order for nation building efforts to be effective, there must be a suitable situation in that country, and among other conditions, some of the more important ones may be that, first and foremost, nothing at all can actually be achieved if the nation is not secure. (U.S. Involvement in Nation Building before Iraq) In other words, people must feel secure and confident enough about themselves to be able to go out and conduct their daily routines and lives and activities without fear. Therefore, it means that there must be more numbers of ground troops in the country. Secondly, if the nation building efforts were to be successful, then its peoples must be united, and possess a strong national identity, and it will do more harm than good if the entire nation were to be torn into several factions depending on ethnicity and other factors. (U.S. Involvement in Nation...

The Carnegie Report especially states that if an outsider were to take over these basic duties, then it would be completely unfavorable, and the outsider would inevitably be seen with hostile eyes. (U.S. Involvement in Nation Building before Iraq) If the country were to be economically developed, then it would be easier to bring in democracy. Otherwise, it would be much too difficult, as it is happening in Afghanistan, which is a completely economically under developed country. Thirdly, it would help to a great extent if the entire undertaking were to be based on multi-lateralism, because of the simple fact that it would be a less expensive affair on account of the involvement and the sharing of the expenses by other countries. (U.S. Involvement in Nation Building before Iraq)
The support of other neighboring nations would be guaranteed as well, and this would indeed "go a long way towards ensuring the success of the ongoing nation building efforts." (U.S. Involvement in Nation Building before Iraq) The Rand Report mentions that nothing can be achieved in one single day, and in this particular case, a time period of at the very least, five years, must be given to the United States, before it can be judged for the effectiveness of its nation building efforts in Afghanistan. Therefore, the more the level of efforts put in, and the more numbers of troops deployed, and the more amount of time spent on the efforts, the better would be its eventual success. (U.S. Involvement in Nation Building before Iraq)

In Afghanistan, as compared to what the U.S. forces were able to achieve in Somalia, in Kosovo, and in Bosnia, there is a clear 'regression', and perhaps the reason may be that the efforts are considerably less expensive than in the other nations. In Iraq, however, the challenges that the United States is facing today, are large and considerable, and according to the Rand Report, there are four valuable and extremely important lessons to be learnt form this particular experience. One is that it is a fact that democratic nation building will work, provided sufficient and adequate resources are offered and are available. (Nation Building, the Inescapable Responsibility of the World's only Super Power: Rand Review) However, it must also be remembered that such inputs may be very high, and that, as a result, they may not be available with ease. In a comparison with the numbers of troops that were used in a similar nation building exercise in other countries, and especially in Kosovo, and if the same levels of troop commitments that were used in Kosovo were to be used in Iraq as well, then it would mean that the numbers would be almost 500,000 U.S. troops and also coalition troops through the year of 2005. (Nation Building, the Inescapable Responsibility of the World's only Super Power: Rand Review)

In reality, in Iraq today, there are about 150,000 coalition troops deployed today. In addition, according to the Rand Report, to add to the military forces deployed in Iraq today, there must also be a significant number of international civil police in the country, and if today, the U.S.A. wished to achieve a similar level of civil police deployment in Iraq as it had in Kosovo, that is, about 5,000 police, then it would mean that in Iraq, there would have to be an immediate infusion of a minimum of about 53,000 international civil police officers, through 2005. (Nation Building, the Inescapable Responsibility of the World's only Super Power: Rand Review) In the same way, although it is a fact that it is indeed much too early to accurately predict the required levels of foreign aid for the United States to successfully rebuild and restructure Iraq, comparisons can be drawn form previous cases. (Nation Building, the Inescapable Responsibility of the World's only Super Power: Rand Review) For example, if the level of foreign aid that was provided in nation building efforts in Bosnia were to be given to the U.S.A. today in its ongoing efforts in Iraq, then it would mean that the country would eventually require about $36 Billion in aid from today through the entire year of 2005. Conversely, aid at the very same level of what had been given in the case of Afghanistan would…

Sources used in this document:
References

Clarke, Richard A. (21 November, 2004) "Book Review of 'What we owe Iraq', a War of Ideas"

The Washington Post Book World. Retrieved at http://www.epic-usa.org/Default.aspx?tabid=1628Accessed 10 November, 2005

Dobbins, James; McGinn, John. G; Crane, Keith; Jones, Seth. G; Lal, Rollie; Rathmell, Andrew;

Swanger, Rachel; Timilsina, Anga. (2003) "America's Role in Nation Building, from Germany to Iraq" Rand Corporation.
Review." Retrieved at http://www.rand.org/publications/randreview/issues/summer2003/nation4.html. Accessed 8 November, 2005
Nation Building" Wikipedia. Retrieved at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nation-buildingAccessed 8 November, 2005
President Addresses Nation discusses Iraq, War on Terror" (June, 2005) Retrieved at http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2005/06/20050628-7.html. Accessed 10 November, 2005
Retrieved at http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2003/03/20030306-8.html. Accessed 10 November, 2005
Reid, Robert. H. (8 November, 2005) "Suicide Bomber Kills four GIs in Iraq." Retrieved from http://www.guardian.co.uk/worldlatest/story/0,1280,-5399675,00.html. Accessed 10 November, 2005
US Involvement in Nation Building before Iraq" Retrieved at http://www.crf-usa.org/election_central/nation_building.htm. Accessed 8 November, 2005
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Building Coalitions
Words: 604 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Building Coalitions Early on in my career I recognized that building coalitions was a highly regarded quality within the federal government, and it became my goal to be respected by both civilian and military leaders. Throughout the course of my career, I have been able to build strong relationships with many outstanding colleagues and have been involved with successful actions at high levels of government which have allowed me ample opportunities

Nation-State Is the Nation-State the
Words: 582 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

In fact, the superficiality of nation-statehood is merely presumed. There is no concrete reason to question the organic nature of the nation-state. The nation-state emerged on the heels of the Enlightenment (Anderson). Historians cannot escape writing natural histories; writing natural histories is certainly preferable to penning unnatural histories. In Korea, "through the practice of state-sponsored rituals, the building of monuments, and the compilations of official histories, narratives about the collective

Building Strategy Partnership As the
Words: 1179 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

This was one of the factors that led to the foundation of the EU, as small, less powerful nations united in an effort to gain and hold power in a collective effort (Tyldesley). Therefore, in the "Five Lenses" and especially so in the case of EU, power is in essence the coin of the realm. In other words, without holding a superior position to others, class structure would not

Building a Secure Workflow Management
Words: 11534 Length: 35 Document Type: Research Proposal

Each onion router removes a layer of encryption to uncover routing instructions, and sends the message to the next router where this is repeated. This prevents these intermediary nodes from knowing the origin, destination, and contents of the message. 1.4. Lecture Survey. The predicted solution of the problems related to e-government administration depends on answering the following questions as brainstorming ideas to solve the problem and the features provided by the system

Nationalism / National Building Process
Words: 1865 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

So, Belgium chose a proportional representation system in 1899 in order to avoid a permanent confrontation between the two sides. The sub-societies of Belgium recognize and respect each other and they all agree on a principle of self-organization. The Belgian government is based on a principle of mutual recognition of the segments, and permanent compromises between them to spread over public goods (Lijpharrt, 1977). The federalization of the state was another

United Nations Was Conceived, the
Words: 1233 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

N. members. For the approval of a judge candidate for the International Court of Justice or a Charter amendment, a 2/3 majority of U.N. members is required, not just those that are present and voting. Part 5- Consensus Decision-Making When referring to the United Nations, consensus refers to a method of negotiation and a method of decision making. Under the rubric of U.N. voting, consensus means that the voting body will have

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now