Verified Document

Namely, Evaluating The Structure Of Term Paper

com discount brokerage firms. However, their relevance to the Schwab vs. Lynch scenario is poorly refined or applied. The data collected and presented by the authors, although extremely interesting, is based on secondary sources rather than primary, or at least not a blend of primary and secondary sources. In fact on page 196 and 197 the authors ignore the cardinal rule of best fit research practice by discussing a particular situation wherein the authors paraphrased certain statements made by the co-CEO of Charles Schwab without any cited reference whatsoever. Further, they even quoted the co-CEO without proper citation.

Particular attention must be given at this time to the authors' use of reference material. When one reviews the reference page it is interesting, and surprising, to note that not one citation mentions the words Charles Schwab or Merrill Lynch. One must ask, therefore, how valid is the material being presented by the authors with respect to their discussion of each brokerage house? Additionally, even the secondary sources upon which the authors base their research study are extremely outdated and possibly irrelevant due to mega technological changes in the it industry in the last five years. As a result, analysis of the Charles Schwab vs. Merrill Lynch it brokerage data scenario is extremely suspect as to reliability and validity. In other words,...

The most significant limitation, and as stated earlier, is in terms of the absence of any primary research data with respect to the early vs. late use of it systems at each respective brokerage house. Another limitation is the lack of information as to how the dot.com collapse affected each brokerage house and their use of improved it systems. Still another limitation is in the area of outsourcing of it services and the relationship this has to both Schwab and Lynch. A great deal of time was spent on discussing the impact of it outsourcing but little of the information was applied to Schwab and Merrill. Finally, Mahnke, Zcan, and Overby might well have reinforced their qualitative research through a more rigorous content analysis and historiography which is gained through fieldwork activities, namely reviewing text material direct from Charles Schwab and Merrill Lynch and from gathering historical evidence applicable to both brokerage houses.

Sources used in this document:
The data collected and presented by the authors, although extremely interesting, is based on secondary sources rather than primary, or at least not a blend of primary and secondary sources. In fact on page 196 and 197 the authors ignore the cardinal rule of best fit research practice by discussing a particular situation wherein the authors paraphrased certain statements made by the co-CEO of Charles Schwab without any cited reference whatsoever. Further, they even quoted the co-CEO without proper citation.

Particular attention must be given at this time to the authors' use of reference material. When one reviews the reference page it is interesting, and surprising, to note that not one citation mentions the words Charles Schwab or Merrill Lynch. One must ask, therefore, how valid is the material being presented by the authors with respect to their discussion of each brokerage house? Additionally, even the secondary sources upon which the authors base their research study are extremely outdated and possibly irrelevant due to mega technological changes in the it industry in the last five years. As a result, analysis of the Charles Schwab vs. Merrill Lynch it brokerage data scenario is extremely suspect as to reliability and validity. In other words, the overwhelming unanswered question is one of how authentic and accurate is the authors' data with respect to both brokerage houses when no part of the presentation was supported with primary research?

In conclusion, and for others reading the Mahnke, Zcan, and Overby (2006) research report, extreme caution must be exercised in terms of accepting the conclusions drawn and inferences made as there are serious limitations of the study. The most significant limitation, and as stated earlier, is in terms of the absence of any primary research data with respect to the early vs. late use of it systems at each respective brokerage house. Another limitation is the lack of information as to how the dot.com collapse affected each brokerage house and their use of improved it systems. Still another limitation is in the area of outsourcing of it services and the relationship this has to both Schwab and Lynch. A great deal of time was spent on discussing the impact of it outsourcing but little of the information was applied to Schwab and Merrill. Finally, Mahnke, Zcan, and Overby might well have reinforced their qualitative research through a more rigorous content analysis and historiography which is gained through fieldwork activities, namely reviewing text material direct from Charles Schwab and Merrill Lynch and from gathering historical evidence applicable to both brokerage houses.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Namely, Evaluating the Structure of
Words: 580 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

E., combination classes or multi-grade and single grade classes). Further, operationalizing the terms context and composition would have greatly aided the reader in interpreting the study's results. Study Purpose. Burns and Mason (2002) did follow best fit research practice protocol by stating the purpose of the study as that being to study student achievement with respect to the effects of class composition. However, this reviewer would have like to see more

Namely, Evaluating the Structure of the Research
Words: 1445 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

namely, evaluating the structure of the research upon which scientific conclusion are drawn. More specifically, the function of a research report (article) is to inform readers about the problem being investigated, the methods used to solve the problem, the results of the investigation, and the conclusions being inferred from the results. The printed manuscript is to inform the reader, as expeditiously as possible, what was done, the outcome of

Structure Organization Choosing. Provide Organization Chart Top
Words: 964 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

structure organization choosing. Provide organization chart top levels organization Word, Excel, a .pdf format preparing organizational chart. (20 marks). As part evaluation, assess appropriateness method departmentalization (20 marks), implications authority (20 marks) job design (20 marks). Organizational structure Wal-Mart is the largest retailer in the United States and it has even increased its presence within the international market place. Throughout the past recent years, when numerous economic agents went bankrupt or

ISP Market Changing Market Structures and Competitive
Words: 1076 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

ISP Market Changing market Structures and Competitive Forces in the Internet Service Provider (ISP) Industry The Internet went from being practically unheard of in the 1980s and early 1990s to being accessible in most of the homes and even on the phones of many people in the developed world just twenty years later. During that period of time, the industry of providing this access to consumers, the Internet Service Provider or ISP

Nursing Research Report the Structure of a
Words: 3179 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Nursing Research Report The structure of a research report is simple. It is almost the same as the structure of the research itself: the problem, the methodology, the results, the conclusions, and the interpretations. The purpose of the research report is to inform readers about the problem investigated, the methods used to solve the problem, the results of the investigation, and the conclusions inferred from the results (Polit & Beck, 2004).

Burke-Litwin Model Structure Burke-Litwin Describes Structure As
Words: 1545 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Burke-Litwin Model Structure Burke-Litwin describes structure as the arrangement of the functions, people responsibilities, authorities, communication and interactions in a way that supports the organization's mission, goals and strategy. National Presto Industries organizational structure type is product departmentalization. The business segments are aligned directly by the main products which are grouped in categories of Small Appliance and Housewares, Absorbent and Defense product lines (NPK:Seekingalpha, 2011). The first business segment is the Housewares and Small

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now